Probing Cosmology through Higher-Order CMB Lensing Statistics
Shu-Fan Chen, J. Colin Hill, Zoltán Haiman · 2026
Read Probing Cosmology through Higher-Order CMB Lensing Statistics by Shu-Fan Chen, J. Colin Hill, Zoltán Haiman (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-12335.txt.
Introduction
Chen, Hill, and Haiman mine higher-order CMB lensing stats for extra cosmological information. Their pipeline ray-traces the MassiveNuS suite and mimics Simons Observatory lensing maps. Nonlinear growth, post-Born effects, and noise all enter in a natural way. The measures include Minkowski functionals, peak counts, moments, and wavelet-scattering scores. Emulators link each measure to matter density, spectrum amplitude, and neutrino mass. Shape-based measures add strong power, cutting errors on all three targets when combined with the spectrum.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shu-Fan Chen, J. Colin Hill, Zoltán Haiman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 82301 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.12335
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Probing Cosmology through Higher-Order CMB Lensing Statistics Shu-Fan Chen, J. Colin Hill, Zoltán Haiman Abstract We investigate the cosmological information in higher-order statistics of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) lensing convergence field for a near-term experiment with noise properties similar to the Simons Observatory (SO). Using a fully field-level forward-modeling pipeline based on ray-traced simulations from the MassiveNuS suite and realistic SO-like CMB lensing reconstruction, we naturally include nonlinear structure formation, post-Born effects, and higher-order reconstruction noise. We measure several non-Gaussian statistics, including Minkowski functionals, peak and minima counts, moments, and wavelet-scattering coefficients. We train Gaussian-process emulators to model each statistic’s dependence on the matter density fraction Ω m \Omega_{m} , the scalar power spectrum amplitude A s A_{s} , and the neutrino mass sum M ν M_{\nu} . We quantify the relative information gain these statistics provide beyond the lensing power spectrum and identify which are most robust to reconstruction noise. We find that morphology-based statistics, particularly Minkowski functionals and peak/minima counts, offer significant complementary constraining power: combining all non-Gaussian statistics with the power spectrum yields reductions of 40% and 38% in the marginalized uncertainties on Ω m \Omega_{m} and A s A_{s} , respectively, and a 70% reduction in the one-sided uncertainty on M ν M_{\nu} . These gains remain non-negligible even when the power spectrum is extended to larger scales and combined with primary CMB and BAO data, with Minkowski functionals providing an additional 11% improvement in σ ( M ν ) \sigma(M_{\nu}) and 35% in σ ( Ω m ) \sigma(\Omega_{m}) beyond the extended power spectrum. By contrast, moments and wavelet-scattering coefficients provide more limited gains at SO noise levels. Our results highlight the potential of non-Gaussian statistics to enhance cosmological constraints from SO and future CMB surveys. 1 Introduction Gravitational lensing of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) provides a powerful probe of the projected matter distribution and the growth of structure over cosmic time. As CMB photons propagate from the last scattering surface, deflections induced by intervening large-scale structure imprint coherent mode couplings in the observed temperature and polarization fields (see 32 for a review). These signatures enable the reconstruction of the CMB lensing convergence field, a line-of-sight integral of the matter fluctuation field, yielding tight constraints on key cosmological parameters 28 . With the upcoming wide-area, high-resolution, low-noise measurements from the Simons Observatory (SO) 3 ; 2 , the fidelity of CMB lensing reconstruction will improve significantly, opening new opportunities for precision cosmology. Current CMB lensing analyses rely primarily on the two-point function or angular power spectrum of the reconstructed convergence field, C_{\ell}^{\kappa\kappa} , as demonstrated in recent measurements from ACT 60 ; 40 , SPT 68 , SPT-3G 55 , Planck 4 ; 15 , and their joint analyses 61 . However, nonlinear structure formation generates significant non-Gaussian features, particularly on the small angular scales to which upcoming data will be sensitive, which are not captured by the lensing power spectrum alone. Refs. 54 ; 16 study the additional information coming from the bispectrum and find at least 35\% improvements on