Entropy Maximization and Weak Gibbsianity of Quasi-Free Fermionic States
Vojkan Jakšić, Claude-Alain Pillet, Anna Szczepanek · 2026
Read Entropy Maximization and Weak Gibbsianity of Quasi-Free Fermionic States by Vojkan Jakšić, Claude-Alain Pillet, Anna Szczepanek (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14020.txt.
Introduction
Jakšić, Pillet, and Szczepanek settle two old questions about quasi-free fermionic states on lattices. Lanford and Robinson showed in 1972 that gauge-invariant quasi-free states maximize entropy at a fixed two-point function. Whether the maximizer is unique, and whether such states are weak Gibbs states, stayed open. For a wide class of states, the authors answer yes to both. The proof draws both facts from the thermodynamic formalism for lattice fermions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Vojkan Jakšić, Claude-Alain Pillet, Anna Szczepanek |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34135 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14020
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Entropy Maximization and Weak Gibbsianity of Quasi-Free Fermionic States Vojkan Jakšić, Claude-Alain Pillet, Anna Szczepanek Abstract Abstract. In their 1972 study of approach to equilibrium, Lanford and Robinson showed that gauge-invariant quasi-free states of lattice fermions maximize entropy among all translation-invariant states with a fixed two-point function, and suggested that the maximizer is unique. In subsequent work on this topic, the uniqueness question re-emerged, together with the problem of whether such quasi-free states are weak Gibbs states. We provide a positive answer to both questions within a class of states whose momentum-space two-point function \widehat{C} satisfies 0<\widehat{C}(k)<1 and belongs to the Wiener algebra of the Brillouin zone. The proof reveals that both the entropy maximization principle and weak Gibbsianity follow directly from the thermodynamic formalism for lattice fermions. 1 Introduction In their 1972 study of approach to equilibrium of free fermionic systems [ LR ] , Lanford and Robinson proved, under natural thermodynamic assumptions, that among all translation-invariant states with fixed two-point function, the specific entropy is maximized by gauge-invariant quasi-free states. They further suggested that this maximizer should be unique; see Proposition 1a and the end of Section A in [ LR ] . We establish this conjecture for systems on the lattice {\mathbbm{Z}}^{d} , under a natural regularity assumption on their two-point function. We also prove the related conjecture that these maximizers are weak Gibbs states. Both results follow directly from the thermodynamic formalism for lattice fermions developed by Araki–Moriya [ AM ] and from the perspective on weak Gibbsianity introduced in [ JPT , JPST ] . These observations fit naturally into the research program initiated in the latter works. Since the arguments are conceptually simple and may be of independent interest, we present them here in a self-contained form. To state the main result, we first recall the standard CAR framework and the Lanford–Robinson result [ LR , Proposition 1a] ; further details are provided in Section 2 . The one-particle space for fermions is {\mathfrak{h}}=\ell^{2}({\mathbbm{Z}}^{d}) , and we denote by {\mathfrak{h}}_{X}=\ell^{2}(X) the closed subspaces of {\mathfrak{h}} associated to subsets X\subset{\mathbbm{Z}}^{d} . We let \left(\delta_{x}\right)_{x\in{\mathbbm{Z}}^{d}} be the canonical orthonormal basis of {\mathfrak{h}} . We further denote by \hat{f}\in L^{2}({\mathbbm{T}}^{d},\tfrac{\mathrm{d}k}{(2\pi)^{d}}) the Fourier transform of f\in{\mathfrak{h}} , 1 1 1 {\mathbbm{T}}^{d} denotes the Brillouin zone [-\pi,\pi]^{d} , identified with the d -dimensional torus. and by {\mathcal{B}}({\mathfrak{h}}) the algebra of bounded operators on {\mathfrak{h}} . {\mathfrak{A}}=\mathop{\mathrm{CAR}}\nolimits({\mathfrak{h}}) denotes the CAR algebra over {\mathfrak{h}} , and a(f) / a^{\ast}(f) the annihilation/creation operator associated with f\in{\mathfrak{h}} . For x\in{\mathbbm{Z}}^{d} , we abbreviate a_{x}\coloneq a(\delta_{x}) and a_{x}^{\ast}\coloneq a^{\ast}(\delta_{x}) . {\mathcal{S}}_{\mathrm{I}} denotes the set of all translation-invariant states on {\mathfrak{A}} . To \omega\in{\mathcal{S}}_{\mathrm{I}} we associate its specific entropy s(\omega) and its covariance, the operator C\in{\mathcal{B}}({\mathfrak{h}}) defined by \langle f,Cg\rangle=\omega(a^{\ast}(g)a(f)). C commutes with the unitary action of {\mathbbm{Z}}^{d} and satisfies 0\leq C\leq\mathbbm{1} . We shall say that such a C\in{\mathcal{B}}({\mathfrak{h}}) is a covariance operator. To a covariance operator C\in{\mathcal{B}}({\mathfrak{h}}) we associate its two-point function C(x,y)=\langle\delta_{x},C\delta_{y}\rangle=(C\delta_{y})(x) . In the Fourier representation of {\mathfrak{h}} , C acts as a multiplication operator (Cf)\hat{\ }(k)=\widehat{C}(k)\hat{f}(k), where {\mathbbm{T}}^{d}\ni k\mapsto\widehat{C}(k) is the Fourier transform of C\delta_{0}\in{\mathfrak{h}} , and hence a measurable function satisfying \widehat{C}(k)\in[0,1] for a.e. k\in{\mathbbm{T}}^{d} . We denote by \omega_{C} the unique translation-invariant and gauge-invariant quasi-free state on {\mathfrak{A}} with covariance C . Its specific entropy is given by s(\omega_{C})=-\int_{{\mathbbm{T}}^{d}}\left(\widehat{C}(k)\log\widehat{C}(k)+(1-\widehat{C}(k))\log(1-\widehat{C}(k))\right)\frac{\mathrm{d}k}{(2\pi)^{d}}. Finally, {\mathcal{S}}_{\mathrm{I}}(C) denotes the set of all \omega\in{\mathcal{S}}_{\mathrm{I}} with covariance C . Clearly \omega_{C}\in{\mathcal{S}}_{\mathrm{I}}(C) . Lanford and Robinson prove the following result [ LR , Proposition 1a] . Theorem 1.1 . \sup_{\omega\in{\mathcal{S}}_{\mathrm{I}}(C)}s(\omega)=s(\omega_{C}) (1.1) In the same work they have also suggested that \omega_{C} is the unique maximizer in ( 1.1 ). In other words, one expects that if the two-point correlations are fixed and maximal disorder is imposed, then no additional structure survives: all higher-order correlations are completely determined by the two-point function through the fermionic Wick formula. The space \ell^{1}({\mathbbm{Z}}^{d}) equipped with the convolution operation (f\star g)(x)=\sum_{y\in{\mathbbm{Z}}^{d}}f(x-y)g(y), is a Banach \ast -algebra. The Fourier transform maps it onto a subalgebra of C({\mathbbm{T}}^{d}) , the Wiener algebra {\mathcal{W}} . We will need the following notion of regularity for covariance operators. Definition 1.2 . A covariance operator C\in{\mathcal{B}}({\mathfrak{h}}) is called regular if \widehat{C}\in{\mathcal{W}} and \widehat{C}({\mathbbm{T}}^{d})\subset]0,1[ . Note that \widehat{C}\in{\mathcal{W}} iff the function x\mapsto C(x,0) belongs to \ell^{1}({\mathbbm{Z}}^{d}) . Let us explore the consequences of this definition from the perspective of the thermodynamic formalism. The function m(z)=\log((1-z)/z) is analytic on the cut plane {\mathbbm{C}}\setminus(]-\infty,0]\cup[1,\infty[) . Since \widehat{C} maps {\mathbbm{T}}^{d} to a compact subset of ]0,1[ , Wiener–Levy’s theorem implies that \widehat{h}\coloneq