A Generative Model of Conspicuous Consumption and Status Signaling
Logan Cross, Jordi Grau-Moya, William A. Cunningham, Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, Joel Z. Leibo · 2026
Read A Generative Model of Conspicuous Consumption and Status Signaling by Logan Cross, Jordi Grau-Moya, William A. Cunningham, Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, Joel Z. Leibo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-13220.txt.
Introduction
Logan Cross and co-authors build a generative model of conspicuous consumption and status signaling. Why some goods gain prestige has long puzzled costly signaling theory, which treats tastes as fixed. Their account grounds status in the theory of appropriateness and a social feedback loop. Groups of LLM-based agents in the Concordia framework test the idea in daily routines. Social visibility turns plain demand into status seeking, the team reports. Price run-ups and Veblen effects appear for both real luxury goods and synthetic ones.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Logan Cross, Jordi Grau-Moya, William A. Cunningham, Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, Joel Z. Leibo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73263 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.13220
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Generative Model of Conspicuous Consumption and Status Signaling Logan Cross, Jordi Grau-Moya, William A. Cunningham, Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, Joel Z. Leibo Abstract Status signaling drives human behavior and the allocation of scarce resources such as mating opportunities, yet the generative mechanisms governing how specific goods, signals, or behaviors acquire prestige remain a puzzle. Classical frameworks, such as Costly Signaling Theory, treat preferences as fixed and struggle to explain how semiotic meaning changes based on context or drifts dynamically over time, occasionally reaching tipping points. In this work, we propose a computational theory of status grounded in the theory of appropriateness, positing that status symbols emerge endogenously through a feedback loop of social observation and predictive pattern completion. We validate this theory using simulations of groups of Large Language Model (LLM)-based agents in the Concordia framework. By experimentally manipulating social visibility within naturalistic agent daily routines, we demonstrate that social interactions transform functional demand into status-seeking behavior. We observe the emergence of price run-ups and positive price elasticity (Veblen effects) for both real-world luxury items and procedurally generated synthetic goods, ruling out pretraining bias as the sole driver. Furthermore, we demonstrate that "influencer" agents can drive the endogenous formation of distinct subcultures through targeted sanctioning, and find that similar social influence effects generalize to non-monetary signaling behaviors. This work provides a generative bridge between micro-level cognition and macro-level economic and sociological phenomena, offering a new methodology for forecasting how cultural conventions emerge from interaction. \reportnumber 1 Introduction Status signaling fundamentally drives human behavior, wherein individuals take actions to advertise otherwise unobservable traits like wealth, fitness, or group allegiance. This drive is adaptive and evolutionarily conserved, as status is a relative ranking that mediates the allocation of scarce resources such as attention, allies, and mating opportunities ( 71 ; 24 ) . Beyond resource allocation, these displays serve a semiotic function: they act as a system of social classification that allows individuals to distinguish in-group members and infer the latent characteristics of others ( 59 ; 11 ; 34 ; 61 ; 65 ) . Modern evolutionary accounts suggest that these signals also facilitate cultural learning by helping individuals identify prestigious models to imitate ( 29 ; 31 ) . Yet, the generative mechanism governing these displays remains a puzzle. Why do some goods, behaviors, or ideas become potent status symbols while others fade, and why do their meanings shift so dynamically across cultures and time ( 5 ) ? Researchers have struggled to empirically isolate the mechanisms, as these signals emerge organically and are socially constructed. Field data about the consumption of status goods confound prestige, marketing, and social diffusion ( 47 ; 27 ) . Experiments in the lab struggle with ecological validity and making status and visibility realistic without losing control ( 44 ; 26 ) . Understanding not just what functions as a signal but also how signals emerge, shift, and propagate is a central problem in social science. Current theoretical frameworks offer only a patchwork of independent explanations for these phenomena. The rational-choice theory of human behavior struggles to explain why status goods frequently exhibit upward-sloping demand curves (Veblen effects) as the Law of Demand posits that demand falls when prices rise ( 6 ; 64 ; 65 ; 4 ) . Costly Signaling Theory (CST) explains conspicuous consumption by treating expenditure as a credible signal of status because the cost is hard to fake for low status individuals ( 71 ; 24 ) . However, even though CST explains why costly signals are honest and have stable equilibria, high production cost is neither necessary nor sufficient to create a status signal ( 38 ; 5 ) . Figure 1: The figure illustrates how status preferences shift dynamically through agent-to-agent interaction rather than hard-coded utility functions. (Left) The Initial Preference Distribution shows an agent with a current snapshot of its preferences. (Middle) During the Social Interaction & Signal Transmission phase, the focal agent (left) interacts with a partner displaying a distinct status signal (an Armani blazer). The dialogue, which includes both casual conversation and specific acknowledgment of the item, is encoded into the agent’s memory stream (depicted in the architecture schematic below). (Right) The Updated Preference Distribution shifts toward the observed status symbol (Armani Suit). Research on neutral markers demonstrates that nearly costless behaviors can emerge as in-group signaling conventions. For example accents, slang, religious markings, conventional in-group badges, and moralized reposts of political news—are nearly costless to produce yet remain reliable social signals ( 17 ; 57 ; 5 ; 63 ; 62 ; 20 ) . These signals solve a coordination problem in which the value of a symbol emerges through equilibrium selection: once a community converges on an arbitrary marker, in-group members imitate that marker over alternatives ( 38 ; 16 ; 45 ; 60 ) . Social imitation of arbitrary symbols and rituals serves as a reliable learning heuristic as humans are embedded in complex environments where knowledge is opaque and culturally inherited ( 31 ) . Moreover, high cost is not sufficient for status, as the semiotic value of a signal is often subject to rapid cultural drift. Expensive goods frequently lose their signaling power because they become accessible to the ’wrong’ groups or fail to align with shifting aesthetic norms, rendering them passé despite their continued expense ( 59 ; 40 ; 11 ; 56 ; 9 ) . Across these domains, rather than cost, the binding constraint is semiotic appropriateness —how observers interpret a signaling action given precedent, social role, context, and shared cultural expectations. Cost can contribute to perceived appropriateness—but so can aesthetic form, identity alignment, and the weight of prior examples. A unified model of signaling must therefore explain why costly signals sometimes work, why cheap signals often work, and why entire cultural regimes of signaling can shift rapidly as conventions change. We propose such a model unified model grounded in the theory of appropriateness, positing that status symbols emerge endogenously through a feedback loop of social observation and imitation via predictive pattern completion ( 12 ; 43 ; 42 ) . Predictive pattern completion conceptualizes humans as culturally trained generative models who produce actions that are appropriate for their context by developing a habitus — an intuitive sense for the “rules of the game” coined by sociologist Pierre Bourdieu ( 11 ) . In this view, signals acquire value through social diffusion: individuals observe peers, update expectations about what "people like us" do, and imitate the signaling behaviors that align with that shared context. We operationalize our theory using multi-agent societies of generative agents in Concordia ( 55 ; 66 ; 67 ; 3 ) . As previous work validated that these Large Language Model (LLM)-based agents can reproduce human signaling dynamics in controlled experiments ( 19 ) , we scale these mechanisms to a naturalistic setting to observe the endogenous emergence of status signals. This approach allows us to create ecologically-valid yet precisely controllable social environments, where we can isolate the essential ingredients for status dynamics to emerge without identification problems ( 47 ) . It enables us to manipulate who talks to whom, what is publicly visible, and how choices are made, while measuring