the constraint on neutrino mass when they include it in addition to the power spectrum. A variety of higher-order and morphology-based statistics, including Minkowski functionals 51 , peak and minima counts 6 ; 13 , low-order moments, and wavelet-scattering coefficients 42 , provide complementary probes of these non-Gaussian structures and have already improved cosmological constraints in galaxy weak-lensing and large-scale-structure analyses (see Refs. 18 ; 66 ; 64 ; 38 ; 56 ; 37 ; 19 ; 33 ; 20 ; 43 for example). Ref. 36 has studied the one-point PDF and peak counts of CMB lensing maps, but their potential for CMB lensing has not yet been comprehensively assessed under realistic reconstruction noise for SO, SPT-3G 9 , PICO 25 , or other future experiments. In this work, we take a fully field-level approach to CMB lensing inference. Rather than relying solely on analytical modeling of the lensing power spectrum or perturbative expansions of estimator noise, we forward-model the entire reconstruction pipeline using ray-traced convergence fields from N -body simulations and simulated CMB temperature and polarization maps expected from SO-like observations. This procedure naturally incorporates all higher-order effects — such as post-Born corrections 59 ; 7 , nonlinear mode coupling, and the full hierarchy of lensing reconstruction noise biases 41 — without requiring separate analytical treatments. Because all statistics are measured directly from the reconstructed fields themselves, the resulting constraints reflect the true information content of the lensing maps in the presence of realistic noise, filtering, and non-Gaussian structure. Building on this framework, our analysis aims to quantify how a broad set of non-Gaussian statistics respond to variations in the matter density fraction \Omega_{m} , the primordial scalar power spectrum amplitude A_{s} , and the sum of neutrino masses M_{\nu} . Because our simulation maps can cover only a small area in the sky, our focus is on the relative information content provided by different statistics rather than the absolute constraints achievable with an SO-like experiment. Higher-order and morphology-based statistics are expected to probe complementary aspects of the reconstructed convergence field compared to those probed by the power spectrum, with much of the additional information coming from the nonlinear regime. Thus, small-area but high-resolution maps are useful in assessing the information content in these statistics. In addition, their cosmological sensitivity and robustness in the presence of realistic SO-like reconstruction noise remain insufficiently understood. With these goals in mind, we assess which statistics are most informative for CMB lensing and under what conditions they provide meaningful gains beyond the standard power spectrum. In particular, we investigate how Minkowski functionals, peak and minima counts, low-order moments, and wavelet-scattering coefficients capture the non-Gaussian structure introduced by nonlinear growth and lensing reconstruction. We also explore their ability to constrain the neutrino mass when analyzed together with C_{\ell}^{\kappa\kappa} . By conducting this comparison within a consistent field-level forward-modeling pipeline, our aim is to clarify the extent to which non-Gaussian statistics can enhance cosmological analyses with SO and other upcoming experiments, and to identify the most promising avenues for incorporating them into future CMB lensing studies. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we describe the simulations and the forward-modeling pipeline used to generate the reconstructed convergence maps for our forecasts. Section 3 introduces the higher-order statistics employed in our analysis, and Section 4 outlines the Gaussian-process emulators used to model their cosmological dependence. In Section 5 , we present the likelihood framework, followed by our main forecasting results in Section 6 . We conclude in Section 7 . 2 Simulations 2.1 N-body Simulations and Ray-Tracing The simulations used in this work are drawn from the Cosmological Massive Neutrino Simulation suite ( MassiveNuS ) 35 1 1 1 https://columbialensing.github.io/#massivenus , a fully ray-traced N-body simulation suite designed to model the effects of massive neutrinos on large-scale structure. The simulations are run using the public code Gadget-2 65 with 1024^{3} cold dark matter (CDM) particles in a (512\,\,\mathrm{Mpc}/h)^{3} box, evolving the matter density field from z=99 to z=0 . Initial conditions are generated with a modified version of NGenIC 65 that enables the inclusion of massive neutrinos directly in Fourier