Social, Legal, Ethical, Empathetic and Cultural Norm Operationalisation for AI Agents
Radu Calinescu, Ana Cavalcanti, Marsha Chechik, Lina Marsso, Beverley Townsend · 2026
Read Social, Legal, Ethical, Empathetic and Cultural Norm Operationalisation for AI Agents by Radu Calinescu, Ana Cavalcanti, Marsha Chechik, Lina Marsso, Beverley Townsend (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11864.txt.
Introduction
Calinescu and co-authors tackle a gap in AI agent design: turning broad social, legal, ethical, empathetic, and cultural norms into concrete, checkable requirements. High-level frameworks state the principles, but builders lack a path to code. The authors propose a step-by-step process to pin down, validate, build, and verify such requirements for agents. They also survey the methods and tools that support each step. Open challenges and a research agenda round out the work, aimed at agents that provably respect human norms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Radu Calinescu, Ana Cavalcanti, Marsha Chechik, Lina Marsso, Beverley Townsend |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41038 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11864
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Social, Legal, Ethical, Empathetic and Cultural Norm Operationalisation for AI Agents Radu Calinescu, Ana Cavalcanti, Marsha Chechik, Lina Marsso, Beverley Townsend Abstract . As AI agents are increasingly used in high-stakes domains like healthcare and law enforcement, aligning their behaviour with social, legal, ethical, empathetic, and cultural (SLEEC) norms has become a critical engineering challenge. While international frameworks have established high-level normative principles for AI, a significant gap remains in translating these abstract principles into concrete, verifiable requirements. To address this gap, we propose a systematic SLEEC-norm operationalisation process for determining, validating, implementing, and verifying normative requirements. Furthermore, we survey the landscape of methods and tools supporting this process, and identify key remaining challenges and research avenues for addressing them. We thus establish a framework—and define a research and policy agenda—for developing AI agents that are not only functionally useful but also demonstrably aligned with human norms and values. 1. Introduction Artificial intelligence (AI) agents are being developed at pace for use in domains such as healthcare, transportation, law enforcement, and education. These agents operate with limited human oversight in pursuit of high-level goals, which they aim to achieve through sophisticated sequences of agent-selected actions. They are increasingly entrusted with making life-changing decisions ( duan2019artificial ; harish2021artificial ) , or with controlling critical systems like self-driving cars ( hong2021ai ) and assistive-care robots ( worth2024robots ) . These high-stakes tasks have profound normative implications of a social, legal, ethical, empathetic and cultural (SLEEC) nature. AI agent actions may even entail prioritising one human value over another, such as favouring privacy over accuracy, or prioritising the users’ well-being over their autonomy. To navigate these complexities, we need a comprehensive understanding of the SLEEC norms that reflect the relevant societal and individual values of AI-agent stakeholders. Importantly, we need methods for engineering AI agents that comply with such SLEEC norms. For example, developed with these methods, an AI-enabled care robot will know that, under normal circumstances, the user should be asked for consent before a human operator is called for extra help. Similarly, a tele-health AI chatbot will adapt the content, tone, and volume of its communication to the needs of users, as defined by their cultural backgrounds and possible disabilities. This level of SLEEC sensitivity and responsiveness in AI agents needs to draw on a plural set of non-exhaustive norms that encode human values derived from rights-based instruments, policy frameworks, standards, professional codes of conduct and best practice, protocols, ethical theory and guidelines, and other sources of social and cultural values. To enable this, a significant corpus of work has been undertaken by multiple organizations, including the OECD ( oecd-2024 ) , UNESCO ( unesco-2021 ) , IEEE ( ieee-2021 ) , ICO/IEC ( iso-iec-2022 ) and the BSI ( BS-2022 ) , among others. Nevertheless, normative principles at a high level of abstraction only state that an AI agent should observe human privacy, well-being, autonomy, etc. Their high-level framing is not and cannot be specialised for the particularities inherent to contexts and applications, and it tells us little about how to apply and enforce these principles, their