The Bianchi IX Attractor in Modified Gravity

Ester Beatriz*, Everaldo Bonotto* and Phillipo Lappicy** · 2026

Read The Bianchi IX Attractor in Modified Gravity by Ester Beatriz*, Everaldo Bonotto* and Phillipo Lappicy** (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-13104.txt.

Introduction

Ester Beatriz and co-authors prove a Mixmaster attractor result for Bianchi IX models in modified gravity. The theories in view, like Hořava-Lifshitz and f(R), perturb the general relativity case by one parameter. General relativity returns at the mid value of that range. For higher values, all type IX solutions converge to the Mixmaster attractor. That set joins Kasner states with heteroclinic chains of type II solutions. Unlike relativity, no rival limit set appears here.

Catalog record

CREATOREster Beatriz*, Everaldo Bonotto* and Phillipo Lappicy**
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51085
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.13104

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Bianchi IX Attractor in Modified Gravity Ester Beatriz*, Everaldo Bonotto* and Phillipo Lappicy** Abstract We consider vacuum anisotropic spatially homogeneous models in certain modified gravity theories (such as Hořava–Lifshitz, λ \lambda – R R or f ⁡ ( R ) f(R) gravity), which are expected to describe generic spacelike singularities for these theories. These models perturb the well-known Bianchi models in general relativity (GR) by a parameter v ∈ ( 0 , 1 ) v\in(0,1) with GR recovered at v = 1 / 2 v=1/2 . We prove an analogue of the well-known Ringström attractor theorem in GR to the supercritical theories: for any v ∈ ( 1 / 2 , 1 ) v\in(1/2,1) , all solutions of Bianchi type IX \mathrm{IX} converge to an analogue of the Mixmaster attractor, consisting of Bianchi type I solutions (Kasner states) and heteroclinic chains of Bianchi type II solutions. In contrast to GR, there are no solutions that converge to a different set other than the Mixmaster (such as the locally rotationally symmetric solutions in GR). Keywords: Ordinary Differential Equations; Dynamical Systems; Global Attractor; Cosmology; Spacelike Singularity; Modified Gravity. MSC 2020: 34D45, 37G35, 37N20, 83C20, 83C75, 83D05. \ast ICMC, Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil \ast \ast Universidad Complutense de Madrid and ICMAT, Spain 1 Introduction The Belinski, Khalatnikov and Lifshitz (BKL) picture suggests that generic singularities in general relativity (GR) are: (i) vacuum dominated , (ii) local and (iii) oscillatory . In this regard, vacuum spatially homogeneous anisotropic cosmologies, the Bianchi models, are expected to play a key role in the dynamical asymptotic behaviour, see [ 23 , 4 , 5 , 15 , 31 , 32 , 10 ] . Similarly, the vacuum anisotropic spatially homogeneous Bianchi models derived in [ 16 ] are expected to describe generic singularities in certain modified higher-order gravity theories, such as Hořava-Lifshitz, \lambda - R or f(R) -gravity, see [ 17 , 18 , 1 , 24 , 13 , 27 , 11 , 28 , 9 ] . Indeed, it is heuristically argued that there is an ‘asymptotically dominant’ curvature term in Hilbert–Einstein action toward the initial singularity, yielding a respective dominant Bianchi model. More importantly, it is expected that such models provide new insights in GR. The dominant vacuum Bianchi models in Hořava gravity are given by (1.1a) \displaystyle\Sigma_{\alpha}^{\prime} \displaystyle=4v(1-\Sigma^{2})\Sigma_{\alpha}+{\cal S}_{\alpha}, (1.1b) \displaystyle N_{\alpha}^{\prime} \displaystyle=-2(2v\Sigma^{2}+\Sigma_{\alpha})N_{\alpha}, for \alpha=1,2,3 , with parameter v\in(0,1) , and the constraints, (1.1c) \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle=1-\Sigma^{2}-\Omega_{k}, (1.1d) \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle=\Sigma_{1}+\Sigma_{2}+\Sigma_{3}, where (1.2a) \displaystyle\Sigma^{2} \displaystyle:=\frac{1}{6}\left(\Sigma_{1}^{2}+\Sigma_{2}^{2}+\Sigma_{3}^{2}\right), (1.2b) \displaystyle\Omega_{k} \displaystyle:=N_{1}^{2}+N_{2}^{2}+N_{3}^{2}-2N_{1}N_{2}-2N_{2}N_{3}-2N_{3}N_{1}, (1.2c) \displaystyle{\cal S}_{\alpha} \displaystyle:=-4[(N_{\beta}-N_{\gamma})^{2}-N_{\alpha}(2N_{\alpha}-N_{\beta}-N_{\gamma})]. Here (\alpha\beta\gamma) is a permutation of (123) . Note that (.){}^{\prime}=d/d\tau denotes the derivative with respect to the chosen time variable, \tau_{-} , which is in the opposite direction of physical time. Hence, for expanding models, \tau_{-}\rightarrow\infty describes the dynamics toward the initial singularity. The Bianchi type of a solution of system ( 1.1 ) is determined by the signs of the N -variables, which are invariant under the flow. This provides a stratification of phase-space by invariant sets of increasing dimension. Bianchi type \mathrm{I} consists