Why Neural Structural Obfuscation Can’t Kill White-Box Watermarks for Good!
Yanna Jiang, Guangsheng Yu , Qingyuan Yu, Yi Chen, Qin Wang · 2026
Read Why Neural Structural Obfuscation Can’t Kill White-Box Watermarks for Good! by Yanna Jiang, Guangsheng Yu , Qingyuan Yu, Yi Chen, Qin Wang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-12679.txt.
Introduction
Yanna Jiang and co-authors show that neural structural obfuscation cannot kill white-box watermarks for good. Obfuscation edits inject dummy neurons and rescale parameters while keeping function intact, which breaks watermark checks. The team recasts the attack as a graph-consistency problem between producer and consumer nodes. Their Canon framework probes the model to find dummy channels, then rewrites all downstream consumers in step. Under strong combined attacks, Canon reached 100% recovery and restored watermark checks with task performance intact.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yanna Jiang, Guangsheng Yu , Qingyuan Yu, Yi Chen, Qin Wang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 130705 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.12679
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Why Neural Structural Obfuscation Can’t Kill White-Box Watermarks for Good! Yanna Jiang, Guangsheng Yu , Qingyuan Yu, Yi Chen, Qin Wang Abstract Neural Structural Obfuscation (NSO) (USENIX Security’23) is a family of “zero cost” structure-editing transforms ( nso_zero , nso_clique , nso_split ) that inject dummy neurons. By combining neuron permutation and parameter scaling, NSO makes a radical modification to the network structure and parameters while strictly preserving functional equivalence, thereby disrupting white-box watermark verification. This capability has been a fundamental challenge to the reliability of existing white-box watermarking schemes. We rethink NSO and, for the first time, fully recover from the damage it has caused. We redefine NSO as a graph-consistent threat model within a producer–consumer paradigm. This formulation posits that any obfuscation of a producer node necessitates a compatible layout update in all downstream consumers to maintain structural integrity. Building on these consistency constraints on signal propagation, we present Canon , a recovery framework that probes the attacked model to identify redundancy/dummy channels and then globally canonicalizes the network by rewriting all downstream consumers by construction, synchronizing layouts across fan-out , add , and cat . Extensive experiments demonstrate that, even under strong composed and extended NSO attacks, Canon achieves 100% recovery success, restoring watermark verifiability while preserving task utility. Our code is available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/anti-NSO-9874 . 1 Introduction In USENIX Security’23. Yan et al. published Rethinking White-Box Watermarks on Deep Learning Models under Neural Structural Obfuscation (NSO) that is a systematic study that claims many white-box watermarks can be “removed at zero cost” by injecting dummy neurons that preserve utility while disrupting verification [ 35 ] . Their toolkit comprises three strategies: (i) zero injection (i.e., nso_zero ), which adds channels with all zero incoming or outgoing weights; (ii) clique cancellation (i.e., nso_clique ), which duplicates incoming weights and sets outgoing weights that sum to zero; and (iii) split preservation (i.e., nso_split ), which replaces a channel with d\!+\!1 substitutes whose outgoing weights sum to the original. The core observation underlying NSO is that mainstream white-box watermark verifiers implicitly bind to index-ordered parameters : once channel indices are structurally perturbed, watermark extraction fails even though the network is functionally equivalent. This poses a fundamental threat to white-box watermark security [ 19 , 27 , 44 , 7 , 39 , 11 ] , requiring a new approach to detect and recovery. Figure 1: Canon can recover a strengthened NSO variant that generalizes the original layer-local edits into graph-aware structural transformations that remain consistent across branches and merges, enabling attacks to be injected globally rather than only in isolated layers. The three NSO attacks correspond to different constrained forms of M (zero injection, clique cancellation \sum w=0 , and split preservation \sum\alpha=1 ). We rethink NSO [ 35 ] and show that it can be fully recovered, even under a stronger threat model, making embedding watermarks practical again. We recognize that existing NSO constructions, while effective, are largely confined to simple, sequential architectures and do not fully capture how structural obfuscation must behave in modern graph-structured networks. In contemporary models, such as ResNet [ 12 ] , EfficientNet [ 30 ] , InceptionV3 [ 28 ] , and DenseNet [ 14 ] , structural edits are no longer layer-local. Instead, injected neurons must propagate their signals consistently through residual connections, multi-branch topologies, and shared downstream operators (e.g., add [ 12 , 30 ] and cat [ 28 , 14 ] ) in order to preserve functional equivalence. To make NSO representative of realistic deployment scenarios, we introduce a producer–consumer perspective, as shown in Fig. 1 , which explicitly models how injected neuron signals are produced and consumed across the computation graph. Under this view, NSO is not treated as a stronger attack, but as a completed and well-defined threat model that changes channel layout while remaining functionally equivalent and shape compatible in graph-consistent architectures. Building on this threat model, recovery and defense face a fundamentally harder challenge. Once NSO is instantiated beyond simple sequential architectures, the attacker may arbitrarily combine multiple NSO primitives, place injections across layers and branches, and exploit residual merges, while the defender has no access to the attacker’s construction details. The central research problem becomes: \heartsuit How to distinguish attack-induced dummy neurones from benign structural components in a complex computation graph, when all edits are deliberately designed to remain functionally equivalent and appear structurally normal? Our approach: Functional equivalence enforces graph-consistent structure under NSO. Our key insight is that the indistinguishability introduced by NSO is only superficial. To preserve functional equivalence, any NSO obfuscation must induce a channel transform that is consistent across all downstream consumers along every producer \rightarrow consumer path of the computation graph: injected channels must satisfy the same cancellation/aggregation identities at every downstream consumption site (fan-outs, residual merges, and concatenations), otherwise the obfuscated network would no longer be functionally equivalent. These constraints are not incidental artifacts of NSO but necessary conditions for its correctness, which we leverage to generalize NSO into a graph-consistent producer-consumer threat model. We thus design Canon , a graph-consistent recovery framework that identifies NSO redundancy and reverses structural obfuscation. Rather than viewing NSO as an irreversible removal of watermarks, Canon models NSO as a family of channel-basis rewrites on the computation graph and recovers a canonical parameterization by (i) probing activations to infer redundancy and dummy channels and (ii) applying the induced ChannelTransform rewrites globally to all downstream linear consumers, including fan-out , residual add , and channel cat . By synchronizing channel layouts across the graph, Canon eliminates NSO-induced index scrambling and restores a compact representation on which existing white-box watermark extractors can be directly applied. As a clean reference model is typically available in the white-box setting, we additionally provide a reference-equivalence certificate. Why NSO fails under Canon . NSO primitives preserve network functionality by construction: injected channels are either null, mutually cancel in cliques, or form proportional split duplicates whose aggregate contribution matches the original channel. Under Canon , these edits manifest as structured redundancy revealed by activation probes through consistent signatures and proportionality relations. Crucially, Canon operates graph-consistently : once a ChannelTransform is inferred at a producer edge, it is propagated to all downstream consumers, including residual merges and concatenations. This allows NSO edits to be removed via equivalence preserving compaction , while downstream linear consumers are rewritten to the recovered channel basis and layouts are synchronized across the graph. The resulting parameters \hat{\theta} ( v.s. original \theta ) form a stable, compact representation on which existing white-box verifiers can be directly applied. Contributions. We make the following contributions: \bullet We generalise the threat model of NSO. We reformulate NSO as a graph-consistent producer–consumer model that captures fan-out, residual addition, and channel concatenation in modern architectures. This exposes the signal-consistency constraints required for function-equivalent NSO, which are missing in prior layer-local formulations. \bullet We show that NSO-style obfuscation is fundamentally recoverable under graph consistency. Contrary to the prevailing belief that NSO can “remove” white-box watermarks at zero cost, we prove constructively that NSO induces structured, globally constrained redundancy. These constraints make it possible to identify dummy channels and reverse layout obfuscation without access to the attacker’s construction details or the clean reference