Mpemba Effect in Many-Body Systems Near Equilibrium
P. Ben-Abdallah · 2026
Read Mpemba Effect in Many-Body Systems Near Equilibrium by P. Ben-Abdallah (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11707.txt.
Introduction
Ben-Abdallah builds a unified framework for the Mpemba effect in many-body systems near equilibrium. A system starting farther from equilibrium can relax faster than a closer one. He splits the effect into a non-uniform kind, marked by crossing global distances, and a strict componentwise kind. Reciprocal systems, he shows, allow only the first kind. Breaking reciprocity makes the operator non-normal and can unlock the strict kind.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | P. Ben-Abdallah |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19273 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11707
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mpemba Effect in Many-Body Systems Near Equilibrium P. Ben-Abdallah Abstract The Mpemba effect, in which a system initially farther from equilibrium relaxes faster than a closer one, is often associated with nonlinear or far-from-equilibrium dynamics. We show that this effect can arise entirely within the linear-response regime of many-body systems. In reciprocal systems, a uniform Mpemba effect emerges for three or more degrees of freedom via spectral separation of fast and slow modes. Breaking reciprocity renders the relaxation operator non-normal, enabling a strict componentwise Mpemba effect, with the hotter state relaxing faster even in every individual degree of freedom. When two systems relax toward a common equilibrium, one naturally expects that the state initially farther from equilibrium will remain farther away at all subsequent times. Relaxation processes typically preserve the ordering of deviations from equilibrium. Surprisingly, under certain conditions a system that starts farther from equilibrium can approach equilibrium faster than one that begins closer. This counterintuitive phenomenon is known as the Mpemba effect , first reported in water freezing experiments Mpemba and subsequently observed in a wide range of classical and quantum systems Lasanta ; Kumar ; Lu ; Klich ; Ares ; Baity . In general, a Mpemba effect occurs when the global distance to equilibrium of an initially hotter system crosses that of a colder one at a finite time (Fig. 1 ). Most existing explanations rely on nonlinear dynamics, metastability, or complex energy landscapes, where initially hotter systems exploit faster relaxation pathways through multiple basins or temperature-dependent transitions. Such mechanisms have been identified, for example, in granular fluids, spin glasses and quantum systems Lasanta ; Baity ; Klich . While these scenarios successfully explain specific realizations of the effect, they typically involve dynamics far from equilibrium and remain strongly system dependent. In this Letter, we show that the Mpemba effect can arise entirely within the linear-response regime of cooperative many-body systems. In this regime, relaxation is governed by a linear operator whose spectral geometry determines how perturbations decay toward equilibrium. We demonstrate that reciprocity imposes strong constraints on anomalous relaxation: for reciprocal interactions the dynamics form a gradient flow, allowing faster global relaxation of a hotter state only for three or more degrees of freedom and forbidding a genuine componentwise Mpemba inversion. Breaking reciprocity fundamentally changes this picture. Nonreciprocal interactions render the relaxation operator non-normal, so that projection and decay directions differ, enabling transient reorientation of perturbations even when all eigenvalues correspond to decay Trefethen ; Schmid . Within this framework, we show that non-normality alone can produce a non-uniform Mpemba effect, while a true componentwise Mpemba effect—where the hotter state is initially larger in every degree of freedom yet relaxes faster—generally requires active interactions. These results reveal that anomalous relaxation is controlled by the spectral geometry of the relaxation operator and provide a unified linear framework for Mpemba physics in many-body systems. Figure 1: (a) Mechanical analogy of the Mpemba effect: relaxation corresponds to overdamped motion in an effective potential V_{\mathrm{eff}}(\Theta)=\tfrac{1}{2}\Theta^{T}M\Theta , with the bottom representing equilibrium. Two initial states are shown: a hotter state (red) aligned with steep directions, and a colder state (green) along shallow directions. (b) Non-uniform Mpemba effect with a many-body system: the hotter state relaxes faster globally without being componentwise larger. (c) True Mpemba effect with a many-body system: the hotter state is strictly larger in all components and still relaxes faster. To