The number of measures on very large measurable cardinals
Arthur W. Apter, Eyal Kaplan, Alejandro Poveda · 2026
Read The number of measures on very large measurable cardinals by Arthur W. Apter, Eyal Kaplan, Alejandro Poveda (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11710.txt.
Introduction
Apter, Kaplan, and Poveda study how many normal measures a measurable cardinal can carry in settings beyond inner model methods. Their tools come from consequences of the Ultrapower Axiom. One result joins the classical Kimchi-Magidor theorem with any prescribed pattern of measure counts on the first n measurable cardinals. Another shows the first such cardinal above a supercompact can carry any given number of normal measures. The same holds at the first measurable limit of supercompacts. The work also strengthens results of Goldberg, Woodin, and others.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Arthur W. Apter, Eyal Kaplan, Alejandro Poveda |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 154632 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11710
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The number of measures on very large measurable cardinals Arthur W. Apter, Eyal Kaplan, Alejandro Poveda Abstract . We study the possible number of normal measures on a measurable cardinal in settings where inner model techniques are unavailable. Instead, we exploit consequences of the Ultrapower Axiom to obtain our theorems. We show that the classical Kimchi–Magidor result—that the first n n measurable cardinals can be strongly compact—can be combined with an arbitrary prescribed pattern for the number of normal measures they carry. We also prove that the first measurable cardinal above a supercompact cardinal can carry any given number of normal measures; the same conclusion is established for the first measurable limit of supercompact cardinals. As further applications of our techniques, we strengthen an unpublished theorem of Goldberg–Woodin and a theorem of Goldberg, Osinski, and Poveda. Our analysis circumvents both the reliance of Friedman–Magidor [ 14 ] on core model methods and the limitations of the Prikry-type forcing iterations of [ 16 ] . 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 03E35, 03E55 1. Introduction The present manuscript studies the number of normal measures on a measurable cardinal . Measurable cardinals trace their origin to the classical work of S. Ulam [ 40 ] in connection with the Lebesgue measure problem. A cardinal \kappa is called measurable if there exists a non-principal, \kappa -complete ultrafilter on \kappa . 1 1 1 Such an ultrafilter U trivially induces a nontrivial, two-valued, \kappa -additive measure on \mathcal{P}(\kappa) . Indeed, the measure \mu\colon\mathcal{P}(\kappa)\to{0,1} associated with U assigns the value 1 to a set if and only if it belongs to U . Normal measures on \kappa are such ultrafilters that are additionally closed under diagonal intersections. It is well-known that every measurable cardinal carries at least one normal measure. The question of how many normal measures a measurable cardinal may carry has been a significant and well-studied problem in recent decades, culminating in its complete solution by Friedman and Magidor in [ 14 ] (see the discussion below). In this paper, we are interested in measurable cardinals that coexist with very large cardinals , such as strongly compact and supercompact cardinals. A cardinal \kappa is strongly compact if, for every cardinal \lambda\geq\kappa , there exists a fine, \kappa -complete ultrafilter on \mathcal{P}_{\kappa}(\lambda)=\{X\subseteq\lambda:|X|<\kappa\} . A cardinal \kappa is supercompact if, for every \lambda\geq\kappa , there exists a fine, normal ultrafilter on \mathcal{P}_{\kappa}(\lambda) . Both are very strong forms of measurability and strictly exceed measurable cardinals in consistency strength. Studying the higher levels of the large cardinal hierarchy can be challenging due to the current lack of a canonical inner model for a supercompact cardinal. The construction of canonical inner models in set theory originated with Gödel’s discovery of the universe of constructible sets, denoted by L . However, L itself cannot accommodate most large cardinals—for instance, by a classical theorem of Scott, there are no measurable cardinals in L . Nevertheless, over the years a sequence of L -like models accommodating progressively stronger large cardinals has been developed, and the inner model program aims to construct such models for all large cardinal axioms. The inner model theoretic approach provides powerful tools and techniques for addressing fundamental questions about large cardinals. The possible number of normal measures on a measurable cardinal is a concrete example of such a question. Indeed, Kunen constructed the canonical inner model for a measurable cardinal, L[U] , and showed that it carries a unique normal measure. Later, Mitchell developed inner models of the form L[\vec{U}] , constructed from coherent sequences of measures \vec{U} , which can exhibit measurable cardinals carrying any reasonable number of normal measures. However, Mitchell’s construction requires assumptions beyond the existence of a single measurable cardinal. It was not clear whether the existence of a single measurable cardinal suffices to establish the consistency of a measurable cardinal \kappa carrying exactly \lambda normal measures, for a prescribed cardinal 1<\lambda<\kappa^{++} . 2 2 2 We concentrate here on the GCH context, under which the number of normal measures on a measurable cardinal \kappa is at most \kappa^{++} . The first major step towards resolving this problem was made in the early 70’s by Kunen–Paris [ 30 ] , who showed that starting from a single measurable cardinal \kappa , one can produce a forcing extension in which the number of normal measures on \kappa is any cardinal \lambda of cofinality greater than \kappa^{+} . In particular, one can achieve the maximal possible number of normal measures, 2^{2^{\kappa}} . More recently, Apter–Cummings–Hamkins [ 1 ] addressed the first case beyond the scope of the Kunen–Paris technique; namely, starting from a single measurable cardinal \kappa , the authors constructed a generic extension where \kappa carries exactly \kappa^{+} normal measures. Still, this left open the question of whether, from a single measurable cardinal, one can produce a model of ZFC with exactly \lambda normal measures for any cardinal \lambda\leq\kappa^{+} . The above problem was completely resolved by Friedman and Magidor in their pioneering work [ 14 ] . Friedman–Magidor’s work not only settled a long-standing open problem, but also skillfully exploited a number of sophisticated techniques that nowadays play a pivotal role in the field. These include forcing over canonical inner models, the use of nonstationary support iterations, generalized Sacks forcing, and self-coding forcing. The lasting influence of Friedman–Magidor’s ideas in the area can be better appreciated through subsequent works like [ 11 , 12 , 9 , 7 , 3 , 23 , 4 , 16 , 8 , 24 ] . One of the distinctive aspects of the Friedman–Magidor proof is that it requires forcing over a canonical inner model (see [ 38 ] ). This feature is essential to their strategy for controlling the normal measures that appear in the generic extension in two ways. First, the new normal measures satisfy that the restriction of their ultrapower embeddings to the ground model is an iterated ultrapower of the core model [ 31 , 37 , 39 ] –– such iterated ultrapowers are particularly well understood, thanks to the nature of the core model. Second, the Friedman–Magidor forcing incorporates a coding mechanism that prevents unwanted normal measures from being created, and in turn this coding utilizes the fine structure of the ground model This fine-structural approach, if elegant, imposes serious limitations on the extent of the applicability of Friedman–Magidor’s methods. Namely, they are limited to those large cardinals within the reach of current inner model theory. For instance, the methodology cannot be leveraged to say anything about the number of normal measures on the first strongly compact cardinal, let alone on the first measurable limit of supercompact cardinals. In response to this, work of Gitik and the second author [ 16 ] suggested an alternative route to bypass these limitations. Their methods make it possible to show, for instance, that the first strongly compact cardinal can carry exactly \eta normal measures \langle U_{\tau}:\tau<\eta\rangle , where each U_{\tau} has Mitchell order \tau , and there are no other measurable cardinals with Mitchell order greater than or equal to \eta [ 16 , Theorem 4.16] . This is proved assuming the consistency of a supercompact cardinal with GCH and the linearity of the Mitchell order