Manufacturable blazed metasurface gratings designed by 3D topology optimization model
Simon Ans, Frédéric Zamkotsian, Guillaume Demésy · 2026
Read Manufacturable blazed metasurface gratings designed by 3D topology optimization model by Simon Ans, Frédéric Zamkotsian, Guillaume Demésy (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14013.txt.
Introduction
Ans, Zamkotsian, and Demésy design blazed metasurface gratings that shops can actually make. Their 3D design method works for light in the visible and near-infrared bands, in reflection. A freeform design reaches an average diffraction score near 62 percent, but its shapes are hard to build. A pillar-based design adds making limits to the search, such as e-beam writing and ion etching. It still reaches about 57 percent, with low dependence on polarization.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Simon Ans, Frédéric Zamkotsian, Guillaume Demésy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46107 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14013
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Manufacturable blazed metasurface gratings designed by 3D topology optimization model Simon Ans, Frédéric Zamkotsian, Guillaume Demésy Abstract We present the generalization of our FEM-based topology optimization framework to 3D blazed metasurfaces operating in reflection over the visible and near-infrared range [400– 1500 1500 ] nm. The design region is described through a density-based SIMP interpolation and optimized using the adjoint method, enabling the treatment of several tens of thousands degrees of freedom. A first approach directly applies topology optimization to the 3D Finite Element mesh (mesh-based), yielding a freeform structure that achieves an average diffraction efficiency of 62% in order − - 1 over two octaves under the targeted incidence. However, such patterns remain difficult to manufacture. We therefore introduce a pillar-based parameterization, embedding fabrication constraints within the optimization loop. The resulting binary metasurface, compatible with e-beam lithography and Reactive Ion Etching techniques, achieves an average efficiency of 57% over the same spectral band in s s -polarization, with low polarization dependence. This work demonstrates that large-scale 3D topology optimization can bridge the gap between broadband optical performance and realistic nanofabrication constraints for blazed metasurfaces. Keywords: Blazed gratings, Metasurface, Broadband optimization, Topology optimization, Maxwell’s equations, Finite Element Method. 1 Introduction Spectrographs are widely used in physics, biology and medicine, for material characterization purposes. Knowing the composition of a material with a non-invasive method is of paramount interest, allowing for the identification of molecules or atoms in living beings. This is the basis of disease diagnoses for instance, and broadly speaking of every kind of quality control for the environment and in the industry. For Earth and Universe Observation, spectroscopy allows us to identify atomic and molecular species, to measure redshifts in deep-field observations, to characterize exoplanetary atmospheres and to monitor ecosystems, mineral compositions, or pollution phenomena. Blazed gratings are fundamental optical components in spectrographs, especially for studying low-flux radiation. The most common type, whose fabrication has been industrialized for certain applications, is the sawtooth-profiled grating (see Fig. 1 , in reflection). It has a period above the considered wavelengths to deflect light on diffraction orders, while its so-called blazed geometry privileges a sole order for Signal-to-Noise (SNR) increase purpose. For visible (Vis) and Near Infrared (NIR) study, their pattern size is therefore around several micrometers. Although they demonstrate a high-level and robust blazing effect on one octave – from one wavelength to its double – the lack of possible improvements in their design nudged the community toward developing subwavelength structures, commonly referred to as metasurfaces in the literature. The first studies on blazed metasurfaces date back to the early 1990s and were published in Ref. [ 17 ] . The concept was later popularized by P. Lalanne et al. through the design and fabrication of a blazed metasurface operating in Vis and NIR, which they compared to a sawtooth blazed grating [ 27 ] . The promising results they obtained led the authors to discuss the natural improvements of their work. On the one hand, they suggested using computational electromagnetics to solve Maxwell’s equations for a given structure. Two widely used numerical methods are the Rigorous Coupled Wave Analysis (RCWA) [ 30 ] and the Finite Element Method (FEM) [ 14 ] , both allowing the resolution of Partial Differential Equations (PDEs) through spatial and temporal discretization. The second one is chosen in this article for its flexibility in design and implementation. On the other hand, the authors invited the reader to locally adjust the structure’s geometry and improve its performance through mathematical and computational techniques. The numerical resolution of PDEs with the FEM has been a major breakthrough in Computational Physics and Engineering. Physical problems involving realistic geometries could be solved numerically in many fields, such as fluid mechanics (Navier-Stokes equation), solid mechanics (convection-diffusion equations, dynamics equations), thermodynamics (heat equation), acoustics (wave equation) and of course photonics (Maxwell’s equations). The idea of modifying the discretized domain to optimize its performance followed naturally. By "performance", we mean a given objective function to be improved ( e.g. , the resistance of a structure or efficiency of a device), which is also called target or merit function. The concept of structural optimization based on FEM appeared in the 1960s, introduced by L. Schmit’s group according to Ref. [ 21 ] . Modifying the design region and its so-called discretization mesh constitutes shape optimization, which remains widely used today. The works of G. Allaire [ 1 ] are often cited as a reference in this domain. The issues raised by shape optimization, such as mesh adaptation or sensitivity analysis – that have been addressed ever since [ 2 , 25 ] – have caused another optimization method to emerge in the late 1980s: Topology Optimization (TO), introduced in Ref. [ 6 ] . Instead of modifying shape boundaries, TO finds the optimal design by directly changing the material distribution within small elementary "boxes", called voxels (a blend of "volume" and "pixel"). These voxels are defined once and for all at the start of the computation, allowing the Finite Element (FE) mesh to remain fixed. The numerous improvements of this method, mainly attributed to M. P. Bendsøe, O. Sigmund [ 8 ] and their collaborators, have established TO as a powerful and versatile design framework. At first developed for solid mechanics, it is now applied to any field governed by PDEs. A non-exhaustive list includes fluid mechanics and fluid-structure interactions [ 9 , 11 ] , acoustics [ 23 , 13 ] , electromechanics [ 26 , 31 ] and photonics [ 18 , 15 , 32 ] . The latter is the domain of interest for this work. More specifically, TO in nanophotonics has been largely developed thanks to the heuristic homogenization of the density parameters, called the Solid Isotropic Material with Penalization method (SIMP), introduced by Bendsøe and Sigmund [ 7 ] . Noticeable examples are the open-source optimization repository MetaNet [ 24 ] and Machine Learning (ML)-aided optimization tools [ 28 , 29 ] . To our knowledge, the state-of-the-art performance of manufactured broadband blazed metasurface gratings designed with TO is around 55% of average efficiency for 5 wavelengths between 900 nm and 1300 nm, for both polarizations (different grating for TE and TM) [ 33 ] . Another design, solely based on the phase shift induced by blazed gratings [ 10 ] , has demonstrated the same performance on the wavelength range [350– 1100 ] nm. There are some recent works in the IR with very high broadband performances, such as in Ref. [ 35 ] . However the targeted wavelength range of [6–12] \mu m in this study is actually an octave, with the same energy gap as the [400–800] nm visible range. Such broadband studies in the Vis/NIR region are not common. This is why we have recently developed an open-source, bespoke, FEM-based and large-parameter topology optimization tool that addressed the issue of nanostructured blazed gratings for the Vis/NIR range [400– 1500 ] nm [ 5 ] , based on Python and the Gmsh/GetDP software suite [ 20 , 16 ] . It can find an optimal design on any wavelength range, on any diffraction order, with any pair of materials under conical incidence, i.e. mono-periodic (or 1D)