Perpetual Dialogues: A Computational Analysis of Voice–Guitar Interaction in Carlos Paredes’s Discography
2026
Read Perpetual Dialogues: A Computational Analysis of Voice–Guitar Interaction in Carlos Paredes’s Discography (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-12854.txt.
Introduction
Gilberto Bernardes and co-authors study how voice and guitar interact in the recordings of Carlos Paredes. This music comes from an oral tradition, so no scores exist for standard tools to use. Their method splits the sound into stems and adds harmonic models and beat-level traits. Eight tracks with four singers were checked for shared and unique patterns. Shared timing proved mostly track-specific, not common to all. Shifts lined up with form breaks and texture changes.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2026 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37805 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.12854
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Perpetual Dialogues: A Computational Analysis of Voice–Guitar Interaction in Carlos Paredes’s Discography Abstract Computational musicology enables systematic analysis of performative and structural traits in recorded music, yet existing approaches remain largely tailored to notated, score‑based repertoires. This study advances a methodology for analyzing voice–guitar interaction in Carlos Paredes’s vocal collaborations—an oral‑tradition context where compositional and performative layers co‑emerge. Using source‑separated stems, physics‑informed harmonic modelling, and beat‑level audio descriptors, we examine melodic, harmonic, and rhythmic relationships across eight recordings with four singers. Our commonality–diversity framework, combining multi‑scale correlation analysis with residual‑based detection of structural deviations, reveals that expressive coordination is predominantly piece‑specific rather than corpus‑wide. Diversity events systematically align with formal boundaries and textural shifts, demonstrating that the proposed approach can identify musically salient reorganizations with minimal human annotation. The framework further offers a generalizable computational strategy for repertoires without notated blueprints, extending Music Performance Analysis into oral-tradition and improvisation-inflected practices. 1 Introduction In ‘‘blueprint’’-driven performances—those relying on documented structures such as scores—interpretative decisions primarily involve nuanced changes in timing and dynamics while leaving compositional content intact. Music Performance Analysis (MPA) 1 1 1 While MPA extends beyond the analysis of musical audio and encompasses multiple dimensions such as visuals and staging, this study focuses on audio analysis. has traditionally focused on such contexts, comparing multiple performances of a shared blueprint to study expressive deviation and interpretative choice. This approach has naturally favored Western art music, where notated scores and extensive performance corpora enable systematic comparative analysis [ 26 , 24 ] . Conversely, MPA faces significant challenges when addressing repertoires rooted in oral transmission, popular music, or improvisation, where no explicit blueprint exists, and compositional and performative dimensions are inseparable [ 28 , 35 ] . In such practices, musical ideas emerge, evolve, and are shaped through performance itself, with recordings often capturing relatively stable realizations of these processes rather than interpretations of a pre-existing score [ 30 ] . Within this context, the work of Carlos Paredes provides a particularly revealing case. Widely recognized as a solo composer–performer, Paredes transformed the Portuguese guitar from a primarily accompaniment role into an autonomous musical voice, redefining the expressive potential of Portuguese musical traditions in the twentieth century. This aesthetic position emerged from a formative trajectory grounded in collective practice: born into a lineage of Coimbra guitarists, Paredes learned the instrument through oral transmission from his father, Artur Paredes, and began his career as a second guitarist in ensemble contexts, where he already demonstrated a marked tendency to reshape and elaborate accompaniments beyond conventional models [ 11 , 18 ] . The resulting tension between accompaniment and artistic autonomy underpins both his solo output and his vocal collaborations. Our work establishes the first steps toward the study of Carlos Paredes’s recorded vocal collaborations, some framed in the Portuguese Canção de Coimbra tradition, spanning his entire career. Although these collaborations represent only a small fraction of his largely solo discography, they provide a consistent and well-defined setting in which voice and Portuguese guitar form two stable interacting layers. We adopt audio content analysis to address both performative and structural dimensions, which—despite their somewhat artificial separation—help frame the agentic