Negative Masses and Spatial Curvature: Alleviating Neutrino Mass Tensions in Λ \Lambda CDM and Extended Cosmologies

Hayyim Pulido-Hernández, Jorge L. Cervantes-Cota · 2026

Read Negative Masses and Spatial Curvature: Alleviating Neutrino Mass Tensions in Λ \Lambda CDM and Extended Cosmologies by Hayyim Pulido-Hernández, Jorge L. Cervantes-Cota (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-13208.txt.

Introduction

Hayyim Pulido-Hernández and Jorge L. Cervantes-Cota test how spatial curvature affects limits on neutrino mass. Their joint analysis uses CMB, BAO, and supernova data from recent major surveys. A symmetric extension lets the effective neutrino mass take negative values, which softens prior bias near zero. Adding curvature shifts the posterior and eases the tension with the terrestrial lower limit. The most flexible model eases tension further but weakens the precision of the mass estimate. Bounds, they conclude, hinge on boundary effects and geometric degeneracies.

Catalog record

CREATORHayyim Pulido-Hernández, Jorge L. Cervantes-Cota
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46799
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.13208

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Negative Masses and Spatial Curvature: Alleviating Neutrino Mass Tensions in Λ \Lambda CDM and Extended Cosmologies Hayyim Pulido-Hernández, Jorge L. Cervantes-Cota Abstract We investigate the impact of spatial curvature, Ω k \Omega_{k} , and dynamical dark energy on the cosmological constraints of the neutrino mass sum, ∑ m ν \sum m_{\nu} . Using a joint analysis of the latest CMB (Planck and ACT DR6), BAO (DESI DR2) and SNe Ia (DESY5 and DES-Dovekie) datasets, we perform an exploration of the neutrino mass parameter space. To mitigate prior-driven biases near the physical boundary, we implement a symmetric extension wrapper that allows for effective negative masses. We find that the inclusion of spatial curvature significantly modifies the posterior distributions, exhibiting a smooth transition across the ∑ m ν = 0 \sum m_{\nu}=0 threshold. In the Λ \Lambda CDM + Ω k \Omega_{k} + ∑ m ν , e ​ f ​ f \sum m_{\nu,eff} framework, we obtain ∑ m ν , e ​ f ​ f = − 0.011 − 0.050 + 0.052 \sum m_{\nu,eff}=-0.011^{+0.052}_{-0.050} , reducing the tension with the terrestrial lower limit of 0.06 0.06 eV from 2.59 ​ σ 2.59\sigma for the Λ \Lambda CDM + ∑ m ν , e ​ f ​ f \sum m_{\nu,eff} model to 1.17 ​ σ 1.17\sigma . For the most flexible scenario ω 0 ​ ω a \omega_{0}\omega_{a} CDM + Ω k \Omega_{k} + ∑ m ν , e ​ f ​ f \sum m_{\nu,eff} , we find ∑ m ν , e ​ f ​ f = − 0.07 ± 0.11 \sum m_{\nu,eff}=-0.07\pm 0.11 with a tension of 1.13 ​ σ 1.13\sigma , illustrating how the increased parameter freedom notably degrades the precision of the mass estimate compared to simpler extensions. Our results demonstrate that current cosmological bounds on ∑ m ν \sum m_{\nu} are heavily influenced by boundary effects and geometric degeneracies. I Introduction The standard model of cosmology assumes its visible components are baryons and photons, from which we have an overwhelming direct evidence, and it also adds dark matter and dark energy, from which we perceive only its gravitational effects. The last piece is neutrinos; they are known to possess mass. Recent results from the ground-based neutrino oscillation experiments pose, on the one hand, a lower bound \sum m_{\nu}>0.059 eV for normal mass ordering and \sum m_{\nu}>0.1 eV for inverted mass ordering Esteban et al. 2024 . On the other hand, an upper bound comes from the KATRIN experiment, that when combined with oscillation results, leads to the limit \sum m_{\nu}<1.35 eV at 90\% cl. Aker et al. 2019 ; Aker et al. 2022 ; Collaboration† et al. 2025 . The determination of neutrino mass through cosmological observables has been an active and fruitful area of research for decades. Since the first estimate in 1966 using astronomical measurements Gershtein and Zeldovich 1966 , followed by the first measurement using modern methodology in 1999 Croft et al. 1999 , both the precision and volume of available data have increased significantly. Today, the availability of large-scale datasets and enhanced computational power allow cosmologists to test a wide range of data and model combinations, aiming to resolve the inconsistencies currently present in the standard cosmological model. Neutrino masses enter naturally in