On the Hausdorff dimension and singularities of the monopolist’s free boundary curve
Robert J. McCann, Lucas D. O’Brien, Cale Rankin · 2026
Read On the Hausdorff dimension and singularities of the monopolist’s free boundary curve by Robert J. McCann, Lucas D. O’Brien, Cale Rankin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14100.txt.
Introduction
McCann, O'Brien, and Rankin study the free boundary curve in the monopolist's pricing problem. The model seeks a convex function that minimizes a perturbed Dirichlet energy. Interest centers on the region where the minimizer is strictly convex. Outside the flat and zero parts, the authors show the free boundary is a continuous curve of Hausdorff dimension one. The region has density one half along that curve, with smooth behavior away from a sparse set of singular points.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Robert J. McCann, Lucas D. O’Brien, Cale Rankin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61706 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14100
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the Hausdorff dimension and singularities of the monopolist’s free boundary curve Thanks: MSC 2020: 35R35 Secondary: 35Q91 90B50 91A65 91B41 91B43 ∗ Robert McCann’s work was supported in part by the Canada Research Chairs program CRC-2020-00289 and Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada Discovery Grants RGPIN–2020–04162. Lucas O’Brien’s work was supported in part by a University of Toronto Excellence Award and by an internal fellowship from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology School of Science. Cale Rankin’s work was supported by grants DP220100067 & DE260100829 of the Australian Research Council. The authors are grateful to Shibing Chen, Alessio Figalli, Yi Ru-Ya Zhang, and Kelvin Shuangjian Zhang for fruitful exchanges. ©August 10, 2026 Robert J. McCann, Lucas D. O’Brien, Cale Rankin Abstract . The simplest genuinely multidimensional monopolist’s problem involves minimizing a linearly perturbed Dirichlet energy among nonnegative convex functions u u on an open domain X ⊂ [ 0 , ∞ ) 2 X\subset[0,\infty)^{2} . The geometry of the region of strict convexity Ω ⊂ X \Omega\subset X for the unique minimizer u u is of central interest. A relatively closed portion X 1 0 ⊂ X X_{1}^{0}\subset X of the domain is comprised of line segments starting and ending on ∂ X \partial X along which u u is affine. For convex polygons and potentially all domains X ⊂ 𝐑 2 X\subset{\mathbf{R}}^{2} , we build on results with Zhang to show that outside X 1 0 ∪ { u = 0 } X_{1}^{0}\cup\{u=0\} , the free boundary of Ω \Omega is a continuous curve of Hausdorff dimension one, and that Ω \Omega has density 1 / 2 1/2 along it (and is C loc α C^{\alpha}_{\mathrm{loc}} for all 0 < α < 1 0<\alpha<1 ), except perhaps at a discrete set of singular points. We do this by showing that much of the free boundary solves an obstacle problem whose endogenous obstacle is C 2 C^{2} . From a slightly stronger conclusion, we deduce the free boundary becomes locally C ∞ C^{\infty} outside a closed set whose relative interior is empty. In response to the circulation of the present manuscript, we received a concurrent but independent work of Chen, Figalli and Zhang who verify a strengthening sufficient for this partial regularity result; (they show in particular that α = 1 \alpha=1 and the discrete set mentioned above is empty). 