Competition-Aware CPC Forecasting with Near-Market Coverage
Sebastian Frey *, Edoardo Beccari *, Maximilian Kranz *, Nicolò Alberto Pellizzari *, Ali Mete Karaman *, Qiwei Han *, Maximilian Kaiser † · 2026
Read Competition-Aware CPC Forecasting with Near-Market Coverage by Sebastian Frey *, Edoardo Beccari *, Maximilian Kranz *, Nicolò Alberto Pellizzari *, Ali Mete Karaman *, Qiwei Han *, Maximilian Kaiser † (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-13059.txt.
Introduction
Sebastian Frey and co-authors forecast cost-per-click in paid search with competition in the model, not just past bids. A single advertiser sees only part of the auction landscape that sets prices. From 1.66 billion Google Ads records, they built weekly series for a car-rental market. Semantic and behavioral neighborhoods plus geographic traits proxy the rival field. Graph models won at one week, while covariate-fed foundation models won at longer horizons. Gains clustered on pricey, volatile keywords where errors cost most.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sebastian Frey *, Edoardo Beccari *, Maximilian Kranz *, Nicolò Alberto Pellizzari *, Ali Mete Karaman *, Qiwei Han *, Maximilian Kaiser † |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38012 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.13059
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Competition-Aware CPC Forecasting with Near-Market Coverage Sebastian Frey *, Edoardo Beccari *, Maximilian Kranz *, Nicolò Alberto Pellizzari *, Ali Mete Karaman *, Qiwei Han *, Maximilian Kaiser † Abstract Cost-per-click (CPC) in paid search is a volatile auction outcome generated by a competitive landscape that is only partially observable from any single advertiser’s history. Using Google Ads auction logs from a concentrated car-rental market (2021–2023), we forecast weekly CPC for 1,811 keyword series and approximate latent competition through complementary signals derived from keyword text, CPC trajectories, and geographic market structure. We construct (i) semantic neighborhoods and a semantic keyword graph from pretrained transformer-based representations of keyword text, (ii) behavioral neighborhoods via Dynamic Time Warping (DTW) alignment of CPC trajectories, and (iii) geographic-intent covariates capturing localized demand and marketplace heterogeneity. We extensively evaluate these signals both as stand-alone covariates and as relational priors in spatiotemporal graph forecasters, benchmarking them against strong statistical, neural, and time-series foundation-model baselines. Across methods, competition-aware augmentation improves stability and error profiles at business-relevant medium and longer horizons, where competitive regimes shift and volatility is most consequential. The results show that broad market-outcome coverage, combined with keyword-derived semantic and geographic priors, provides a scalable way to approximate latent competition and improve CPC forecasting in auction-driven markets. 1 Introduction Paid search advertising allocates sponsored placements through real-time auctions triggered by user queries, and advertisers typically pay under a cost-per-click (CPC) pricing scheme ( 18 ; 9 ; 15 ) . In sponsored search, CPC is not a fixed tariff but an auction-generated outcome determined by bid-dependent ranking, platform-estimated quality signals, and query-specific auction conditions ( 20 ; 11 ; 22 ) . For advertisers, this creates a difficult forecasting problem: CPC directly determines how much demand a fixed budget can buy, yet the competitive conditions that generate CPC are only partially observable from any single advertiser’s data. Forecasting CPC is difficult precisely because of this partial observability. Advertisers can observe realized CPC, clicks, impressions, and spend, but they cannot directly observe competitor bids, competitor quality signals, or the full auction state underlying price formation ( 11 ) . As a result, the observed CPC series contains only an indirect and noisy trace of the competitive landscape. This limits the effectiveness of purely autoregressive forecasting approaches, especially at medium and longer horizons where regime shifts, localized demand changes, and competitor reallocation become more important than short-run inertia. More broadly, while the sponsored-search literature has extensively characterized ranking and pricing mechanisms in generalized second-price environments ( 13 ; 24 ) , it offers more limited guidance for forecasting under these conditions of indirect competition observability. To address this limitation, we approximate latent competition through observable competition proxies . The key idea is that competition leaves different observable traces: semantic similarity captures substitutable intent, CPC trajectory alignment captures shared behavioral exposure, and localized query intent captures spatially segmented market structure. Using large-scale Google Ads auction logs from the car-rental sector, we operationalize these traces through semantic neighborhoods and a fixed