Global and local helicity-preservation in the finite element discretisation of magnetic relaxation

Patrick E. Farrell, Mingdong He, Kaibo Hu, Ganghui Zhang · 2026

Read Global and local helicity-preservation in the finite element discretisation of magnetic relaxation by Patrick E. Farrell, Mingdong He, Kaibo Hu, Ganghui Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-12134.txt.

Introduction

Farrell, He, Hu, and Zhang compare finite element schemes by how well they keep helicity in magnetic relaxation. Ideal theory conserves helicity locally, while Taylor relaxation keeps only the global total. Three schemes face off: one with no conservation, one local method, and one global multiplier method. Tests with magnetic knots and braids show helicity limits act as real topological barriers when the invariant is nonzero. When it vanishes, braided topology escapes full description. The results map both the power and the limits of this approach.

Catalog record

CREATORPatrick E. Farrell, Mingdong He, Kaibo Hu, Ganghui Zhang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51297
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.12134

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Global and local helicity-preservation in the finite element discretisation of magnetic relaxation Thanks: Submitted to the editors DATE. Patrick E. Farrell, Mingdong He, Kaibo Hu, Ganghui Zhang Abstract Magnetic relaxation drives plasma toward lower-energy equilibria under helicity constraints. In ideal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), helicity is locally conserved, while resistive theories such as Taylor relaxation preserve only global helicity. This distinction has important implications for structure-preserving numerical methods. We compare three finite element formulations: an unconstrained scheme that does not conserve helicity, a mixed method based on finite element exterior calculus that preserves all local helicities, and a Lagrange multiplier approach that enforces only global helicity conservation. Numerical experiments on braided and knotted magnetic fields show that local helicity preservation prevents spurious reconnection and maintains nontrivial topology in ideal MHD or magneto-friction, whereas enforcing only global helicity allows further relaxation through local reconnection. Numerical results on magnetic knots and braids are provided. These results clarify how different levels of discrete helicity constraints influence magnetic relaxation and equilibrium structure in numerical computation. keywords magnetohydrodynamics, structure-preservation, Lagrange multiplier, finite element exterior calculus, magnetic helicity, magnetic relaxation. Funding. This work was funded by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council [grant number EP/W026163/1], the Science and Technology Facilities Council [grant number UKRI/ST/B000495/1], the Donatio Universitatis Carolinae Chair “Mathematical modelling of multicomponent systems”, the UKRI Digital Research Infrastructure Programme through the Science and Technology Facilities Council’s Computational Science Centre for Research Communities (CoSeC), the Swedish Research Council under grant no. Z2021-06594 while in residence at Institut Mittag-Leffler in Djursholm, Sweden, the European Research Council (ERC Starting Grant, project 101164551 GeoFEM), and by a Royal Society University Research Fellowship (URF \backslash R1 \backslash 221398). For the purpose of open access, the authors have applied a CC BY public copyright licence to any author accepted manuscript arising from this submission. No new data were generated or analysed during this work. † † runningheads: Global and local helicity-preservation / P. E. Farrell, M. He, K. Hu and G. Zhang MSC 65N30, 65L60, 76W05 1 Introduction Magnetic relaxation describes the process by which a magnetized plasma reorganizes its magnetic field toward a lower-energy equilibrium. Magnetic relaxation is a fundamental process in plasma physics, playing a central role in the understanding of magnetic equilibria in both natural and laboratory plasmas. In magnetically ideal situations, this reorganization is described by the ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations, or their simplification, the magneto-frictional (MF) equations [ 28 , 45 , 15 , 52 ] posed on a bounded, contractible, Lipschitz domain \Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^{3} : \displaystyle\partial_{t}\bm{B}+\nabla\times\bm{E} \displaystyle=\bm{0}, (1a) \displaystyle\bm{E}+\bm{u}\times\bm{B} \displaystyle=\bm{0}, (1b) \displaystyle\bm{u} \displaystyle=\tau\bm{j}\times\bm{B}, (1c) \displaystyle\bm{j} \displaystyle=\nabla\times\bm{B}, (1d) where \bm{B} is the magnetic field, \bm{E} is the electric field, \bm{u} , is the velocity, \bm{j} is the current, and \tau>0 is a coupling parameter. These MF equations possess the same equilibria as the ideal MHD equations, allowing their study with less computational expense. Both the ideal MHD and MF systems