When Dark Energy Turns On: Constraints on a Critical Emergence Model
Mahdi Najafi, Mahdi Habibollahi, Masoume Reyhani, Eleonora Di Valentino, Supriya Pan, Javad T. Firouzjaee, Weiqiang Yang · 2026
Read When Dark Energy Turns On: Constraints on a Critical Emergence Model by Mahdi Najafi, Mahdi Habibollahi, Masoume Reyhani, Eleonora Di Valentino, Supriya Pan, Javad T. Firouzjaee, Weiqiang Yang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-13137.txt.
Introduction
Mahdi Najafi and co-authors constrain a model where dark energy switches on late, through a phase transition. In this critically emergent picture, dark energy is absent early and matters only after a set epoch. They fit it to microwave background, baryon acoustic oscillation, and supernova data. Several data mixes favor a nonzero transition point over the standard model. Statistical gauges back that edge in those mixes. The model does not fully ease the Hubble tension, though.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mahdi Najafi, Mahdi Habibollahi, Masoume Reyhani, Eleonora Di Valentino, Supriya Pan, Javad T. Firouzjaee, Weiqiang Yang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48184 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.13137
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
When Dark Energy Turns On: Constraints on a Critical Emergence Model Mahdi Najafi, Mahdi Habibollahi, Masoume Reyhani, Eleonora Di Valentino, Supriya Pan, Javad T. Firouzjaee, Weiqiang Yang Abstract We investigate a specific emergent dark energy scenario, known as critically emergent dark energy (CEDE), in which dark energy is effectively absent in the early Universe and becomes dynamically relevant only after a critical cosmic epoch through a phase transition. We constrain this model using recent cosmological observations, including cosmic microwave background (CMB) data from Planck 2018, baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) measurements from SDSS and DESI DR2, and two independent Type Ia supernova compilations, PantheonPlus and Union3. Our results show that within the CEDE framework a dark energy phase transition is not ruled out. In particular, CMB-only, CMB+SDSS, and CMB+DESI datasets provide evidence for a nonzero transition scale factor and, according to standard statistical indicators such as Δ χ 2 \Delta\chi^{2} and Bayesian evidence, can favor CEDE over the Λ \Lambda CDM model. At the same time, we find that CEDE does not fully resolve the Hubble constant tension. Overall, our analysis indicates that dark energy models featuring a phase transition remain a viable and phenomenologically interesting extension of the standard cosmological framework. Upcoming high-precision cosmological surveys will be essential to further assess whether such emergent dark energy scenarios represent a genuine departure from Λ \Lambda CDM or an effective description of current data. I Introduction The standard cosmological model, \Lambda -Cold Dark Matter ( \Lambda CDM), provides a remarkably successful and economical description of the Universe, accurately fitting a wide range of high-precision cosmological observations. Within the framework of Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity (GR), \Lambda CDM assumes the presence of a cosmological constant \Lambda , interpreted as dark energy (DE), together with cold dark matter (CDM) and ordinary matter. Despite its empirical success, the physical nature of both DE and CDM remains unknown, and their apparent independent conservation lacks a fundamental explanation. Moreover, \Lambda CDM faces long-standing conceptual challenges, most notably the cosmological constant problem 260 and the cosmic coincidence problem 272 . Beyond these theoretical issues, recent years have seen the emergence of significant observational tensions that challenge the internal consistency of the \Lambda CDM framework. Among them, the most prominent is the Hubble constant tension 254 ; 82 ; 80 ; 188 ; 219 ; 228 ; 1 ; 85 ; 137 ; 106 ; 127 ; 255 ; 73 ; 83 ; 176 , namely the