Light double-gluon hybrid states

G. Daylan Esmer, B. Barsbay, K. Azizi, H. Sundu, S. Türkmen · 2026

Read Light double-gluon hybrid states by G. Daylan Esmer, B. Barsbay, K. Azizi, H. Sundu, S. Türkmen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14368.txt.

Introduction

Esmer and co-authors compute light hybrid mesons made of a quark, an antiquark, and two gluons, using QCD sum rules. States with eight spin-parity-charge sets are covered, from 0++ to 1--. Currents built from light quark and gluon fields probe three flavor mixes, with strange quarks swapped in step by step. Quark and gluon condensates enter up to dimension twelve, which sharpens the mass and coupling estimates. Results can guide lab searches for these hybrid states and later decay work.

Catalog record

CREATORG. Daylan Esmer, B. Barsbay, K. Azizi, H. Sundu, S. Türkmen
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31664
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14368

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Light double-gluon hybrid states G. Daylan Esmer, B. Barsbay, K. Azizi, H. Sundu, S. Türkmen Abstract We investigate light hybrid mesons composed of a light quark-antiquark pair and two gluons within the framework of QCD sum rules. We focus on states with quantum numbers J PC = 0 + ⁣ + , 0 + ⁣ − , 0 − ⁣ + , 0 − ⁣ − J^{\mathrm{PC}}=0^{++},0^{+-},0^{-+},0^{--} and J PC = 1 + ⁣ + , 1 + ⁣ − , 1 − ⁣ + , 1 − ⁣ − J^{\mathrm{PC}}=1^{++},1^{+-},1^{-+},1^{--} . By employing various interpolating currents constructed from valence light quarks and gluon fields, we determine the masses and current couplings of the q ¯ ​ G ​ G ​ q \bar{q}GGq , q ¯ ​ G ​ G ​ s \bar{q}GGs , and s ¯ ​ G ​ G ​ s \bar{s}GGs hybrid configurations. Nonperturbative effects are incorporated through quark and gluon condensates up to dimension twelve in the operator product expansion, improving the reliability of the numerical predictions. The results presented here may provide useful input for future experimental searches for light hybrid mesons and can also serve as a basis for studies of their decay properties and interactions with other hadronic states. I Introduction In the conventional quark model ParticleDataGroup:2022pth ; Gell-Mann:1964ewy ; Zweig:1964jf , hadrons are described as mesons composed of quark–antiquark pairs ( q\bar{q} ) and baryons formed by three quarks ( qqq ). However, quantum chromodynamics (QCD), as the fundamental theory of the strong interaction, predicts a much richer hadron spectrum that extends beyond these conventional configurations. In particular, QCD allows for the existence of exotic hadronic states such as multiquark systems, hybrid mesons, and glueballs, in which the gluonic degrees of freedom play a crucial role in determining their internal dynamics and quantum structure. A hybrid meson is typically considered to be a bound state containing a quark–antiquark pair and an excited gluonic field ( \bar{q}Gq ). The explicit participation of the gluonic degree of freedom enables these states to exhibit quantum numbers that cannot be realized in ordinary mesons, for instance J^{\mathrm{PC}}=0^{--},0^{+-},1^{-+},2^{+-},3^{-+},4^{+-},... ParticleDataGroup:2020ssz . Among the observed light hybrid candidates are \pi_{1}(1400) IHEP-Brussels-LosAlamos-AnnecyLAPP:1988iqi , \pi_{1}(1600) E852:2001ikk and \pi_{1}(2015) E852:2004gpn with the exotic quantum number J^{PC}=1^{-+} . More recently, the isoscalar \eta_{1}(1855) has been reported by the BESIII Collaboration in the decay channel J/\psi\rightarrow\gamma\eta_{1}\rightarrow\gamma\eta\eta^{\prime} BESIII:2022riz ; BESIII:2022iwi . This state, with J^{PC}=1^{-+} , is regarded as the isoscalar partner of \pi_{1}(1600) and a likely member of the light hybrid nonet Chen:2022qpd ; Chen:2023ukh ; Chen:2022isv ; Qiu:2022ktc ; Shastry:2023ths ; Shastry:2022mhk . Recent progress in coupled-channel analyses has significantly clarified the long-standing ambiguity surrounding the \pi_{1}(1400) and \pi_{1}(1600) resonances, suggesting that existing experimental data can be adequately described by a single \pi_{1}(1600) state JPAC:2018zyd ; Kopf:2020yoa . Furthermore, lattice QCD studies of radially excited states have identified \pi_{1}(2015) as a promising candidate for the first excited hybrid meson, providing valuable insight into the structure of gluonic excitations Dudek:2010wm . The discovery of \eta_{1}(1855) has also opened new perspectives for understanding isoscalar hybrid configurations and the role of nonperturbative gluonic dynamics in hadron formation Chen:2022qpd ; Shastry:2022mhk ; Wan:2022xkx ; Dong:2022cuw ; Yan:2023vbh ; Yang:2022rck ; Qiu:2022ktc . Over the past decades, numerous