Direct Boltzmann inversion method from particle configurations at arbitrary state points

Olivier Coquand, Davide Paolino, Ludovic Berthier · 2026

Read Direct Boltzmann inversion method from particle configurations at arbitrary state points by Olivier Coquand, Davide Paolino, Ludovic Berthier (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-12081.txt.

Introduction

Coquand, Paolino, and Berthier infer particle interactions straight from snapshots, with no fresh simulation at each step. Older Boltzmann inversion loops a new Monte Carlo run into every round of refinement. Their direct method instead forces two routes to the pair correlation function to agree. One route uses interparticle distances, and the other uses pairwise forces. The scheme stays cheap and simple, and it works at any state point, even at high density. Tests on varied potentials went well.

Catalog record

CREATOROlivier Coquand, Davide Paolino, Ludovic Berthier
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51817
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.12081

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Direct Boltzmann inversion method from particle configurations at arbitrary state points Olivier Coquand, Davide Paolino, Ludovic Berthier Abstract We introduce a direct Boltzmann inversion method to infer the interaction potential in particle systems using as input particle configurations generated at an arbitrary state point of the system. Unlike iterative Boltzmann inversion, the proposed method does not require performing a new Monte Carlo simulation at each step of the iteration process. It relies instead on enforcing consistency between two independent estimates of the pair correlation function, respectively obtained from interparticle distances and from pairwise forces. As a result, the approach is computationally inexpensive and straightforward to implement. Because it relies on the sole expression of interparticle forces, our method naturally applies to any state point, including when the density is large and alternative methods may fail. Here we present the basic principles of the method and benchmark its performance on a diverse set of test potentials studied using computer simulations. Practical aspects and detailed implementation of the method are also discussed. Owing to its simplicity and generality, the method should be broadly applicable, from the construction of coarse-grained interaction potentials to the inference of effective interactions in non-equilibrium systems. I Introduction In liquid-state theory Hansen and McDonald 2013 , two cornerstone quantities are the interaction potential, u(r) , and the radial distribution function, g(r) . The first dictates the microscopic dynamics of each particle, while the second describes the structure. The latter can easily be obtained numerically, or experimentally using for example scattering or microscopy techniques. In a classic paper, Henderson proved that for equilibrium systems governed by pairwise interactions, there exists a one-to-one correspondence between the pair potential and the radial distribution function Henderson 1974 . A fundamental consequence is that knowledge of one function uniquely determines the other, at least in principle. As is well-known, there is no exact analytic formula to predict directly g(r) from u(r) , and the derivation of approximate closure relations was a basic endeavor of liquid-state theory Hansen and McDonald 2013 . The parallel development of computer simulations of particle systems Allen and Tildesley 2017a ; Frenkel and Smit 2023 has allowed for an essentially exact determination of g(r) given any interaction potential u(r) . From a numerical viewpoint, the forward problem of determining g(r) for a given u(r) can therefore be considered as being essentially solved. By contrast, the inverse problem Chayes et al. 1984 of computing the interaction potential from a known g(r) has attracted somewhat less attention, and there exists no fully satisfying solution either analytically or numerically. This so-called Boltzmann inversion problem is nevertheless of interest as it can be used for several purposes. An obvious application is the determination of an unknown interaction potential from an experimental dataset Royall et al. 2007 . For pairwise interactions, this can be done by studying only two particles, but there is no such simple method available when an arbitrary bulk state point is accessible, or in the presence of many-body interactions. Another application is the determination of an effective coarse-grained interaction potential representing a more complex system with a larger number of degrees of freedom. This is a useful task, as the determined coarse-grained model can then be studied numerically over much larger length scales and time scales Maurel et al. 2015 ; Ingólfsson et al. 2014 ; Moore et al. 2014 . A final application could be the determination of effective interactions in systems evolving far from equilibrium Torquato and Wang 2022 ; Rees-Zimmerman et al. 2026 , in order to provide an equilibrium interpretation of physics phenomena observed far from equilibrium. Over the years, a number of numerical methods have been developed to solve the inverse Boltzmann problem. Existing methods can be broadly divided into model-based and model-free approaches. Model-based methods essentially fit the measured radial distribution function by optimizing a parametrized family of potentials. Although widely used Torquato and Wang 2022 ; Wang and Torquato 2023 ; Tian and Berthier 2023 , these approaches rely heavily on guessing an accurate parametrization and become less tractable as the number of parameters increases Izvekov et al. 2004 . Model-free techniques, by contrast, do not impose a functional form for u(r) . These algorithms typically refine iteratively an initial potential guess until the simulated structural data matches the reference one Delbary et al. 2020 . The main differences between different algorithms lie in the iteration rules Bernhardt et al. 2021 , whose complexity typically trades off with the number of iterations needed to converge. For example, Inverse Monte Carlo Lyubartsev and Laaksonen 1995 converges in relatively few steps but this requires long simulations at each step for accurate statistics as well as a good initial guess Murtola et al. 2007 . In contrast, Iterative Boltzmann Inversion Schommers 1973 ; Reith et al. 2003 ; Moore et al. 2014 relies on a very simple update rule, making it one of the most robust and widely-used algorithms, applied in fields from liquid interfaces Jochum et al. 2012 to polymers Maurel et al. 2015 and biomolecules Ingólfsson et al. 2014 . Its convergence is typically much slower than Inverse Monte Carlo, often requiring an order of magnitude more iteration steps Jain et al. 2006 . Recent proposals using Machine Learning to reconstruct interactions are promising Berressem and Nikoubashman 2021 , but still lack the accuracy of iterative algorithms Ruiz-Garcia et al. 2024 , or must rely on intense training Bag and Mandal 2021 . A common feature of all iterative methods mentioned above is the need to perform a computer simulation at each iteration step using the updated potential, in order to compare the generated data to the target g(r) . This represents the main computational bottleneck when performing the inversion, potentially limiting scalability to larger systems or higher accuracy. Recently, an elegant strategy was proposed to bypass this bottleneck Stones et al. 2019 ; Rees-Zimmerman et al. 2025a ; Rees-Zimmerman et al. 2025b ; Rees-Zimmerman et al. 2026 . The method uses two expressions for the radial distribution function, the usual one using pairwise distances and a second one known as test-particle insertion formula Hansen and McDonald 2013 ; Stones and Aarts 2023 that requires knowledge of the interaction potential. The quality of the updated potential is now assessed by comparing the radial distribution function generated by the test-particle insertion to the reference one coming from the initial data set. An important shortcoming of this approach is that the test-particle insertion method is computationally much more expensive than conventional g(r) calculations. An even more severe limitation is that particle insertions become virtually impossible in dense fluids and the proposed approach is thus by construction limited to small enough densities to allow particle insertions Rees-Zimmerman et al. 2025a . Here, we propose an alternative approach to directly obtain the interaction potential without performing a novel computer simulation at each step of the iteration and that can be applied to any state point, including dense fluids. Our central idea is to replace the particle insertion expression of the radial distribution with an alternative expression based on interparticle forces Borgis et al. 2013 ; Rotenberg 2020 . This force-formula for g(r) involves both interparticle distances and forces.

Read the complete text