discussion since they provoke effects in the Hubble expansion rate, CMB power spectra, and clustering properties of large scale structure. The measurement of neutrino masses has thus become a central objective of major astronomical collaborations. However, as cosmological data have reached unprecedented precision, a new challenge has emerged: the neutrino mass sum inferred from cosmological observables is in significant tension with the lower bounds established by terrestrial experiments. In fact, posterior probabilities resulting from the cosmological inference in the \Lambda CDM model seem to prefer negative values. This is not a recent artifact, as early results from the Planck collaboration already hinted at this trend Ade et al. 2014 , which has been only amplified with subsequent data releases Palanque-Delabrouille et al. 2015 ; Alam et al. 2021 ; Aiola et al. 2020 ; Di Valentino et al. 2022 . Most recently, the DESI collaboration has reported the most stringent constraints to date, which simultaneously represent the highest level of tension with local measurements Abdul Karim et al. 2025 ; Elbers et al. 2025 . On the other hand, the DESI results also indicate a preference for alternative dark energy models, specifically the Chevallier-Polarski-Linder (CPL, also named \omega_{0}\omega_{a} CDM) parameterization Chevallier and Polarski 2001 ; Linder 2003 . This parametrization, however, changes the inferred value of the matter energy density ( \Omega_{m} ), that in turn affects the neutrino mass. The synergy between DESI’s precise \Omega_{m} measurements and additional datasets, such as CMB, CMB Lensing, and Supernovae type Ia (SN Ia), allows for the breaking of key parameter degeneracies, most notably for the present work, those involving spatial curvature, \Omega_{k} . While the flat-Universe baseline model is standard, treating \Omega_{k} as a free parameter significantly impacts the total matter density and, consequently, the inferred \sum m_{\nu} . Recent investigations have demonstrated that exploring curved cosmologies can effectively mitigate the tension with terrestrial constraints Chen and Zaldarriaga 2025 . Alongside by these developments, this work provides a comprehensive extension to the current literature by analyzing the \omega_{0}\omega_{a} CDM framework in conjunction with the spatial curvature and also exploring the negative neutrino mass scenario. Although a negative mass is physically nonsensical within the current paradigm, it serves as a valuable phenomenological approach to identify the directions in which current datasets pull the model. To this end, we adopt and numerically implement the methodology proposed in Ref. Elbers et al. 2025 for an effective neutrino mass sum. The structure of this work is organized as follow: Section II discusses the cosmological role of neutrinos and their interplay with our chosen datasets. Section III details the numerical implementation of the effective neutrino mass and the sampling configuration. Our main findings are presented and discussed in Section IV . In Section V we summarize our findings and conclude. Finally, Appendix A reports relevant results utilizing the most recent supernova recalibration. II Neutrino mass effects, cosmic probes, and models Although terrestrial experiments can impose upper Aker et al. 2019 ; Aker et al. 2022 ; Collaboration† et al. 2025 or lower de Salas et al. 2021 ; Capozzi et al. 2021 ; Esteban et al. 2024 bounds on the sum of neutrino masses, the most restrictive constraints arise from cosmological measurements Elbers et al. 2025 ; Calabrese et al. 2025 . Through the evolution of the Universe, neutrinos are the only particles that transition from relativistic behavior in the early Universe to behaving as cold dark matter in the late Universe. This transition affects the dynamics in various ways, modifying the cosmological observables. The bounds imposed by terrestrial measurements imply that neutrinos begin to behave as dark matter well after the epoch of recombination. Consequently, neutrinos have two primary implications in Large Scale Structure Loverde and Weiner 2024 : they modify the geometry of the Universe and suppress the growth of large-scale structure. When influencing the cosmic geometry, neutrinos modify the cosmological distances. For the background evolution, a fundamental expression is the Friedmann equation, which takes

Read the complete text