The Eccentric Disk Model for Superhumps

* · 2026

Read The Eccentric Disk Model for Superhumps by * (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14083.txt.

Introduction

Lubow reviews a model for superhumps, bright features in the light curves of close binary stars. A superhump period runs a bit longer than the orbital period. The model blames a disk that is off-center and slowly turns, like a wobbling ring. Disk material orbits at the 3:1 resonance, where a coupling with the pair's tidal pull makes the disk grow off-center. That growth also limits what the disk's inner turbulence must do to reach the resonance.

Catalog record

CREATOR*
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39412
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14083

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Eccentric Disk Model for Superhumps * Abstract An important goal of the disk instability model is to explain the superhump phenomenon. Superhumps are features found in the light curves of binary systems, characterized by a period slightly different from the binary orbital period. In cases where the superhump period is longer than the orbital period (positive superhumps), they have been interpreted as arising from an eccentric, precessing disk. This paper reviews the theory and simulations that indicate that the disk’s eccentricity originates from a dynamical instability at the 3:1 resonance. The instability is described by a mode-coupling process involving the interaction of the disk eccentricity with the binary tidal potential. This instability provides critical constraints on the nature of the disk turbulence that enables the disk to reach this resonance. [a]Stephen H. Lubow 1 Introduction Dwarf novae are highly evolved binary systems that undergo occasional increases in brightness known as outbursts. In these systems, a red dwarf secondary star fills its Roche lobe and transfers mass to a white dwarf primary star through a narrow gas stream. The stream results in the formation of a disk around the primary. Dwarf novae undergo outbursts of 2-3 mag over a duration of a few days that repeat on timescales of weeks to years. The disk instability model (DIM) was developed to explain dwarf nova outbursts as being due to a sudden accretion event in the disk. It originated in work by Osaki [ 1 ] and Smak [ 2 ] (see review by Osaki in this conference). The so-called normal outbursts are described to result from a thermal instability involving the ionization of hydrogen based on early work by Hōshi [ 3 ] and Meyer & Meyer-Hofmeister [ 4 ] (see also paper by Hameury in this conference). Some systems undergo superoutbursts that are somewhat brighter, 3-5 mag, last somewhat longer, a few weeks, and repeat on timescales of weeks to years. Nearly all of these systems that undergo superoutbursts also undergo normal outbursts. A distinctive property of a superoutburst is that it exhibits a feature in its light curve that has a period that is slightly different from the binary orbital period [ 5 , 6 ] . In some cases, the period of the feature is longer than the binary orbital period (positive superhumps), while in other cases the feature has a shorter period (negative superhumps). This review discusses only the positive superhumps. Superhumps in outbursting systems are generally found during superoutbursts. Superhumps are also found as a long-term feature, called permanent superhumps, in some nonoutbursting systems. There have been many observations of superhump systems (e.g., [ 7 , 8 ] ). A review of superhump observations by Nogami & Kato is provided in this conference. Based on photometry and spectroscopy of dwarf nova Z Chamaeleontis, Vogt [ 9 ] proposed a model for superhumps in which the outer part of the disk is eccentric. In this model, the difference between the superhump period and the binary orbital period is due to the slow prograde apsidal precession of the disk, resulting in a disk beat period that is slightly longer than the binary orbital period. The superhump radiation was modeled as being due the the stream-disk impact. Osaki [ 10 ] computed the apsidal precession rate of a disk due to the gravitational effects of the secondary by calculating the precession rate of a particle at two different estimates for the disk outer radii. The resulting prograde precession rates of a few percent of the binary angular frequency implied superhump periods that covered the range of observed periods for the known superhump systems. This finding provided early support for the eccentric disk model. There are alternative models for superhumps, such as that of Smak [ 11 ] in which the superhump radiation is provided by the impact of the gas stream with a precessing disk of azimuthally varying thickness. Whitehurst [ 12 ] later discovered in 2D Lagrangian (particle) simulations of a dwarf nova disk that disk eccentricity does in fact naturally develop. It occurs as a result of the tidal interaction of the disk with the secondary star for binary mass ratios q<0.25 , defined as the secondary mass divided by the primary mass. Such mass ratios are common in superhump systems. In these simulations a disk is formed from a burst of accretion through a mass transfer gas stream. The disk is initially compact and nearly circular with its outer edge near the so-called circularization radius of the gas stream [ 13 ] . It later expands due to viscosity, becomes eccentric, and precesses. As a result of the apsidal precession, each successive tidal interaction of the secondary with the apoastron region of the disk occurs with a period slightly longer than the binary orbital period. Each such interaction gives rise to enhanced disk dissipation and thus provides superhump radiation. Hirose & Osaki [ 14 ] later confirmed the eccentric disk instability in independent Lagrangian simulations. They also suggested that the 3:1 resonance plays a role based on the behavior of ballistic particles (see also [ 15 ] ). The disk instability model was extended by Osaki [ 16 ] to describe superoutbursts by incorporating the effects of the tidal instability into the tidal-thermal instability. Simulations have been carried out by various groups that provide support for the tidal-thermal instability disk instability model (e.g., [ 17 , 18 ] ). A dynamical model for the eccentric disk instability was provided by Lubow [ 19 ] . This analysis showed that an initially small disk eccentricity grows exponentially in time through a mode-coupling process. In this process, the instability results from the interaction of the eccentric disk mode with a tidal disk mode at the 3:1 resonance. The outline of this paper is as follows. Section 2 contains a review of the mode-coupling model for the eccentric disk instability. Section 3 discusses its application to a broad disk. Section 4 describes results of some 2D grid based simulations that applied the alpha disk model for turbulence [ 20 ] . Section 5 discusses possible 3D effects. Section 6 discusses recent MHD simulations in which the disk turbulence occurs through the magneto-rotational instability (MRI) of Balbus & Hawley [ 21 ] . Section 7 discusses the value of turbulent viscosity parameter alpha. Section 8 discusses disk precession. Section 9 contains the summary. 2 The Mode-coupling Model for the Eccentric Disk Instability 2.1 Background The binary is on a circular orbit. How does an initially noneccentric ring/disk become eccentric? The disk is initially noncircular owing to the tidal effects of the secondary, but that is not what is meant by an eccentric disk. An eccentric disk is one that is lopsided relative to the central star and this lopsided component of the density distribution is nearly stationary in the inertial frame. Tidal distortions of the disk are stationary in the corotating frame of the binary, while eccentric distortions are not. The eccentric motions are described by noncircular velocities of particles in the classic Kepler two-body problem but modified by disk pressure and turbulence. A tidally distorted disk with exactly zero initial eccentricity cannot develop eccentricity. Eccentricity is a vector that

Read the complete text