CAN WE FALL IN LOVE WITH AI FICTION?

THE AI-FICTION PARADOX · 2026

Read CAN WE FALL IN LOVE WITH AI FICTION? by THE AI-FICTION PARADOX (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-13545.txt.

Introduction

Katherine Elkins names and analyzes the AI Fiction Paradox in AI development. Developers treat large corpora of modern books as worth major cost and legal risk, yet models still struggle to write compelling long-form fiction. Elkins gives three challenges that explain why fiction resists AI generation. Narrative causation demands plot events that feel surprising yet retrospectively inevitable. Informational revaluation asks that early details gain new meaning later. Multi-scale emotional architecture is the third challenge she sets out.

Catalog record

CREATORTHE AI-FICTION PARADOX
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61213
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.13545

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

CAN WE FALL IN LOVE WITH AI FICTION? THE AI-FICTION PARADOX Abstract ABSTRACT AI development has a fiction dependency problem: models are built on massive corpora of modern fiction and desperately need more of it, yet they struggle to generate it. I term this the “AI-Fiction Paradox,” and it is particularly startling because in machine learning, training data typically determines output quality. This paper offers a theoretically precise account of why fiction resists AI generation by identifying three distinct challenges for current architectures. First, fiction depends on what I call narrative causation , a form of plot logic where events must feel both surprising in the moment and retrospectively inevitable. This temporal paradox fundamentally conflicts with the forward-generation logic of transformer architectures. Second, I identify an informational revaluation challenge : fiction systematically violates the computational assumption that informational importance aligns with statistical salience, requiring readers and models alike to retrospectively reweight the significance of narrative details in ways that current attention mechanisms cannot perform. Third, drawing on over seven years of collaborative research on sentiment arcs, I argue that compelling fiction requires multi-scale emotional architecture , the orchestration of sentiment at word, sentence, scene, and arc levels simultaneously. Together, these three challenges explain both why AI companies have risked billion-dollar lawsuits for access to modern fiction and why that fiction remains so difficult to replicate. The analysis also raises urgent questions about what happens when these challenges are overcome. Fiction concentrates uniquely powerful cognitive and emotional patterns for modeling human behavior, and mastery of these patterns by AI systems would represent not just a creative achievement but a potent vehicle for human manipulation at scale. Keywords AI-Fiction Paradox, narrative causation, informational revaluation, sentiment arc, emotional architecture, large language models, fiction generation, training data Presented at the MFS Cultural AI Conference, Purdue University, September 18, 2025. This preprint is part of a proposed collection of essays for MFS Modern Fiction Studies . 1 AI’s Modern Fiction Dependency Problem AI development has a fiction dependency problem: it’s built on modern fiction and desperately needs more of it. And yet, in spite of being trained on it, models struggle to generate it. I call this the “AI-Fiction Paradox,” and it’s startling because typically training data determines output. With such a significant quantity of training data—thousands of novels—we would expect far better results. Our AI-Fiction Paradox yields several key questions. Why is modern fiction so important for AI development, even driving companies to risk legal battles for pirated novels? Given fiction as such a substantial part of training data, why is AI still not very good at generating it? What are the specific limitations in generating fiction, and what do these weaknesses suggest about modern fiction that distinguishes it from other text genres more easily generated? Answering these questions will bring us closer to determining whether AI models will ever generate quality fiction that we could fall in love with. But it also raises new questions about fiction as a highly powerful emotional technology, one that—if it were mastered by AI—would offer a vehicle for human manipulation. In the following pages, I’ll explore ways in which AI’s current failures seem tied to how models are built, not the novels they’re trained on. Current struggles highlight the distinct qualities of fiction that make it so crucial for building general intelligence. It’s hard to imagine AI limitations are permanent, and if fiction offers something unique and irreplaceable (at least for now) for building intelligent models, it behooves scholars of fiction to consider the extent to which building better fiction-generating machines might open doors best left closed. Let’s be precise: AI actually has a modern fiction dependency problem. I say modern because there is plenty of fiction training data that is out of copyright and widely available on Gutenberg like Robinson Crusoe and Jane Eyre . In fact, AI companies have found modern fiction to be so key for building performant models that they have taken on significant legal risk. 1 1 1 Both Meta and an Anthropic case have now been resolved in ways that reflect the extreme legal uncertainty surrounding this issue. Anthropic settled for $1.5 billion after being found liable for downloading pirated books from shadow libraries. The court ruled, however, that training AI on legitimately acquired books constituted fair use. Meta, on the other hand, prevailed in court by successfully arguing that its use of pirated materials was transformative and constituted fair use. These markedly different outcomes—both companies used similar pirated datasets but faced different consequences—underscore how current copyright law struggles to address AI training practices. Liability may currently hinge on technical legal arguments rather than the underlying conduct of using unauthorized materials. We now know that Meta used thousands of pirated novels, including the 183,000-book Books3 dataset from LibGen, even though it was flagged as “medium-high legal risk” ( Silverman v. Meta ). Yes, the fact that books are “more important” than web data for training intelligent AI models is likely to seem obvious to most literary scholars. To be clear, the Books3 database is not just fiction, and includes by some estimates approximately two-thirds non-fiction works. Even so, this is a huge addition to previous datasets that relied on sites like Gutenberg for literary materials. Many scholars of modern fiction would gladly accept that, of course, what we study is integral to intelligence—of course over 60,000 novels would be more useful for building intelligence than the contents of Wikipedia or the facts and figures found elsewhere on the internet. However there is one striking element to this AI-Fiction Paradox that might cause surprise. Books3 contains not just the contemporary literary fiction most typically found on a college syllabus---works prized for their formal innovation, narrative complexity, or social critique---but a vast range of popular fiction that scholars usually value less. The actual dataset is a mix of critically acclaimed literary fiction alongside romance novels, Nobel Prize-winning works and self-published erotica, experimental postcolonial narratives but also licensed fantasy tie-in novels set in gaming worlds like Dungeons & Dragons’ Forgotten Realms. 2 2 2 See Daniel Reiser’s Atlantic article for a deeper dive into the full dataset. It would seem that for AI development, a sophisticated highly literary novel carries the same weight as a predictable airport thriller. It’s hard to imagine risking CEO-level lawsuits for such an eclectic mix unless something about fiction in general, regardless of literary merit, is at stake. 3 3 3 My guess is that AI companies are not necessarily clear on why fiction offers such a performance boost—just that training on the data creates more performant models. The legal risk Meta undertook underscores this AI-Fiction dependency’s seriousness. Documents from the ongoing Silverman lawsuit reveal engineers hesitating to torrent massive novel collections—one wrote, “torrenting from a corporate laptop doesn’t feel right” ( Silverman vs. Meta ). Another memo, escalated to executives including Mark Zuckerberg, noted approval to use pirated material despite ‘‘medium-high legal risk’’ and data quality issues, like page numbers embedded in texts. 4 4 4 There are different views on whether the Books3 corpus was taken from the larger LibGen dataset also used to train models, or whether it was from a different pirated site called Bibliotik.

Read the complete text