Weibel Instability in Collisionless Plasmas Across Astrophysical and Laboratory Shocks Preprint: AIP/123-QED

Vivek Shrivastav, Mani K Chettri, Hemam D Singh, Britan Singh, Rupak Mukherjee · 2026

Read Weibel Instability in Collisionless Plasmas Across Astrophysical and Laboratory Shocks Preprint: AIP/123-QED by Vivek Shrivastav, Mani K Chettri, Hemam D Singh, Britan Singh, Rupak Mukherjee (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-12747.txt.

Introduction

Vivek Shrivastav and co-authors analyze the Weibel instability in collisionless plasmas across lab and astrophysical shocks. They use a cold-fluid approach in four regimes, from non-relativistic to relativistic and multi-species cases. Dispersion relations yield scaling laws for the peak growth rate and wavenumber. Relativistic effects cut growth, while species mix matters only in a narrow mass range. A laser experiment and two MMS bow shock crossings match the predicted filament scale well.

Catalog record

CREATORVivek Shrivastav, Mani K Chettri, Hemam D Singh, Britan Singh, Rupak Mukherjee
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48907
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.12747

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Weibel Instability in Collisionless Plasmas Across Astrophysical and Laboratory Shocks Preprint: AIP/123-QED Vivek Shrivastav, Mani K Chettri, Hemam D Singh, Britan Singh, Rupak Mukherjee Abstract We present a systematic cold-fluid analysis of the purely transverse Weibel (current-filamentation) instability across four regimes: non-relativistic (NR) single-species, NR multi-species, relativistic single-species, and relativistic multi-species (electron–positron and electron–proton). Beginning from the linearized fluid equations, we derive the quartic dispersion relations in each regime, reduce them to standard quadratics in ω 2 \omega^{2} , and extract explicit scaling laws for the maximum growth rate γ max \gamma_{\rm max} and characteristic unstable wavenumber k max = ω p ​ i / c k_{\rm max}=\omega_{pi}/c . The main analytical contributions are: (i) explicit regime-transition criteria in the ( v 0 / c v_{0}/c , m i / m e m_{i}/m_{e} ) parameter space, quantifying the error from applying a simpler formula outside its domain of validity; (ii) contour maps of relativistic suppression and mass-ratio dependence that serve directly as diagnostic charts; and (iii) an assessment of where in parameter space the purely transverse mode dominates over competing oblique and two-stream instabilities. Relativistic corrections suppress γ max \gamma_{\rm max} by up to 40 per cent, becoming significant above v 0 ≈ 0.2 ​ c v_{0}\approx 0.2c and reaching maximum suppression near v 0 ≈ 0.9 ​ c v_{0}\approx 0.9c . For the tabletop laser experiment by Bai et al. (2025, Nat. Commun. 16 , 3770), the cold-fluid prediction gives d i = c / ω p ​ i ≈ 31.7 ​ μ ​ m d_{i}=c/\omega_{pi}\approx 31.7\,\mu{\rm m} , in excellent agreement (within 2 per cent) with the measured filament spacing λ F ≈ 31 ​ μ ​ m \lambda_{F}\approx 31\,\mu{\rm m} . The saturation field estimate B sat ∼ μ 0 ​ n i ​ m i ​ v 0 ≈ 2.3 × 10 4 B_{\rm sat}\sim\sqrt{\mu_{0}n_{i}m_{i}}\,v_{0}\approx 2.3\times 10^{4} T is a cold-fluid upper bound, consistent with the measured ≈ 5000 \approx 5000 T within the expected kinetic suppression. In-situ comparison with two MMS burst-mode bow shock crossing events (2015 October 16 and 2017 November 25) is presented in Section IV . Both events confirm the cold-fluid scale prediction k max ​ d i = 1 k_{\rm max}d_{i}=1 from FGM/FPI PySPEDAS data; the upstream ion skin depths ( d i = 51 d_{i}=51 km and 62 62 km respectively) lie within a factor of 2 of the spectral break in the perpendicular magnetic field power spectrum, consistent with Kropotina et al. 21 . The multi-environment scatter plot spans 21 orders of magnitude in n i n_{i} , from the laser-plasma ( d i ≈ 32 ​ μ ​ m d_{i}\approx 32\,\mu{\rm m} ) to young SNR scales, with all points lying within a factor of 3 of the 1:1 line. I Introduction Collisionless shocks appear in many astrophysical environments. They form in gamma-ray burst (GRB) afterglows where relativistic ejecta drive into the interstellar medium at Lorentz factors \Gamma\sim 10 – 100 25 ; 27 ; in young supernova remnants (SNRs) expanding at v_{\rm sh}\sim 10^{4}\,{\rm km\,s}^{-1} 28 ; in pulsar wind nebulae driven by ultra-relativistic pair winds 26 ; and at planetary bow shocks formed by the solar wind 4 ; 7 . In these environments, binary