Quantum Dynamical Entropy and non-Markovianity: a collisional model perspective

Giovanni Nichele, Fabio Benatti · 2026

Read Quantum Dynamical Entropy and non-Markovianity: a collisional model perspective by Giovanni Nichele, Fabio Benatti (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14015.txt.

Introduction

Nichele and Benatti use a collisional model to study quantum dynamical entropy and memory effects in open systems. Watching only the open system hides how it and its environment act together. Multi-time correlations fix that gap and ground the Alicki-Lindblad-Fannes entropy. In their model, a finite-level system couples to an endless classical spin chain. The entropy can then be computed in closed form. It depends on the statistical traits of the environment and links to when memory effects switch on.

Catalog record

CREATORGiovanni Nichele, Fabio Benatti
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE156043
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14015

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum Dynamical Entropy and non-Markovianity: a collisional model perspective Giovanni Nichele, Fabio Benatti Abstract Accessing the physical mechanisms behind non-Markovian phenomena in open quantum dynamics requires the study of the statistical properties of the joint system-environment dynamics. This is impossible at the level of the reduced dynamics of the open system alone as the latter is obtained by suitably eliminating the environment. The task is instead made possible by considering multi-time correlation functions involving observables of the open system, only: the open system-environment interactions turn them into global ones thus building up correlations between the two systems. Multi-time correlations form the basis of both the theory of quantum stochastic processes and of the Alicki-Lindblad-Fannes dynamical entropy (ALF entropy for short). This latter quantity provides for quantum systems a measure of the dynamical entropy production as the Kolmogorov-Sinai entropy does for classical systems. In the case of a collisional model whereby the dissipative dynamics of a finite-level system is obtained by its coupling to an infinite classical spin chain, the ALF entropy can be explicitly computed. It turns out to depend on the parameters characterizing the statistical properties of the environment and can be related to the activation and super-activation of memory effects in the open quantum system. I Introduction Due to their importance in quantum information technologies, the non-Markovian features of open quantum dynamics have recently become the focus of much research and have been addressed by several, non-equivalent, techniques resulting in an intricate hierarchy Li et al. 2018 . As an instance, typically the time-evolution of an open quantum system is provided by a family \{\Lambda^{\ddagger}_{t}\}_{t\geq 0} of completely positive and trace preserving (CPTP) linear maps \rho\longmapsto\Lambda^{\ddagger}_{t}[\rho] on the space of states \rho that result from tracing over the environment degrees of freedom. In such a setting, one may identify Markovianity with the completely positive divisibility (CP-divisibility) of the evolution Chruściński 2022 ; Rivas et al. 2010 ; Rivas and Huelga 2012 . Namely, with the complete positivity of intermediate-time propagators \Lambda^{\ddagger}_{t,s} , t\geq s\geq 0 , composing as \Lambda^{\ddagger}_{t}=\Lambda^{\ddagger}_{t,s}\circ\Lambda^{\ddagger}_{s} . In such a scenario, the lack of positivity-preservation and thus of contractivity of the propagators gives rise to the increase, instead of the decrease, of several information distances, a phenomenon generally interpreted as a physical back-flow of information from the environment into the open system Breuer et al. 2009 . Considering instead a classical discrete time scenario as a benchmark for possible quantum extensions of the notion of Markovianity, there one deals with multi-time probabilities \pi_{[0,n-1]} of a stochastic variable X having, say, discrete values x_{j} at subsequent times: \displaystyle p_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,n-1]}}^{[0,n-1]}:=P(X_{0}=x_{0},\cdots,X_{n-1}=x_{n-1})\,, \displaystyle\pi_{[0,n-1]}=\left\{p_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,n-1]}}^{[0,n-1]}\right\}_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,n-1]}}\,. Markovianity is then identified with lack of memory and mathematically characterized by multi-time conditional probabilities depending only on the immediately preceding outcome: p_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,n-1]}}^{(n-1|n-2,\cdots,0)}:=\frac{p_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,n-1]}}^{[0,n-1]}}{p_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,n-2]}}^{[0,n-2]}}=p_{x_{n-1}\,x_{n-2}}^{(n-1|n-2)}\,, (1) where \boldsymbol{x}_{[0,n-1]}:=x_{0}\cdots x_{n-1} . Evidently, for classical Markovian processes, multi-time probabilities factorize into products of conditional probabilities, p_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,n-1]}}^{[0,n-1]}=\prod_{j=1}^{n-1}p_{x_{j}x_{j-1}}^{(j|j-1)}\ p_{x_{0}}^{(0)}\,, (2) and satisfy the Chapman-Kolmogorov equations; namely, for all j\geq\ell\geq k , p_{x_{j}x_{k}}^{(j|k)}=\sum_{x_{\ell}}p_{x_{j}x_{\ell}}^{(j|\ell)}\ p_{x_{\ell}x_{k}}^{(\ell|k)}\ , (3) where \displaystyle p_{x_{j}x_{k}}^{(j|k)}=\frac{\sum_{x_{i}\neq x_{j},x_{k}}p_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,j]}}^{[0,j]}}{\sum_{x_{i}\neq x_{k}}{p_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,k]}}^{[0,k]}}}\,. Therefore, the transition matrices T(j,k)=\left[p_{x_{j}x_{k}}^{(j|k)}\right] , are stochastic matrices composing as T(j,k)=T(j,\ell)T(\ell,k) and play the same role as the discrete-time quantum propagators \Lambda^{\ddagger}_{j,k},j\geq k . However, this composition law does not imply classical Markovianity as embodied by ( 1 ), which is stronger. Instead, it is equivalently identified by the so-called Classical Regression (CR). This latter property holds if multi-time correlation functions \left\langle F^{(0)}F^{(1)}\cdots F^{(n-1)}\right\rangle_{\pi} are expressible in terms of transition probabilities, as follows: \displaystyle\left\langle F^{(0)}F^{(1)}\cdots F^{(n-1)}\right\rangle_{\pi}=\!