formalize these statements, we consider small deviations \Theta\in\mathbb{R}^{N} from equilibrium for N interacting degrees of freedom, which may represent local temperatures in thermal networks, populations in linearized kinetic networks or occupation probabilities in Markov processes. Reciprocal systems. — When microscopic reciprocity holds, the relaxation matrix M is symmetric and positive definite, with non-positive off-diagonal entries and the time evolution of the system is driven by the dynamic linear system \dot{\Theta}=-M\Theta. (1) Then, the relaxation process decomposes into independent collective modes \Theta(t)=\sum_{k=1}^{N}a_{k}v_{k}e^{-\lambda_{k}t}, (2) with eigenvectors v_{k} and rates \lambda_{k} . Large \lambda_{k} correspond to fast-decaying modes, small \lambda_{k} to slow bottlenecks. The initial projections a_{k} determine the global relaxation behavior. For two-body systems, all eigenvector components have the same sign. Consequently, initial ordering of modal amplitudes is preserved, a_{\pm}^{(h)}-a_{\pm}^{(c)}\geq 0, (3) and the global norm difference \displaystyle\Phi(t) \displaystyle=\|\Theta^{(h)}(t)\|^{2}-\|\Theta^{(c)}(t)\|^{2} \displaystyle=A_{+}e^{-2\lambda_{+}t}+A_{-}e^{-2\lambda_{-}t},\quad A_{\pm}\geq 0, (4) cannot change sign. Therefore, a Mpemba effect is impossible. For three or more degrees of freedom, the situation changes because the eigenvectors of the relaxation matrix can have mixed signs. As a result, the hotter state may project more strongly onto fast-decaying modes and more weakly onto slow ones. In that case, the difference in global distance to equilibrium \Phi(t)=\sum_{k}\Delta a_{k}\,e^{-2\lambda_{k}t} (5) can change sign at a finite time t^{\ast} , producing a Mpemba effect. However, because the relaxation matrix is symmetric, the dynamics correspond to a gradient flow in which cooperative interactions preserve the ordering of the state components. In particular, if the hotter initial state is strictly larger than the colder one in every component, this componentwise ordering cannot be reversed during relaxation. Each degree of freedom of the hotter state therefore remains larger than the corresponding one of the colder state at all times. Consequently, a true (componentwise) Mpemba effect—where a state that is initially larger in every coordinate becomes globally closer to equilibrium—is forbidden in reciprocal linear systems. Only a uniform Mpemba effect can occur: the hotter state may relax faster in terms of its global distance to equilibrium, but this requires that it is not larger in every component initially, so that different projections onto the fast and slow relaxation modes control the dynamics. Geometrically, the relaxation can be viewed as a gradient descent in the quadratic potential V_{\rm eff}(\Theta)=\tfrac{1}{2}\Theta^{T}M\Theta,\qquad\dot{\Theta}=-\nabla_{\Theta}V_{\rm eff}. (6) In this picture (Fig. 1 ), fast modes correspond to steep directions of the potential landscape, while slow modes correspond to shallow directions. A hotter initial state can therefore relax faster globally if it is preferentially aligned with the steep directions, even though the componentwise ordering of the states is preserved. Figure 2: Mpemba effect in a many-body system (a) made with three SiC nanoparticles (radius r=50~\mathrm{nm} ) arranged in a scalene triangle which exhange heat between them and with an external bath by radiation in near-field and far-field, respectively. Double arrows indicate the strength of radiative coupling G_{ij} , the shortest separation d_{12}=3r corresponding to the strongest interaction. All particles are coupled to the bath (wavy arrows) at T_{b}=300~\mathrm{K} . (b) Distance to the equilibrium \mathcal{D}(t)=\|\Theta^{(h,c)}(t)\| for a “hot” initial state \Theta^{(h)}(0)=(25,-23,-1.5) (red) and a “cold” initial state \Theta^{(c)}(0)=(4,4,4) (blue). Despite starting farther from equilibrium, the hot state relaxes faster at short times due to suppressed projection onto the slowest mode, producing a clear crossing, showing a non-uniform Mpemba effect. Non-reciprocal systems. – When reciprocity is broken, the relaxation matrix M is no longer symmetric. Although stability still requires \mathrm{Re}\,\lambda_{k}>0 for all eigenvalues, the operator is generally non-normal, MM^{\dagger}\neq M^{\dagger}M . Then, right and left eigenvectors differ and form a biorthogonal basis. The spectral decomposition of the dynamic matrix reads e^{-Mt}=\sum_{k}e^{-\lambda_{k}t}\,v_{k}\otimes w_{k},\qquad w_{k}^{\!\top}v_{\ell}=\delta_{k\ell}, (7) so that modal amplitudes are determined by projections onto the left eigenvectors, a_{k}=w_{k}^{\!\top}\Theta(0), (8) rather than by orthogonal projections as in reciprocal systems. Because left and right eigenvectors are misaligned, non-normal dynamics can transiently