Unequal changes in commuting patterns across socio-economic strata in response to pandemic restrictions
Cristiano Marinelli, Leo Ferres, Niccolò Comini, Nicolò Gozzi, Nicola Perra · 2026
Read Unequal changes in commuting patterns across socio-economic strata in response to pandemic restrictions by Cristiano Marinelli, Leo Ferres, Niccolò Comini, Nicolò Gozzi, Nicola Perra (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11758.txt.
Introduction
Marinelli and co-authors track how pandemic restrictions reshaped work commuting in Bogotá across income strata. Anonymized mobile phone data reveal home and work spots from nightly and weekday connection patterns. Daily commuting measures then get grouped by district and socioeconomic stratum. Commuting fell hard under 2020 restrictions and bounced back strongly in 2021. The rebound split by income: poorer groups returned to pre-pandemic levels faster. Richer groups, in contrast, kept higher stay-at-home rates. The data also carry land use, population density, and Speedtest readings as context.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cristiano Marinelli, Leo Ferres, Niccolò Comini, Nicolò Gozzi, Nicola Perra |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 76991 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11758
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unequal changes in commuting patterns across socio-economic strata in response to pandemic restrictions Cristiano Marinelli, Leo Ferres, Niccolò Comini, Nicolò Gozzi, Nicola Perra Abstract Commuting patterns are a central component of urban dynamics and many societal activities. Exogenous shocks, such as a pandemic, might drastically modify them inducing heterogeneous variations across socioeconomic strata. Here, we quantify changes in work commuting patterns in Bogotá, Colombia during three different periods of the COVID-19 pandemic: pre-pandemic ( 2019 2019 ), COVID-19 restrictions ( 2020 2020 ), and partial reopening ( 2021 2021 ). To this end, we use anonymized mobile phone data to infer home and work locations from recurring nighttime and weekday connection patterns, and to build daily commuting metrics. We aggregate mobility flows by administrative boundaries and socioeconomic strata. Additionally, we enrich the dataset with a range of other variables such as territorial vocation (i.e., urban versus rural), demographic information (i.e., population density) and, as a proxy for digital infrastructure quality, geolocated Speedtest ® measurements from Ookla ® . We find a marked reduction of commuting during restrictions in 2020 2020 and a strong recovery in 2021 2021 , but with persistent heterogeneity across socioeconomic strata. Indeed, while commuting declined similarly across income groups during restrictions, groups of the population in the lower-income bracket rebounded faster to pre-pandemic levels. On the contrary, we find that groups in the higher-income bracket managed to keep higher stay-at-home behavior. Regression analyses reveal that territorial characteristics and disparities in digital connectivity significantly contribute to these differences, suggesting that infrastructure investments could help mitigate mobility-based inequalities. 1 Introduction Human mobility is a fundamental driver of social, economic, and environmental processes across spatio-temporal scales. Movements are critical for social interactions, access to job opportunities, urbanization, and the spread of infectious diseases [ 59 , 32 , 46 , 45 , 6 ] . Mobility patterns are complex and dynamic, yet they exhibit repeating structures that shape society, such as commuting to work [ 21 , 56 , 14 , 36 , 43 , 1 ] . At the same time, the way we move is influenced by exogenous factors that interact heterogeneously with local conditions across socio-economic strata. Large-scale emergencies, like pandemics, might abruptly disrupt mobility flows, creating natural experiments to investigate the interplay between such external shocks and local contexts in different groups of the population [ 48 , 19 , 55 , 28 , 16 , 10 , 54 , 34 , 25 ] . Indeed, during the COVID-19 Pandemic, the drastic contraction in mobility we witnessed had far-reaching and unequal socioeconomic consequences. Restrictions on movement and commercial activity triggered one of the largest employment shocks in recent history, resulting in income losses and reduced purchasing power that reinforced existing and structural inequities [ 51 , 12 , 47 , 50 ] . Decline in public transport usage was particularly pronounced, as it was directly targeted by containment policies [ 13 , 4 , 22 , 3 ] . Since public transport users are disproportionately drawn from lower-income groups, these groups were among the