\sum_{\boldsymbol{a}_{[0,n-1]}}p_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,n-1]}}^{[0,n-1]}\ F_{x_{0}}^{(0)}F_{x_{1}}^{(1)}\ldots F_{x_{n}}^{(n-1)} \displaystyle=\sum_{\boldsymbol{x}_{[0,n-1]}}\prod_{j=2}^{n}\ T_{x_{j}x_{j-1}}(j,j-1)\ F_{x_{0}}^{(0)}F_{x_{1}}^{(1)}\ldots F_{x_{n}}^{(n-1)}\,, (4) for all functions F^{(j)} of the random variable X . In the quantum realm, in order to properly discuss non-Markovian issues, two are the main reasons for choosing the non-commutative analog of ( 4 ), namely Quantum Regression (QR), as a starting point, instead of the reduced dynamics Lax 1963 ; Chruściński 2022 ; Lonigro and Chruściński 2022a ; Lonigro and Chruściński 2022b : the first one is that the latter in practice involves 2 -time correlation functions losing precious information coming from the multi-time statistics. The second reason is that multi-time correlations provide a powerful tool to access the dynamics of information exactly when a given open quantum dynamics at discrete time n , \Lambda^{\ddagger}_{n} , is derived from the global reversible dynamics \Theta^{\ddagger}_{n} of system-environment factorized states \rho_{S}\otimes\rho_{E} after tracing away the environment, \Lambda^{\ddagger}_{n}[\rho_{S}]={\rm Tr}_{E}\Big(\Theta^{\ddagger}_{n}[\rho_{S}\otimes\rho_{E}]\Big) . Indeed, QR regards multi-time correlations {\rm Tr}_{S+E}\Big(\rho_{S}\otimes\rho_{E}\Big(\widetilde{B}^{(n)\dagger}\widetilde{A}^{(n)}\Big)\Big) of observables A_{j},B_{j} of the open system only, evolving according to the Heisenberg joint reversible dynamics, \Theta_{n} , associated to \Theta_{n}^{\ddagger} , where \widetilde{A}^{(n)}:=\Theta_{n-1}[A_{n-1}\otimes\mathds{1}_{E}]\ldots\Theta_{1}[A_{1}\otimes\mathds{1}_{E}]A_{0}\otimes\mathds{1}_{E}\,, and amounts to the possibility of expressing them in terms of CPU (completely positive and unity-preserving) propagators \Lambda_{n,n-1} Chruściński 2022 ; Li et al. 2018 acting on S : {\rm Tr}_{S+E}\Big(\rho_{S}\otimes\rho_{E}\Big(\widetilde{B}^{(n)\dagger}\widetilde{A}^{(n)}\Big)\Big)=\Tr_{S}\!\bigg(\rho_{S}\,B_{0}^{\dagger}\,\Lambda_{1}\Big[B_{1}^{\dagger}\,\Lambda_{2,1}\big[\dots{\\ }\Lambda_{{n-1},{n-2}}\big[B_{{n-1}}^{\dagger}A_{n-1}^{\phantom{\dagger}}\big]\dots\big]A_{1}\Big]\,A_{0}\bigg)\,, for all possible choices of observables of S . Another approach to non-Markovian quantum issues is thus to check whether QR is violated. The proper quantum extension of non-Markovian stochastic processes, including the multi-time statistics, is rooted in a long history dating back to pioneering works Accardi et al. 1982 ; Accardi 1981 ; Lindblad 1979 ; Lewis 1981 ; Frigerio 1981 and still much debated in recent years. In particular, including the multi-time statistics in the description involves repeated quantum measurements that interfere with the dynamics and generally change the quantum state (see Alicki and Fannes 2001 ; Breuer et al. 2016 ; Milz et al. 2020 and the recent review Shrikant and Mandayam 2023 ). Among the most recent proposals concerning such operational approach, particularly prominent ones include the so-called process tensor formalism Milz and Modi 2021 ; Pollock et al. 2018a ; Pollock et al. 2018b , quantum combs (see Chiribella et al. 2008 ; Milz et al. 2020 and references therein), conditional past-future independence Budini 2018 ; Budini 2022 and temporal entanglement (see the recent work Vilkoviskiy et al. 2025 ). A shared idea among most of these approaches is to map multi-time correlations into spatial ones encoded in a quantum many-body state. Furthermore, in such a non-commutative scenario, G. Lindblad Lindblad 1979 proposed to look at Markovianity using a quantum version of the Kolmogorov-Sinai (KS) entropy, this latter concept measuring the amount of entropy, that is of ignorance before measuring or, equivalently, of information gathered afterwards, per unit time-step provided by the dynamics. Such a notion was later fully developed by Alicki and Fannes in Alicki and Fannes 1994 , with applications mainly to the reversible dynamics of quantum many-body systems Alicki and Fannes 2001 . Differently from other proposals of quantum dynamical entropy, the Alicki-Lindblad-Fannes (ALF) entropy takes into consideration the fact that information about quantum systems is obtained by measuring schemes that, unlike classical phase-space localization with respect to a suitable coarse graining, interfere with the given dynamics. Notice, that such an approach contrasts with the idea of information back-flow which instead focuses on the dynamics of the system S only, without the need of any measurement and so, effectively, on marginal probabilities. In the following, we adapt the ALF entropy to an open quantum system scenario, whereby a one-qubit Pauli dynamics is obtained by means of a so-called collisional model Ciccarello et al. 2022 ; Campbell and Vacchini 2021 with the environment being a correlated classical spin chain and

Read the complete text