of all N_{\alpha} being zero (constituting a circle of equilibria), Bianchi type \mathrm{II} consists of a single non-zero N_{\alpha} (yielding a hemisphere containing heteroclinic orbits between the equilibria of type \mathrm{I} ), Bianchi types \mathrm{VI}_{0},\mathrm{VII}_{0} consist of two non-zero N_{\alpha} , and Bianchi types \mathrm{VIII},\mathrm{IX} consist of three non-zero N_{\alpha} . See Table 1.1 . Bianchi type {N}_{\alpha} {N}_{\beta} {N}_{\gamma} Dimension \mathrm{IX} + + + 4 \mathrm{VIII} - + + 4 \mathrm{VII}_{0} 0 + + 3 \mathrm{VI}_{0} 0 - + 3 II 0 0 + 2 I 0 0 0 1 Table 1.1: The Bianchi types are invariant subsets of phase-space characterized by the zeros and signs of the variables (N_{\alpha},N_{\beta},N_{\gamma}) , where (\alpha\beta\gamma) is a permutation of (123) . There are equivalent representations associated with an overall change of sign. Equations ( 1.1 ) describe vacuum spatially homogeneous models in GR when v=1/2 , and therefore v\in(0,1) denotes perturbations of GR. The dynamics of the ODEs ( 1.1 ) in GR, when v=1/2 , has been extensively considered in the literature. A major achievement is the attractor theorem by H. Ringström, which states that the \omega -limit set of generic solutions of Bianchi type IX is contained in the space of solutions of Bianchi types I and II, see [ 26 , 14 ] . Therefore, it is expected that the concatenation of heteroclinic orbits of Bianchi type II and the induced map of Bianchi type I (the so-called BKL map ) play a key role in the dynamics. Stability of some concatenations can be found in [ 2 , 21 , 22 , 6 , 3 ] . For an overview, see [ 15 ] . In the case that v\neq 1/2 , some of the features of GR persist. In particular, the Bianchi hierarchy of invariant sets remains valid depending on whether the variables N_{\alpha} are nonzero. Bianchi type \mathrm{I} consists of all N_{\alpha} being zero, Bianchi type II consists of a single non-zero N_{\alpha} , Bianchi types \mathrm{VI}_{0},\mathrm{VII}_{0} consist of two non-zero N_{\alpha} , and Bianchi types \mathrm{VIII},\mathrm{IX} consist of three non-zero N_{\alpha} . The authors in [ 16 ] describe the dynamics of the types \mathrm{I},\mathrm{II},\mathrm{VI}_{0},\mathrm{VII}_{0} for all v\in(0,1) . In particular, it is shown that in GR, v=1/2 , is a bifurcation where chaos becomes generic; see also [ 19 ] . A counter-example of the BKL conjecture was found when v=0 , where there are periodic orbits that are far from the Mixmaster attractor, see [ 8 ] . We prove that in the Bianchi type IX supercritical case, v\in(1/2,1) , the global attractor, {\cal A}_{-} , consists of Bianchi types \mathrm{I} and \mathrm{II} . Our main result is stated as follows. Theorem 1.1 . For the supercritical case, v\in(1/2,1) , all Bianchi type IX solutions converge (as \tau_{-}\rightarrow\infty ) to the Bianchi types \mathrm{I} and \mathrm{II} subsets. We emphasize that there is no meagre set that does not converge to Bianchi types \mathrm{I} and \mathrm{II} , as the locally rotationally symmetric set when v=1/2 . Note that we do not settle [ 16 , Conjecture 7.4] that claims that there is a stable set S of Bianchi type \mathrm{I} solutions which is the generic attractor. Indeed, we expect that generic solutions do not oscillate following types \mathrm{I} and \mathrm{II} solutions, since infinite heteroclinic chains of types \mathrm{I} and \mathrm{II} that do not converge to the stable subset S form to a Cantor set, which should only possess a codimension 1 (non-generic) stable manifold; see [ 16 ] . However, we cannot prove such a result using the current methods. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 explicitly describes the hierarchy of invariant sets of the Bianchi models by their increasing dimension. Section 3 presents concluding remarks and open problems. 2 Bianchi Hierarchy We describe the stratification of invariant sets by increasing dimension; see Table 1.1 . We rewrite ( 1.1 ) using Misner variables \Sigma_{1}=-2\Sigma_{+},\Sigma_{2}=\Sigma_{+}+\sqrt{3}\Sigma_{-},\Sigma_{3}=\Sigma_{+}-\sqrt{3}\Sigma_{-} : (2.1a) \displaystyle\Sigma_{+}^{\prime} \displaystyle=4v(1-\Sigma^{2})\Sigma_{+}+\,{\cal S}_{+}, (2.1b) \displaystyle\Sigma_{-}^{\prime} \displaystyle=4v(1-\Sigma^{2})\Sigma_{-}+\,{\cal S}_{-}, (2.1c) \displaystyle N_{1}^{\prime} \displaystyle=-2(2v\Sigma^{2}-2\Sigma_{+})\,N_{1}, (2.1d) \displaystyle N_{2}^{\prime} \displaystyle=-2(2v\Sigma^{2}+\Sigma_{+}+\sqrt{3}\Sigma_{-})N_{2}, (2.1e) \displaystyle N_{3}^{\prime} \displaystyle=-2(2v\Sigma^{2}+\Sigma_{+}-\sqrt{3}\Sigma_{-})N_{3}, bound to the following constraint: (2.2) 1=\Sigma^{2}+N_{1}^{2}+N_{2}^{2}+N_{3}^{2}-2N_{1}N_{2}-2N_{2}N_{3}-2N_{3}N_{1}, which restricts the phase-space \mathbb{R}^{5} to a four-dimensional

Read the complete text