impose topological constraints of the magnetic fields. Helicity is a quantitative measure of the knottedness and linking of the magnetic fields, which is defined on a domain \Omega_{s}\subset\Omega as \mathcal{H}(\Omega_{s})\coloneqq\int_{\Omega_{s}}\bm{A}\cdot\bm{B}\,\mathrm{d}x, (2) where \bm{A} is any magnetic potential satisfying \nabla\times\bm{A}=\bm{B} . The quantity \mathcal{H}(\Omega) , known as Woltjer’s invariant [ 49 ] , describes the total averaged knotting of the magnetic field in the domain. Hereafter, we refer to this quantity as the global helicity since it is integrated over the entire domain. Woltjer’s invariant is conserved in ideal MHD. In fact, \mathcal{H}(\Omega_{s}) is conserved for any magnetically closed domain \Omega_{s}\subset\Omega , i.e., any subdomain \Omega_{s} such that \bm{B} is tangent to its boundary ( \bm{B}|_{\partial\Omega_{s}}\cdot\bm{n}_{\partial\Omega_{s}}=0 ). A more geometric description is that the volume form \bm{A}\wedge\bm{B} is transported by the flow and is thus invariant. Hereafter, we refer to the conservation of \mathcal{H}(\Omega_{s}) for \Omega_{s}\subsetneq\Omega as the local conservation of helicity. In both ideal MHD and the MF equations, the local helicity is conserved in time for any suitable \Omega_{s} . For a comprehensive review of magnetic relaxation and its topological constraints, we refer to [ 53 ] . Numerical simulations of magnetic relaxation yield nonphysical results if the numerical schemes do not appropriately preserve helicity [ 28 ] ; if helicity is not conserved, then the magnetic field relaxes without topological constraints towards the trivial zero state \bm{B}=\bm{0} . In our previous work [ 28 ] we introduced a structure-preserving scheme. However, this scheme requires the introduction of auxiliary variables (fields over the domain), and is substantially more expensive than non-structure-preserving approaches. In this work we investigate whether this is necessary: to predict the correct relaxed state, is it possible to use a cheaper real-valued Lagrange multiplier to preserve \mathcal{H}(\Omega) ? Realizing the distinction between local and global helicities, we reframe the central question as follows: to recover the physically relevant relaxed state, is conservation of global helicity alone adequate (as achieved by a Lagrange-multiplier approach), or must both the global helicity and all local helicities be preserved, as imposed in the mixed-variable structure-preserving scheme [ 28 ] ? We therefore compare three finite element discretizations. The first takes no special care to conserve helicity on discretization and leads to nonphysical trivial states. The second is our projection-based scheme from [ 28 ] , which introduces the projection of the magnetic field onto another function space so as to conserve helicity for every magnetically closed domain. The third is a novel scheme where the global helicity constraint is enforced with a Lagrange multiplier. This corresponds to Taylor’s relaxation theory [ 38 , 45 ] , which assumes that the global helicity is approximately conserved in the real plasma relaxation, although local helicities can change due to reconnections. The first leads to \bm{B}=\bm{0} and thus with vanishing current \bm{j}=\nabla\times\bm{B}=\bm{0} ; the second leads to so-called ‘nonlinear force-free fields’ with \bm{j}=\alpha(\bm{x})\bm{B} ; the third leads to so-called ‘linear force-free fields’ with \bm{j}=\alpha\bm{B} for a constant \alpha . In the second and third cases, equilibrium is described by the vanishing of the Lorentz force \bm{j}\times\bm{B}=\bm{0}. (3) We demonstrate that solving the MF equations with the Lagrange multiplier scheme leads to qualitatively wrong solutions: the magnetic field decays to zero due to spurious numerical reconnections of the field lines. This evinces the crucial importance of local -helicity-preservation in problems where local helicity is preserved. For these problems, the numerical scheme enforcing only the global constraint is not enough to correctly compute the steady state with local topological structures. In fact, even for magnetic knots with non-zero helicity, the Lagrange multiplier scheme may still converge to different stationary states (though nonzero) compared to the projection-based approach (see Figure 5 below). However, real physical situations are not ideal, breaking helicity conservation. Taylor’s relaxation theory assumes that the global helicity is approximately conserved to high accuracy, although local helicities are not [ 45 , 53 , 38 ] . A consequence of the Taylor relaxation theory is that turbulent plasmas relax toward a linear force-free state under only the global constraint. In the latter part of this paper, we discuss the possibility of using the local reconnections arising from numerical errors in the Lagrange multiplier approach as an approach for simulating Taylor relaxation. In short, numerical errors (reconnections) in local helicity might reflect the

Read the complete text