collisions between particles are negligible. Yet sharp shock transitions with large density and pressure jumps do exist. These shocks are maintained by plasma instabilities that generate magnetic turbulence on scales close to the ion inertial length d_{i}=c/\omega_{pi} , providing an effective collisionality 3 . The Weibel instability, also known as the current-filamentation instability, is one mechanism for this process 32 ; 25 ; 29 . When two plasma populations stream through each other, the velocity anisotropy drives exponentially growing transverse electromagnetic perturbations. The plasma organises into current filaments and the magnetic field grows until the ion gyroradius becomes comparable to the filament spacing, at which point the shock transition is established 13 ; 19 . Particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations confirm this picture across a wide range of shock velocities 29 ; 13 ; 4 ; 18 . A two-beam plasma is, however, unstable to a spectrum of modes beyond the purely transverse Weibel mode. These include the longitudinal two-stream (electrostatic) mode, the oblique electromagnetic-filamentation mode, and the Bell and Buneman modes in the presence of a background magnetic field or current. Bret 5 performed a comprehensive three-dimensional analysis of all these modes and showed that in the sub-relativistic regime ( v_{0}\lesssim 0.2c ) with a symmetric cold-beam configuration, the transverse filamentation (Weibel) mode typically has the highest growth rate among electromagnetic modes. At mildly relativistic velocities ( v_{0}\sim 0.2 – 0.5c ), oblique modes can become competitive. At highly relativistic velocities, the maximum growth often shifts to oblique modes. We analyse only the transverse Weibel mode in this paper, restricting to v_{0}\lesssim 0.2c where this mode dominates; the full justification and parameter boundaries are given in Section VI.2 . Direct laboratory evidence has come from large laser facilities. Huntington et al. 17 observed Weibel magnetic field generation in counterstreaming plasmas at OMEGA and NIF. Fox et al. 14 reported filamentation in laser-driven plasmas at OMEGA EP. Manuel et al. 24 studied the saturation of ion-Weibel fields in CH, Al, and Cu counterstreaming experiments. Most recently, Bai et al. 2 showed that a Weibel-mediated collisionless shock can be produced with a compact tabletop femtosecond laser operating at v_{\rm sh}\approx 0.03c , greatly reducing the experimental requirements. The expanding geometry of laser-produced plasmas and the role of density gradients in modifying the Weibel spectrum have been analysed in detail by Kocharovsky et al. 20 . Spacecraft data at Earth’s bow shock provide an independent in-situ test. The NASA Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission 7 provides burst-mode measurements that resolve scales down to the electron inertial length. Two separate MMS bow shock events are analysed here using PySPEDAS 16 . The first is a 2015 October 16 quasi-perpendicular crossing with moderate parameters ( M_{A}\approx 2.4 , \beta_{i}\approx 9.0 , upstream d_{i}\approx 51 km). The second is a 2017 November 25 crossing ( M_{A}\approx 2.3 , \beta_{i}\approx 2.4 , upstream d_{i}\approx 62 km) associated with the event studied by Kropotina et al. 21 using hybrid kinetic simulations. The full in-situ comparison—including FGM/FPI timeseries, B_{\perp} power spectra, and a multi-environment d_{i} scatter plot spanning 21 orders of magnitude—is presented in Section IV . The present work derives and applies the cold-fluid Weibel dispersion relations across these four regimes. Its contributions are as follows. First, it provides explicit numerical criteria for when each regime formula fails and by how much (Section V ), filling a gap between the individual papers that treat each regime separately. Second, it maps the relativistic suppression and mass-ratio dependence as two-dimensional contour charts (Figs 6 and 9 ) that can be used directly as diagnostic tools without recomputing the dispersion relation. Third, it applies these maps to assess where the transverse Weibel mode dominates over competing modes (Section VI.2 ). Fourth, it validates the scale prediction k_{\rm max}=\omega_{pi}/c with the Bai et al. experiment (Section III ) and provides a quantitative assessment of the cold-fluid framework’s reliability and limitations. The paper is organised as follows. Section II gives the four dispersion relations. Section III

Read the complete text