interplay through which compositional and interpretative processes co‑shape these works. By leveraging audio source separation, we isolate these two layers to enable independent analysis of their melodic, harmonic, and rhythmic characteristics. This approach allows us to explore how these layers interact across different works, revealing patterns of dialogue, contrast, and complementarity that define Paredes’s collaborative style. Our analytical framework centers on statistical tools that capture commonalities—through correlations and linear relationships—and diversity—through residual analysis and outlier detection. Given this perspective, our research addresses the following questions: (i) What performative and structural characteristics distinguish individual pieces, specific collaborations, and the corpus as a whole? (ii) What patterns of voice–guitar interaction—through commonality and diversity analysis—can be identified across Paredes’s collaborative recordings, and how do these patterns vary between recordings and collaborators? This work contributes to MPA in three key ways. First, it introduces an integrated framework that jointly models structural and performative dimensions in repertoires where no notated blueprint exists. Second, the approach combines source separation, physics‑informed harmonic descriptors, and multi‑scale statistical analysis to reveal interaction patterns that are otherwise obscured in polyphonic recordings. Third, by framing commonality and diversity through both correlations and residual‑based deviations, the method identifies not only stable expressive relationships but also structurally meaningful departures that align with perceptually salient musical events. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. Section 2 reviews relevant work in MPA, source separation, and structural analysis. Section 3 introduces the corpus of Paredes’s vocal collaborations. Section 4 presents the computational pipeline, including source separation, descriptor extraction, and statistical methods. Section 5 reports the assessment of our descriptors. Section 6 details the main analytical findings on melodic, harmonic, and rhythmic characteristics and their interactions. Section 7 provides a musicological interpretation of the results considering the broader context of Paredes’s artistic practice. Section 8 concludes with implications for the computational study of oral‑tradition–based repertoires and outlines directions for future work. 2 Related Work MPA has traditionally focused on score-based traditions where interpretative decisions involve nuanced changes in timing and dynamics while preserving notated compositional content [ 5 , 26 ] . Computational models of expressive performance enable systematic evaluation of performance hypotheses through quantitative analysis [ 5 ] . However, these approaches are fundamentally biased toward repertoires with explicit notational blueprints, making them less applicable to musical traditions rooted in oral transmission or improvisational practices [ 28 , 35 ] . In traditions where composition and performance are inseparable, such as jazz, popular music, and other orally transmitted practices, the continuum from strictly notated to fully improvised music reflects distinct music traditions and social dynamics [ 30 , 10 ] . In oral musical cultures, improvisation involves the internal process of recalling previously heard music rather than manipulating pre-existing notated material [ 35 ] . This distinction is particularly relevant for analyzing Carlos Paredes’s work within the Canção de Coimbra tradition, where compositional ideas emerge and crystallize through performance and recording rather than through predetermined scores [ 18 , 11 ] . Computational musicology has made substantial progress in automated music analysis through audio content descriptors and machine learning approaches [ 23 ] . Music source separation—the task of decomposing recordings into constituent instrumental or vocal components—has seen tremendous advancement with deep learning methods [ 8 ] . These techniques divide into model-based approaches that explicitly represent musical structure through repetition or harmonic patterns [ 32 ] , and data-driven deep learning methods that achieve state-of-the-art performance given sufficient training data [ 14 , 34 ] . Recent work has applied deep learning frameworks to specific vocal ensemble challenges, including the analysis of choral singing and multi-voice separation [ 7 ] . Following source separation, structural analysis techniques identify musical organization through repetition detection and pattern discovery [ 12 , 27 ] . The automatic extraction of repeating patterns enables music summarization, indexing, and structural segmentation [ 20 , 25 ] . These methods typically rely on self-similarity matrices computed from acoustic descriptors to detect recurring segments at multiple temporal scales. However, most computational approaches focus on identifying structural