statistically significant discrepancy between the value of the present-day expansion rate inferred from early-Universe probes and that obtained from direct late-Universe measurements. This discrepancy first exceeded the 5\sigma level when comparing the Hubble constant inferred from Planck Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) observations, interpreted within the \Lambda CDM framework 11 , with local distance-ladder measurements from the SH0ES collaboration 203 . More recently, the tension has further increased. By combining CMB measurements from Planck , SPT-3G , and ACT 11 ; 9 ; 13 ; 158 ; 55 , and comparing them with a homogeneous compilation of direct late-Universe determinations assembled by the H 0 Distance Network (H0DN), the discrepancy has reached approximately 7.1\sigma 57 , representing the most robust manifestation of the Hubble constant tension to date. The persistence of this early-late discrepancy is particularly intriguing because the late-Universe determinations rely on a broad range of independent observational techniques and astrophysical systems, yet consistently converge on higher values of H_{0} 94 ; 43 ; 203 ; 32 ; 221 ; 136 ; 28 ; 95 ; 252 ; 128 ; 149 ; 189 ; 140 ; 218 ; 46 ; 70 ; 166 ; 50 ; 93 ; 204 ; 257 ; 224 ; 214 ; 47 ; 223 ; 150 ; 134 ; 205 ; 39 ; 169 ; 243 ; 57 ; 12 ; 41 . Reconciling this discrepancy within a single cosmological framework has proven extremely challenging and has motivated extensive exploration of physics beyond \Lambda CDM. Proposed explanations span a wide range of physical mechanisms. These include extensions of the standard cosmological parameter space 79 , modifications of gravity 141 ; 51 ; 173 ; 78 ; 273 ; 174 ; 7 ; 69 ; 192 ; 23 ; 33 ; 217 ; 241 ; 247 ; 122 ; 261 ; 191 ; 165 ; 88 ; 131 ; 242 ; 53 ; 104 ; 18 ; 15 ; 123 ; 133 , vacuum phase transitions 77 , evolving or late-time dark energy scenarios 87 ; 258 ; 14 ; 81 ; 84 ; 266 ; 76 ; 120 ; 106 ; 8 ; 111 ; 144 ; 143 ; 49 ; 245 ; 135 ; 163 ; 240 ; 179 ; 145 , early-Universe solutions such as early dark energy 197 ; 235 ; 170 ; 142 ; 219 ; 269 ; 194 ; 171 ; 71 ; 198 ; 67 ; 172 ; 253 ; 89 ; 232 ; 58 ; 98 ; 107 ; 102 ; 196 ; 187 ; 139 ; 195 ; 236 , late-time or local transitions in the expansion history 75 ; 26 ; 212 ; 96 ; 211 , dark energy models with negative energy density or sign-switching behavior 14 ; 256 ; 268 ; 54 ; 21 ; 226 ; 72 ; 20 ; 177 ; 19 ; 30 ; 8 ; 18 ; 116 ; 29 ; 17 ; 263 ; 184 ; 112 ; 248 ; 113 ; 22 ; 239 ; 238 ; 16 ; 90 ; 48 ; 100 , emergent dark energy scenarios 182 ; 264 ; 265 , solutions involving dark matter or neutrino physics 74 ; 31 ; 181 ; 27 ; 65 ; 4 , and modifications to the physics of recombination 117 ; 118 ; 225 ; 119 ; 146 ; 64 ; 115 ; 114 ; 37 ; 227 ; 164 ; 160 ; 248 ; 220 ; 233 ; 97 ; 249 . Despite their diversity, these approaches share the common goal of reconciling early- and late-Universe determinations of the Hubble constant within a consistent cosmological framework. In parallel with the Hubble constant tension, recent large-scale structure measurements have provided independent evidence pointing toward departures from a cosmological constant. In particular, the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) 6 ; 3 has reported a preference for dynamical dark energy (DDE) when Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) measurements are combined with Type Ia supernova (SNIa) data. Assuming the Chevallier-Polarski-Linder (CPL) 63 ; 154 parametrization of the dark energy equation of state, this preference reaches a statistical significance of approximately 3.2 - 3.4\sigma 193 ; 126 and remains stable across successive SNIa data reanalysis. Although this evidence is intrinsically model dependent and parametrization driven, it has been widely explored in the literature using different combinations of cosmological datasets and alternative dark energy parametrizations 157 ; 6 ; 3 ; 66 ; 230 ; 159 ; 101 ; 86 ; 167 ; 259 ; 267 ; 244 ; 56 ; 185 ; 92 ; 156 ; 42 ; 200 ; 162 ; 105 ; 201 ; 108 ; 186 ; 151 ; 135 ; 207 ; 148 ; 262 ; 229