most severely affected by mobility restrictions. At the same time, essential workers—who continued commuting to/from work to sustain critical economic functions—were also predominantly drawn from lower-income social strata. Evidence suggests that mobility reductions were less pronounced among these groups [ 8 , 58 , 5 , 25 ] . Despite these unequal impacts, the temporary reduction in commuting also produced short-lived positive externalities, including sharp declines in emissions and relief for workers previously exposed to long commuting times, which are known to be associated with lower well-being and poorer mental health outcomes [ 40 , 15 , 37 ] . More broadly, the disruption of commuting has fueled discussions on proximity-based urban planning approaches aimed at reducing long daily commutes and improving urban well-being [ 2 ] . These dynamics are particularly salient in cities of the Global South, where high rates of informal and often precarious employment are compounded by rapid urbanization and high population densities. In Latin America, approximately 80\% of the population resides in urban areas, making cities the primary arena in which socioeconomic inequalities and mobility constraints intersect [ 49 ] . The urban geographies of the region are characterized by pronounced spatial segregation driven by differences in income, socioeconomic stratification, and ethnicity, which correlate with unequal access to housing, infrastructure, and local amenities. Nearly a quarter of the urban population lives in dense informal settlements [ 31 ] . At the same time, the concentration of economic activities and high land values in a limited number of central areas, combined with sustained demographic growth, have contributed to the expansion of low-income populations in peripheral zones. As a result, the urban structure of many Latin American cities generates disproportionately long travel times for populations that rely primarily on public transport and active modes, which together account for a large share of daily trips [ 17 ] . During the COVID-19 Pandemic, these structural conditions amplified the distributional effects of mobility restrictions, particularly in contexts where reductions in public transport supply increased waiting times, congestion, and social tensions in high-density urban areas [ 4 ] . Understanding how commuting patterns respond to large-scale disruptions has traditionally relied on travel surveys and census data. While surveys provide rich socioeconomic detail, they are costly, infrequent, and subject to sampling and cognitive biases. In recent years, the increasing availability of mobile phone data, such as Call Detail Records (CDR) and eXtended Data Records (XDRs), has enabled researchers to observe population mobility with unprecedented spatial and temporal resolution. Despite ongoing methodological challenges related to the inference of trips and interactions from sparse network connections, these data have been widely used to study commuting flows and behavioral responses to policy interventions [ 35 , 34 ] . Urban mobility research has long examined how movement patterns relate to the physical structure of cities, transportation networks, population density, and socioeconomic characteristics. More recently, attention has also turned to the role of digital infrastructure, particularly Internet accessibility, as a factor shaping mobility behavior and the feasibility of remote work [ 23 , 24 , 41 , 52 ] . However, empirical evidence based on high-resolution mobility data remains heavily concentrated in developed countries, leaving important gaps in our understanding of commuting dynamics in developing regions. In this context, here we focus on commuting patterns—defined as regular movements between inferred home and work locations—in the metropolitan area of Bogotá, Colombia between 2019 and 2021 . Bogotá represents a particularly relevant case study: it is a large and highly urbanized Latin American city that has implemented substantial mobility and social policies, yet continues to exhibit marked socioeconomic inequalities [ 26 ] . The city also features a well-established socioeconomic stratification system at the cadastral-block level, which provides a reliable proxy for residents’ income [ 27 ] . We analyze anonymized mobile phone XDR data covering three distinct periods: a pre-pandemic baseline, the phase of strict COVID-19 mobility restrictions in 2020 , and the 2021 period characterized by partial reopening. To enrich the mobility information, we integrate these data with multiple external sources capturing socioeconomic stratification, territorial vocation (i.e., urban versus rural), demographic information, and measures of digital