m\circ\widehat{C}\in{\mathcal{W}} . We denote by h the associated operator on {\mathfrak{h}} , and note that since m:]0,1[\to{\mathbbm{R}} , h is a self-adjoint element of {\mathcal{B}}({\mathfrak{h}}) such that C=\left(\mathbbm{1}+\mathrm{e}^{h}\right)^{-1}. We will refer to h as the one-particle Hamiltonian associated to C and denote by \tau_{h}=\left(\tau_{h}^{t}\right)_{t\in{\mathbbm{R}}} the group of Bogoliubov automorphisms of {\mathfrak{A}} generated by h . The unique \tau_{h} -KMS state at \beta=1 is \omega_{C} . It also follows from the Araki-Moriya thermodynamic formalism of fermionic systems that \omega_{C} is the unique equilibrium state for the fermionic interaction \Phi defined by 2 2 2 Here, one allows for x=y . \Phi(X)\coloneq\begin{cases}\tfrac{1}{2}\left(h(x,y)a_{x}^{\ast}a_{y}+h(y,x)a_{y}^{\ast}a_{x}\right)&if $X=\{x,y\}$;\\[4.0pt] 0&otherwise,\end{cases} (1.2) where h(x,y)=\langle\delta_{x},h\delta_{y}\rangle . We will review the thermodynamic formalism of fermionic systems and discuss the naturalness of definition 1.2 in this context in Section 2 . Our first result is Theorem 1.3 . Suppose that C is a regular covariance operator. Then \omega_{C} is the unique maximizer in ( 1.1 ). We now turn to our second result. In the following, \Lambda always denotes a cubic box in {\mathbbm{Z}}^{d} centered at the origin, and we write \lim_{\Lambda} for a limit over an increasing sequence of such cubes. The local Hamiltonian induced in the box \Lambda by the interaction ( 1.2 ) is H_{\Lambda}(\Phi)\coloneq\sum_{X\subset\Lambda}\Phi(X)=\sum_{x,y\in\Lambda}h(x,y)a_{x}^{\ast}a_{y}. It coincides with the gauge-invariant quadratic Hamiltonian associated to the compression of h to the finite-dimensional subspace {\mathfrak{h}}_{\Lambda} , h_{\Lambda}\coloneq\mathbf{1}_{\Lambda}h\mathbf{1}_{\Lambda} , where \mathbf{1}_{\Lambda} denotes the orthogonal projection on {\mathfrak{h}}_{\Lambda} . We denote by \omega_{\Lambda} the restriction of a state \omega\in{\mathcal{S}}_{\mathrm{I}} to the finite dimensional subalgebra \mathop{\mathrm{CAR}}\nolimits({\mathfrak{h}}_{\Lambda}) . We identify \omega_{\Lambda} with its density matrix in the canonical trace representation. The pressure of the interaction ( 1.2 ) in the box \Lambda is P_{\Lambda}(\Phi)=\log\mathop{\mathrm{tr}}\nolimits(\mathrm{e}^{-H_{\Lambda}(\Phi)}). Theorem 1.4 . The state \omega_{C} is weak Gibbs in the sense that there are positive constants c_{\Lambda} satisfying \lim_{\Lambda}\tfrac{\log c_{\Lambda}}{|\Lambda|}=0, and c_{\Lambda}^{-1}\mathrm{e}^{-H_{\Lambda}(\Phi)-P_{\Lambda}(\Phi)}\leq\omega_{C,\Lambda}\leq c_{\Lambda}\mathrm{e}^{-H_{\Lambda}(\Phi)-P_{\Lambda}(\Phi)}. Weak Gibbsianity plays a central role in the research program introduced in [ JPT , JPST ] . To our knowledge, it has not been explicitly observed in the literature that Theorem 1.3 follows directly from the non-negativity of relative entropy density 3 3 3 This fact also plays central role in Lanford–Robinson’s proof of Theorem 1.1 . and the Araki–Moriya thermodynamic formalism. Likewise, Theorem 1.4 is a consequence of [ JPT , Theorem 3.1] . Gauge-invariant quasi-free states play an important role across physics and mathematical physics, and we hope that these observations may find applications beyond the study of approach to equilibrium. Finally, we remark that Lanford and Robinson in [ LR ] worked in the continuous Fermi systems setting in which the one-particle Hilbert space is L^{2}({\mathbbm{R}}^{d}) . The thermodynamic formalism of such systems has not been developed, and our method of proof does