semantic keyword graph, Dynamic Time Warping (DTW)-based behavioral neighborhoods, and geographic-intent covariates that encode localized demand and competitive heterogeneity. Together, these signals provide a scalable approximation to the competitive conditions that are not directly observable from any single advertiser’s history. The car-rental sector provides a particularly suitable empirical setting for this problem because demand is geographically localized, acquisition costs are operationally important, and competition is concentrated among a relatively small set of major advertisers. The raw dataset contains approximately 1.66 billion advertising logs and, after preprocessing and temporal filtering, yields a weekly panel of 1,811 keywords observed over 127 weeks. This scale does not imply full market observability. Rather, it creates a setting that is still partially observed but sufficiently dense to learn structured competition signals from realized outcomes, making it well suited to test whether proxy-based competition modeling improves forecasting in practice. Our contribution is therefore architectural only in a limited sense; the main novelty lies instead in domain-informed proxy construction and forecasting design under partial observability. We benchmark a broad model universe spanning classical statistical and machine-learning baselines, time-series foundation models (including Chronos-2, TimeGPT, and Moirai), and spatiotemporal graph neural networks. We evaluate competition proxies both as exogenous covariates and as relational priors. The most consistent gains emerge at business-relevant medium and longer horizons, where competition-aware augmentation improves stability and error profiles relative to stronger univariate or weakly contextual baselines. Beyond average forecast accuracy, we show that the value of competition-aware forecasting is concentrated in the hardest parts of the market. CPC dynamics are highly heterogeneous across keywords: some are relatively cheap and stable, while others are both expensive and volatile. This heterogeneity is economically important because forecasting failures on high-value, high-volatility keywords carry the greatest budget risk. We therefore complement aggregate evaluation with a competitive frontier perspective that links model performance to keyword-level CPC intensity and volatility, translating predictive gains into a more meaningful notion of operational robustness. The paper makes three contributions. First, it reframes CPC forecasting in paid search as a problem of partial competition observability, arguing that auction-generated prices can be forecast more effectively when latent competition is approximated through observable proxy structure. Second, it operationalizes this idea at industrial scale by constructing semantic, behavioral, and geographic competition proxies and evaluating them across a broad model universe spanning classical baselines, time-series foundation models, and spatiotemporal graph neural networks. Third, it provides substantive evidence that the value of competition-aware forecasting is horizon- and regime-dependent: geographic structure acts as a strong stabilizing prior for foundation models, semantic and graph-based structure are most useful for relational spillovers, and the largest gains concentrate in high-CPC, high-volatility keyword regimes. 2 Related Work CPC and paid search auctions. In Generalized Second Price (GSP) auctions, ad slots are assigned by ranking advertisers on an effective score that combines bids with platform-estimated quality factors ( 16 ; 6 ) . Realized CPC is therefore an endogenous auction outcome shaped by rival bids, click-through-rate (CTR) predictions, and latent demand shifts ( 1 ; 10 ) . A large literature has characterized these pricing and ranking mechanisms, as well as the role of CTR estimation in sponsored search ( 32 ) . However, this literature is more informative about how CPC is generated than about how CPC should be forecast when the competitive state is only indirectly observed from one advertiser’s data. The closest adjacent empirical work is ( 23 ) , which studies keyword-level CPC forecasting with competitive-landscape covariates, but does not evaluate foundation-style forecasters, does not construct text-derived relational structure, and does not compare covariate-based and graph-based routes within a unified forecasting framework. Time-series forecasting and foundation models. Classical baselines such as ARIMA and Prophet remain common reference points in business forecasting ( 27 ) , including advertising applications ( 23 ) , but they are often ill-suited to the nonlinear and non-stationary dynamics of auction-generated CPC series. Deep learning models, including LSTMs and Transformer-based forecasters, capture richer temporal structure ( 7 ; 28 ) , yet typically require task-specific training and careful feature design. More recently, time-series foundation models (TSFMs) such as TimeGPT ( 12 ) , Chronos ( 4 ) , and related pretrained forecasters have shown strong zero-shot and