contextual appropriateness, and their operationalisation for a concrete AI agent. What we mean by SLEEC norm operationalisation is the complex process of identifying relevant social, legal, ethical, empathetic and cultural norms, and translating them into unambiguous, concrete requirements that are then validated, implemented by an AI agent under development, and verified prior to deploying that agent . Addressing the critical question of SLEEC norm operationalisation for concrete AI agents requires reaching down to individual cases and applying norms practically in real-world contexts. For high-level norms to be useful, we need to ground them in evaluative standards specified as normative requirements through a systematic process of SLEEC rule elicitation ( townsend2022pluralistic ) , validation, and refinement ( feng2024analyzing ; feng2024normative ; feng2023towards ; getir2023specification ; Troquard2024 ) . Furthermore, the AI agent for which a SLEEC ruleset is obtained using this process must be verified to ensure its SLEEC-rule compliance ( yaman2023specification ; getir2023specification ; yaman2024toolkit ) . Finally, if on-the-fly code synthesis is used for enhanced autonomy, these rules need to be considered during deployment as well ( sleec-adapt-2025 ) . Adopting such a SLEEC-norm operationalisation approach is the only way to ensure that AI agent actions in response to stimuli are modelled on those that a human moral agent following the applicable norms would undertake in response to a similar body of information. Traditional requirements and systems engineering methods are ill-equipped for this task. They lack the mechanisms to effectively engage the broad range of required technical and non-technical stakeholders, to operate at the high abstraction level of normative principles, to deal with the complex and often subtle conflicts inherent in normative requirements, and to provide SLEEC requirement well-formedness and AI agent compliance guarantees. This paper explores how recent research advances in SLEEC norm elicitation, validation, and verification ( townsend2022pluralistic ; feng2024analyzing ; feng2024normative ; feng2023towards ; getir2023specification ; yaman2023specification ; yaman2024toolkit ; sleec-adapt-2025 ; townsend2025normative ; kleijwegt2025tool ) contribute to addressing this gap, and discusses remaining challenges for the systematic operationalisation of normative requirements for AI agents. To that end, we propose a SLEEC-norm operationalisation process . We summarise the stages and activities of this process, and overview the methods and tools already available to carry out some of these activities. Looking ahead, we then discuss remaining challenges that must be addressed to ensure efficient and effective SLEEC norm operationalisation for the rapidly expanding range of AI technologies and applications, outlining initial steps and avenues to tackle these challenges. 2. SLEEC Norm Operationalisation Process The operationalisation of SLEEC norms requires dedicated activities throughout the AI agent development lifecycle. Many of these activities are often uncommon for other types of AI agent requirements, or pose challenges not encountered for conventional engineered systems. Figure 1 . SLEEC norm operationalisation process. Successful completion of all stages is necessary for the deployment of a SLEEC-norm-compliant AI agent; failure at any point precludes the agent’s deployment. Diagram of the SLEEC norm operationalisation process. Our proposed process, illustrated in Figure 1 , consists of five stages. Stages 1 and 2 involve determining the functional capabilities of the AI agent, and eliciting its SLEEC requirements, and are carried out as part of the planning phase of the agent’s development lifecycle. Stage 3 encompasses the formal well-formedness checking of the SLEEC requirements, to identify and resolve issues such as conflicts and redundancies; this stage is part of the analysis phase of the lifecycle. Stage 4 translates validated SLEEC requirements into implementable agent abstractions, learning-time data schemas, and runtime guardrails, enabling both enforced compliance at deployment, and controlled adaptation when SLEEC requirements evolve. Stage 5, potentially extending across the design, implementation and testing phases of development, comprises the verification of the agent’s compliance with its SLEEC requirements. Successful verification leads to the deployment of the AI agent. If verification or any earlier-stage activity fails, the SLEEC norm operationalisation process is halted, potentially precluding the development or deployment of the AI agent. As indicated in Figure 1 , the process is inherently iterative: feedback from the activities of a stage may trigger a return to an earlier stage to fine-tune that