Interrogating Design Homogenization in Web Vibe Coding ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06
Donghoon Shin, Alice Gao, Rock Yuren Pang, Jaewook Lee, Katharina Reinecke, Emily Tseng · 2026
Read Interrogating Design Homogenization in Web Vibe Coding ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06 by Donghoon Shin, Alice Gao, Rock Yuren Pang, Jaewook Lee, Katharina Reinecke, Emily Tseng (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-13036.txt.
Introduction
Donghoon Shin and co-authors interrogate design homogenization in web vibe coding, where lay creators prompt models instead of writing code. Generative tools tend to copy dominant styles from their training data. For web design, that pull may narrow the range of sites online. The authors map the vibe coding lifecycle and mark stages where sameness can creep in. A sociotechnical risk analysis then unpacks the harms. Their fix centers on productive friction that pushes creators to challenge default outputs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Donghoon Shin, Alice Gao, Rock Yuren Pang, Jaewook Lee, Katharina Reinecke, Emily Tseng |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62342 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.13036
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Interrogating Design Homogenization in Web Vibe Coding ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06 Donghoon Shin, Alice Gao, Rock Yuren Pang, Jaewook Lee, Katharina Reinecke, Emily Tseng Abstract . Generative AI is known for its tendency to homogenize, often reproducing dominant style conventions found in training data. However, it remains unclear how these homogenizing effects extend to complex structural tasks like web design. As lay creators increasingly turn to LLMs to ‘vibe-code’ websites—prompting for aesthetic and functional goals rather than writing code—they may inadvertently narrow the diversity of their designs, and limit creative expression throughout the internet. In this paper, we interrogate the possibility of design homogenization in web vibe coding. We first characterize the vibe coding lifecycle, pinpointing stages where homogenization risks may arise. We then conduct a sociotechnical risk analysis unpacking the potential harms of web vibe coding and their interaction with design homogenization. We identify that the push for frictionless generation can exacerbate homogenization and its harms. Finally, we propose a mitigation framework centered on the idea of productive friction . Through case studies at the micro, meso, and macro levels, we show how centering productive friction can empower creators to challenge default outputs and preserve diverse expression in AI-mediated web design. 1. Introduction The rise of generative AI has transformed creative expression, enabling a broader range of individuals, or lay creators , to craft digital artifacts without technical expertise. This shift has given rise to the emerging practice of vibe coding , where creators use high-level, informal prompts to convey a desired vibe ( 56 ; 55 ) , relying on large language models (LLMs) to interpret these abstractions into functional websites. This workflow promises to democratize web development by leveraging LLMs’ capabilities in rapid prototyping and aesthetic interpretation ( 56 ) . However, this convenience comes with a trade-off; by offloading structural and aesthetic decisions to AI models, lay creators increasingly depend on the latent patterns embedded within the AI to fill in their creative gaps. This reliance offers a new and urgent site of inquiry. The spread of web vibe coding means generative AI is increasingly used to construct the web interfaces through which people connect, work, transact, and live; however, those same AI systems are known for their tendency to reproduce dominant style conventions found in training data ( 2 ) . Primarily trained on English-centric datasets ( 31 ; 10 ) , such models often align with Western aesthetic conventions ( 47 ; 3 ; 31 ; 36 ) . While these biases are well-documented in domains such as text ( 54 ; 80 ) and image generation ( 45 ; 37 ; 49 ) , it is unclear how they manifest in interactive creative domains like web development. Richness in creative expression relies on the creator’s diverse perspectives ( 77 ) , and replacing intentional choices with probabilistic defaults risks accelerating design homogenization—a convergence toward the mean, dominant aesthetic ( 66 ; 12 ) . We posit that vibe coding may accelerate design homogenization by creating a direct pathway from a model’s latent biases to finished creative work, especially when the mechanisms of generation prioritize speed over distinctiveness. In this paper, we interrogate design homogenization in web vibe coding, unpacking its conceptual underpinnings to anticipate and potentially mitigate its risks. We first characterize the vibe coding lifecycle by systematically reviewing academic and gray literature on the practice, and conducting walkthroughs of popular vibe coding tools. Our lifecycle breaks down vibe coding into stages—from user prompting to deployment—and identifies where homogenization risks may arise. Then, building on this lifecycle, we conduct a sociotechnical risk analysis adapting existing harm frameworks ( i.e. , ( 67 ; 78 ; 11 ; 62 ) ) to web vibe coding. Our analysis finds that LLMs’ tendencies towards homogenization work in tandem with mounting social pressures in the interaction design industry to create a sociotechnical environment encouraging creators to accept the path of least resistance. Risks, such as cognitive overload and overreliance on the vibe-coded design outputs, incentivize lay creators to accept the model’s default output rather than iterating on a diverse and creative design. We conclude by translating these insights into a mitigation strategy that challenges the paradigm of frictionless design ( 33 ; 22 ; 1 ; 19 ) . We argue that addressing the potential homogenization requires introducing productive friction into the vibe coding workflow. Moving away from a frictionless paradigm where LLMs execute plans automatically, we propose frameworks where the model acts as a mediator, explicitly querying design assumptions and presenting alternatives before finalizing output. We structure these across three layers: micro (individual creator), meso (organization), and macro (ecosystem). By shifting the goal from immediate output to interactive co-creation, we outline a research agenda for designing tools that empower creators to maintain diverse, authentic web aesthetics against the pressure of automation. We close by unpacking where, within this agenda, the communities around responsible technology can leverage its strengths to work in collaboration with allied communities in HCI and AI, in the subfield of human-AI interaction. In summary, this paper contributes: • A systematic review of academic and gray literature around vibe coding, resulting in a comprehensive characterization of the vibe coding lifecycle (§ 3 ), pinpointing stages where potential homogenization risks may intrude; • A risk analysis (§ 4 ) unpacking harms in vibe coding and their intersection with design homogenization, and identifying frictionless generation as an active contributor to homogenization; • A multi-level mitigation framework (§ 5 ) that proposes productive friction as a design intervention, offering case studies at the micro, meso, and macro levels, and offers a collaborative research agenda for teams of scholars across human-AI interaction. 2. Related Work 2.1. Harms and Homogenization in Generative AI In HCI, AI, and allied communities around responsible technology, the widespread consumer release of LLMs has driven a surge of work examining the societal risks and harms of generative AI. Open-ended interactions with current AI systems may shape perception, behavior, and social norms in ways that the stakeholders must understand to guide these systems toward positive ends ( 23 ; 73 ; 20 ) . As such, prior research has sought to taxonomize the range of generative AI harms. For example, Weidinger et al. ( 78 ) developed a taxonomy of ethical and social risks associated with language models, identifying six categories ( i.e. , discrimination, information hazards, misinformation, malicious uses, HCI harms, and environmental harms). Suresh & Guttag ( 67 ) examined harms across the full machine learning (ML) lifecycle to anticipate, prevent, and mitigate downstream effects. Identifying issues like historical, representation, and deployment bias, they emphasized that harms do not stem solely from data, but can arise at multiple stages of the ML pipeline, such as data collection, preparation, model development, evaluation, postprocessing, and deployment. In response, several recent studies have built on these broader characterizations of generative AI harms through in-depth studies in specific applications, thus revealing additional severe and persistent problems. For instance, Agarwal et al. ( 2 ) found that LLM writing assistants homogenize users’ output toward Western-preferred styles, thus diminishing cultural nuances. This homogenizing effect may compound with the risks on long-term creativity, as Kumar et al. ( 35 ) revealed that,