theoretical investigations have been carried out on the \bar{q}Gq hybrid mesons using a variety of approaches, including flux-tube models Isgur:1984bm ; Isgur:1985vy ; Close:1994hc ; Barnes:1995hc ; Page:1998gz ; Burns:2006wz , the MIT bag model Barnes:1982tx ; Chanowitz:1982qj , lattice QCD Lacock:1996vy ; Lacock:1997an ; McNeile:1998cp ; Lacock:1998be ; Bernard:2003jd ; Hedditch:2005zf ; Dudek:2009qf ; Dudek:2010wm ; Dudek:2011tt ; Dudek:2011bn ; Dudek:2013yja and QCD sum rules Balitsky:1982ps ; Govaerts:1983ka ; Govaerts:1984hc ; Govaerts:1985fx ; Govaerts:1986pp ; Zhu:1998ki ; Jin:2002rw ; Qiao:2010zh ; Berg:2012gd ; Chen:2013zia ; Chen:2013pya ; Chen:2013eha ; Li:2021fwk ; Palameta:2017ols ; Palameta:2018yce ; Ho:2018cat ; Ho:2019org ; Chen:2022qpd ; Barsbay:2024vjt ; Esmer:2025xss ; Agaev:2025llz ; Agaev:2025mqe . A consistent outcome of these studies is the emergence of a characteristic supermultiplet structure. The lowest-lying hybrid configurations involve states with negative parity and positive charge conjugation in the scalar, axial, and tensor channels, together with a vector state carrying negative charge conjugation. In contrast, a higher-lying supermultiplet corresponds to states with positive parity combined with negative charge conjugation, predominantly within the scalar and tensor quantum-number channels HadronSpectrum:2012gic ; Chen:2013zia ; Meyer:2015eta ; Dudek:2013yja ; Dudek:2009qf ; Dudek:2010wm ; Dudek:2011tt ; Dudek:2011bn ; Wang:2023whb . Recently, theoretical attention has extended to hybrid configurations involving two valence gluons, often referred to as double-gluon or gluon-rich hybrids. In the light quark sector, Su et al. (2023) studied these states using QCD sum rules, predicting that the mass of the J^{PC}=2^{+-} double-gluon hybrid meson is approximately 2.26~\mathrm{GeV} for the \bar{q}GGq configuration, while the corresponding \bar{s}GGs state has a slightly larger mass of about 2.38~\mathrm{GeV} Su:2022fqr . Along similar lines, another QCD sum rule study investigated double-gluon hybrid states with exotic quantum numbers J^{PC}=1^{-+} and J^{PC}=3^{-+} . For the \bar{q}GGq configuration, the masses were found to be approximately 4.35~\mathrm{GeV} for J^{PC}=1^{-+} and 3.02~\mathrm{GeV} for J^{PC}=3^{-+} , while the corresponding \bar{s}GGs hybrid states were predicted to have masses of about 4.49~\mathrm{GeV} for J^{PC}=1^{-+} and 3.16~\mathrm{GeV} for J^{PC}=3^{-+} Su:2023jxb . These results further support the existence of double-gluon hybrid mesons over a broad mass range and highlight their relevance for exploring exotic QCD dynamics. In the heavy quark sector, Lian et al. (2024) revisited the masses of double-gluon hybrid mesons with exotic quantum numbers J^{PC}=1^{-+} and J^{PC}=2^{+-} in the framework of QCD sum rules. Their analysis predicts that the masses of these states lie in the ranges of 6.1-7.2 GeV and 6.3-6.4 GeV for the charmonium systems, and 13.7-14.3 GeV and 12.6-13.3 GeV for the bottomonium systems, respectively Lian:2024fsb . These heavy hybrid mesons are of particular interest for experimental searches at facilities such as Belle II, PANDA, Super-B, GlueX, and LHCb, where they could decay into pairs of charmed or bottom mesons, or into combinations of charmed/bottom and light mesons. The exploration of light double-gluon hybrid mesons provides an important opportunity to advance our understanding of nonperturbative QCD. In the light quark sector, the explicit inclusion of dynamical gluon degrees of freedom is expected to play a significant role in shaping the properties of hadronic states. Studies of such hybrid configurations can therefore offer valuable insight into color confinement, gluon self-interactions, and the emergence of exotic hadronic structures beyond the conventional quark model. This article is structured in the following from: In Sec. II , we investigate double-gluon hybrid mesons with various J^{PC} quantum numbers within the QCD sum rule formalism. By employing various interpolating currents constructed from valence light quarks and gluon fields, we determine the masses and current couplings of the \bar{q}GGq , \bar{q}GGs , and \bar{s}GGs hybrid configurations. Among the eight interpolating currents considered, four are found to vanish identically due to internal symmetry properties of the gluon fields. In Sec. III , we perform the numerical analysis of the remaining nonvanishing sum rules, with the results summarized and discussed in Sec. IV . II Spectroscopic Parameters The QCD sum rules for the parameters of the light double-gluon hybrid states \bar{q}GGq , \bar{q}GGs , and \bar{s}GGs are obtained from the analysis of

Read the complete text