1. Introduction The problem of identifying optimal strategies facing asymmetric information has a venerable history in economic theory, surveyed in Laffont and Martimort [ 22 ] and Basov [ 2 ] . The monopolist’s problem in the principal agent framework of Mussa and Rosen [ 31 ] serves as a paradigm in this regard: a monopolist wishes to price a line of products so as to optimize profits, facing a field of anonymous buyers whose preferences are known only statistically. The seminal works of Mirrlees [ 29 ] , Spence [ 37 ] , and Myerson [ 32 ] address variants of this problem in which the spaces — both of actions and of private information — are again unidimensional. In spite of much progress — see references in [ 38 , 1 , 14 , 20 , 21 ] and below — the multidimensional version of the problem continues to pose vexing challenges. A landmark contribution of Rochet and Choné [ 35 ] reduced the question to a problem in the calculus of variations under the simplifying assumptions of linear transfers and quadratic direct costs and preferences. Under the further assumption that the space of actions is Y=[0,\infty)^{n} , and that types are uniformly distributed over a domain X\subset Y of the same dimension, this takes the form of maximizing the profit functional (1.1) \Pi(u):=\int_{X}[x\cdot\nabla u(x)-u(x)-\frac{1}{2}|\nabla u(x)|^{2}]\ d\mathcal{H}^{n} over the set (1.2) \mathcal{U}:=\{0\leq u\in W^{1,2}(\overline{X})\ |\ u\text{ is convex}\} of convex indirect utilities; here \mathcal{H}^{k} denotes k -dimensional Hausdorff measure. If X is convex, the product selected turns out to depend continuously on consumer type x\in X [ 35 , 9 ] , and to be given by \nabla u(x) , where u is the unique maximizer of ( 1.1 )–( 1.2 ). This continuity also extends to \overline{X} [ 12 ] . Generalizations to other distributions of types [ 35 ] , preferences [ 36 , 10 , 18 ] and transfers [ 33 , 25 ] , including regularity results [ 13 , 24 ] , have also been given e.g. by Carlier, Chen, Figalli, Kim, McCann, Noldeke, Rankin, Rochet, Samuelson, Zhang, and to auction design by Daskalakis, Deckelbaum and Tzamos [ 14 ] . Rochet–Choné showed the maximizer of ( 1.1 )–( 1.2 ) was characterized by the convex–ordering of the positive and negative parts of the variational derivative, conditioned on the action selected. A duality-based characterization [ 14 , 26 ] was eventually parlayed into a characterization via Euler-Lagrange equations for a free boundary problem by two of us with Zhang [ 23 ] . However, none of these characterizations extend to the more general settings of [ 10 , 18 , 33 , 25 ] . For convex domains X\subset{\mathbf{R}}^{n} , a deeper analysis of the maximizer of ( 1.1 )–( 1.2 ) performed by two of us with Zhang [ 23 ] revealed unexpected structures, only partly foreshadowed by numerics of Rochet–Choné [ 35 ] , Ekeland–Moreno-Bromberg [ 15 ] , Mirebeau [ 28 ] , Boerma–Tsyvinsky–Zimin [ 5 ] , Carlier–Dupuis–Rochet–Thanassoulis [ 11 ] and theory of McCann and Zhang [ 27 , 26 ] . For n=2 the analysis of the free boundary separating the customization region — the largest open set \Omega_{n}\subset X on which u is strictly convex — from its complement was initiated in [ 23 ] ; it will be continued here, still for n=2 . Line segments along which u is affine that have both endpoints on \partial X form a relatively closed subset of X . For domains satisfying a family of regularity assumptions (see §1.1(a)–(d)) — which include all convex polygons X\subset[0,\infty)^{2} — we shall show that outside of this subset, the free boundary X\cap\partial\Omega_{2} has Hausdorff dimension 1, and \Omega_{2} has density 1/2 along X\cap\partial\Omega_{2} , apart from a discrete set of singular points. This is achieved by building on our results with Zhang [ 23 ] and combining them with techniques pioneered for the obstacle problem with C^{2,\alpha} obstacles by Caffarelli [ 8 , 6 ] , and extended to lower regularity obstacles by Blank [ 4 ] . Since our obstacle arises endogenously from u and was not known to be better than C^{1,1} previously, we use [ 23 ] *Lemma 7.3 and its proof to show the obstacle is C^{2} and control the singular points on the free boundary before analyzing the regular points (where \Omega_{2} has density 1/2 ) by exploiting developments in Blank [ 4 ] . A key to understanding the maximizer u of ( 1.1 ) on ( 1.2 ) is to divide the domain X into the convex sets where the solution u to the monopolist’s problem contacts each of its supporting hyperplanes [ 35 ] . Define an equivalence relation on the closure \overline{X} of X by setting (1.3) x_{1}\sim x_{2}\text{ when