DIALECTIC: A Multi-Agent System for Startup Evaluation
Jae Yoon Bae, Simon Malberg, Joyce Galang, Andre Retterath, Georg Groh · 2026
Read DIALECTIC: A Multi-Agent System for Startup Evaluation by Jae Yoon Bae, Simon Malberg, Joyce Galang, Andre Retterath, Georg Groh (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-12274.txt.
Introduction
Bae, Malberg, Galang, Retterath, and Groh built DIALECTIC, a multi-agent system that screens startups for investors. Venture investors face far more pitches than they can study with full diligence. The system first gathers facts on a startup and sorts them into a hierarchical question tree. Agents then draft arguments for and against the deal and refine them through simulated debate. Only the most convincing arguments survive that critique loop. Numeric scores let investors rank the flow, and backtests on real deals matched human VC precision.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jae Yoon Bae, Simon Malberg, Joyce Galang, Andre Retterath, Georg Groh |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57170 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.12274
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
DIALECTIC: A Multi-Agent System for Startup Evaluation Jae Yoon Bae, Simon Malberg, Joyce Galang, Andre Retterath, Georg Groh Abstract Venture capital (VC) investors face a large number of investment opportunities but only invest in few of these, with even fewer ending up successful. Early-stage screening of opportunities is often limited by investor bandwidth, demanding tradeoffs between evaluation diligence and number of opportunities assessed. To ease this tradeoff, we introduce DIALECTIC, an LLM-based multi-agent system for startup evaluation. DIALECTIC first gathers factual knowledge about a startup and organizes these facts into a hierarchical question tree. It then synthesizes the facts into natural-language arguments for and against an investment and iteratively critiques and refines these arguments through a simulated debate, which surfaces only the most convincing arguments. Our system also produces numeric decision scores that allow investors to rank and thus efficiently prioritize opportunities. We evaluate DIALECTIC through backtesting on real investment opportunities aggregated from five VC funds, showing that DIALECTIC matches the precision of human VCs in predicting startup success. 1 Introduction The global venture capital (VC) industry is expanding rapidly alongside intensified competition for attractive deals. The market is projected to grow from USD 337 billion in 2024 to USD 1.46 trillion by 2033, a compound annual growth rate of 17.6% ( IMARC Group 2024 ) . Entrepreneurial activity has also surged, with annual U.S. business formations rising from 3.5 million in 2019 to 5.2 million in 2024, an increase of nearly 40% ( U.S. Census Bureau 2025 ) . Traditional VC decision-making processes are challenged in this setting. Investors face high time pressure and information overload, both associated with suboptimal decisions Zacharakis and Shepherd 2001 . These conditions have increased interest in computational approaches for scalable investment evaluation. Among these approaches, machine learning methods have emerged as a promising direction. Prior studies demonstrate strong predictive performance that, in some cases, even surpasses human investors Antretter et al. 2019 ; Retterath 2020 ; Zacharakis and Shepherd 2001 ; Arroyo et al. 2019 ; Dellermann et al. 2021 ; Sharchilev et al. 2018 . Yet, these non-iterative models diverge from how investment decisions are formed by human VCs. In practice, conviction emerges through iterative hypothesis formation, challenge, and refinement as new information appears Chong and Tuckett 2014 . Recent advances in large language model (LLM) orchestration tools enable iterative and interpretable reasoning. Frameworks such as LangChain Chase 2022 support the decomposition of complex tasks, the generation of intermediate conclusions, and the iterative refinement of responses while making the underlying logic explicit. They allow multi-step reasoning and dialectical interaction, a setup in which LLMs can articulate arguments, generate counterpoints, and produce transparent reasoning traces. This paper introduces D ecision I teration with A rgument- L evel E vidence and C ounter- T hinking for I nvestment C onclusions ( DIALECTIC ), an LLM-based system that models iterative and argumentative elements of venture evaluation. Our system draws on principles of dialectical reasoning, an approach shown to be effective for complex, unstructured problems that benefit from structured confrontation of differing perspectives ( Jarupathirun and Zahedi 2007 ) . The contributions of this work are: • A structured LLM reasoning system that models how investors build and refine investment theses through argumentation. • An empirical evaluation demonstrating predictive performance in venture screening. Overall, the proposed system brings data-driven VC methods closer to industry practice. Furthermore, it enables the process of iterative argumentation in early-stage screening, which has traditionally been restricted to later stages of the decision funnel due to limited investor bandwidth. This shift allows investors to apply iterative reasoning earlier in the process, improving both diligence quality and screening efficiency. 2 Related Work Prior studies propose different machine learning approaches to predict startup outcomes, drawing on public data sources such as Crunchbase ( Arroyo et al. 2019 ; Żbikowski and Antosiuk 2021 ; Retterath 2020 ) , Twitter ( Antretter et al. 2019 ) , web data ( Sharchilev et al. 2018 ) , and Google Search ( Gavrilenko et al. 2023 ) , and often reporting promising prediction accuracy (see Table 4 in the Appendix for an overview). Most studies trained gradient tree boosting models (e.g., XGBoost ) ( Corea et al. 2021 ; Arroyo et al. 2019 ; Żbikowski and Antosiuk 2021 ; Retterath 2020 ) and interpreted predictions using feature-importance rankings with features such as geography, industry, or founder background ( Żbikowski and Antosiuk 2021 ; Sharchilev et al. 2018 ; Gavrilenko et al. 2023 ) . Some newer studies have used LLMs to extract structured features or embeddings from unstructured data, while still resorting to machine learning models such as XGBoost for prediction ( Ozince and Ihlamur 2024 ; Maarouf et al. 2025 ) . Xiong and Ihlamur 2023 used LLMs to assess founder-idea fit, also providing pro and contra arguments for interpretability. In follow-up work ( Xiong et al. 2024 ) , they focus on extracting traits associated with successful entrepreneurs. Both studies look at individual founders rather than startup companies. Beyond VC, LLM-based decision-making frameworks have been proposed for fields such as business or finance. DeLLMa combines LLMs with decision-theoretic reasoning ( Liu et al. 2025 ) , while STRUX extracts facts from companies’ earnings calls and produces weighted pro and contra aspects for buy or sell decisions ( Lu et al. 2025 ) . A promising approach to improving LLM reasoning is the introduction of multi-agent systems ( Han et al. 2024 ) . Instead of relying on a single model, several LLMs interact through collaboration, debate, or specialization. In adversarial or collaborative debating, agents defend opposing stances and a separate judge model or heuristic evaluates the quality of their arguments ( Chan et al. 2023 ; Liang et al. 2024 ) . 3 DIALECTIC Figure 1: Overview of the DIALECTIC method. The right side shows the flow of operations. Agents are shown in red, agent inputs/outputs are shown in blue, and loops are shown in green. The left side illustrates the key outputs of the agents. DIALECTIC is inspired by how real VC investors make investment decisions. They collect information about a startup, form narrative investment hypotheses, and refine these hypotheses through debate with other VCs until making a decision. DIALECTIC proceeds in three phases: fact collection , reasoning , and decision-making . During fact collection, DIALECTIC gathers factual knowledge about a company and organizes these facts hierarchically in a question tree. In the reasoning phase, it synthesizes raw facts into arguments pro and contra an investment, which it iteratively self-critiques, evaluates, and refines, letting only the best arguments survive. Finally, it makes a decision based on a comparison of the best pro and contra arguments; see Figure 1 for an illustration. In the following, we formally introduce DIALECTIC. Let X=\{x_{i}\}_{i=1}^{N} be the set of investable companies, each described by multiple features x_{i}^{(d)},d=1,...,D . The goal is to predict the ground truth label y_{i}\in\{\text{successful},\text{unsuccessful}\} signaling whether the company will be successful and should be invested in or not. 3.1 Fact Collection Phase We denote the universe of natural-language questions as \mathcal{Q} , the universe of natural-language answers as \mathcal{A} , and the set of industries as I . For a given company x in industry x^{(0)}\in