One-Shot Individual Claims Reserving

Ronald Richman, Mario V. Wüthrich · 2026

Read One-Shot Individual Claims Reserving by Ronald Richman, Mario V. Wüthrich (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11660.txt.

Introduction

Richman and Wüthrich reopen the debate on individual claims reserving, a method not yet standard in actuarial practice. In their view, older approaches are either too complex or too rigid and fragile for daily use. Their earlier work reframed the task from the classical chain-ladder method at the level of single claims. That piece drew wide discussion in the actuarial community. Here they continue and deepen the exchange. The stated goal is a new standard for micro-level reserving.

Catalog record

CREATORRonald Richman, Mario V. Wüthrich
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE108775
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11660

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

One-Shot Individual Claims Reserving Ronald Richman, Mario V. Wüthrich Abstract Individual claims reserving has not yet become established in actuarial practice. We attribute this to the absence of a satisfactory methodology: existing approaches tend to be either overly complex or insufficiently flexible and robust for practical use. Building on the classical chain-ladder (CL) method, we introduced a new perspective on individual claims reserving in Richman and Wüthrich [ arXiv:2602.15385 ]. This manuscript has sparked considerable discussion within the actuarial community. The aim of the present paper is to continue and deepen that discussion, with the ultimate goal of advancing toward a new standard for micro-level reserving. Keywords. Claims reserving, chain-ladder method, individual claims reserving, micro-level reserving, granular reserving, neural networks, Mack’s method. 1 Introduction We recently uploaded an individual claims reserving proposal to arXiv:2602.15385 that addressed many of the shortcomings present in the published micro-reserving literature; see Richman–Wüthrich [ 10 ] . Starting from the classical chain-ladder (CL) method of Mack [ 8 ] , we derived an alternative representation of the ultimate claim predictor. This alternative representation motivates a direct estimation of projection-to-ultimate (PtU) factors which allow for a one-shot forecast of the ultimate claims. The approach extends naturally to individual claims reserving for reported but not settled (RBNS) claims, allowing one to incorporate arbitrary input information (including dynamic stochastic covariates) into the estimation procedure of individual RBNS claims reserves. Our arXiv paper has stimulated substantial discussion of the proposed approach, indicating that this may be a promising way forward for individual claims reserving. It has also been noted that our main CL result is not new, it had previously appeared in the literature by Lorenz–Schmidt [ 5 ] . The purpose of the present manuscript is to address the many points raised in these discussions and to examine the open issues identified, we also refer to Richman–Wüthrich [ 10 , Section 5] for a list of potential next steps. We begin by summarizing some of the feedback received; an acknowledgement is found at the end of this section. • “Maybe I am confusing the methods here but for triangles your PtU factors are called grossing-up factors, could that be? (because I think this recursive technique was already used for triangles in the grossing-up method of (Handbook of Loss Reserving, Radtke, p 127))?”; comment by Florian Gerhardt. This is indeed correct – thank you! We were not aware of the corresponding result of Lorenz–Schmidt [ 6 , page 130] ; in fact, this CL result was first published by the same authors [ 5 ] in 1999. Following their theorem in Lorenz–Schmidt [ 6 , page 130] , the authors state “…, the grossing up method is irrelevant in practice.” We believe that this assessment is too pessimistic in the era of machine learning. In our view, precisely this structural perspective provides the key to bringing individual claims reserving into practical applications. This is also supported by the following comments that we received: • “Your comment ’An alternative of building full simulation models for complex claims processes with multiple stochastic covariates and nested projections is not very practical’ is interesting – this is basically what I was working on at the start of my career! Admittedly without a lot of the complexity you could build into it, because it was too computationally intensive back then. But I’m not at all convinced it’s impractical nowadays.”; comment by Chris Dolman. • “I experimented with a similar idea several years ago and a couple of clients reported back that it worked well. They kept their existing triangle methods to keep the regulator happy but used the individual claim ultimate cost machine learning approach to inform the triangle parameters.”; comment by Colin Priest. • “I’ve worked on something very similar two years ago. I called it ’Similarity score weighted micro chain ladder’. It also had the same recursive pattern, but predictions of the point to ultimate estimates per claim were made with simple classification techniques to estimate distance measures between the claim to predict with older claims to take a weighted average point to ultimate (as opposed to using a NN for this as in your case). It becomes computationally complex really quickly. One thing I found quite useful for computational efficiency here was to group claims in operational time bands instead of development periods. This works especially well if you have transaction dates in your data. In this work we were specifically looking to close the gap between micro reserving and triangle reserving since adoption of micro reserving has been so poor. Great to see you guys also moving into this space.”; comment by Stephan Marais. • “Wondering if it’s the same idea as in the addendum [to Semenovich [ 12 ] ]? This is something I looked into originally 10+ years ago. But never got to a satisfactory formulation around doing joint IBNR and IBNER estimation in a single regression model until the method in the addendum.”; comment by Dimitri Semenovich. • “Did something similar to estimate prob default after 12 months in IFRS9 …”; comment by Willem Ras. • “This is really interesting work. I think micro reserving is the next step in reserving, not just for improved accuracy, but also for greater flexibility. As soon as data is compressed into a triangle, much of the claim-level information is lost. Parodi’s triangle-free paper [ 9 ] makes this point nicely with the analogy of moving from a high-resolution to a low-resolution picture. Working at claim level makes it easier to reflect environmental shifts, such as inflation shocks, detect changes in business mix earlier or generate different views since IBNR is produced from bottom-up. But triangles have survived for nearly a century for a reason: they are simple, robust, and hard to fool. So I expect they will stick around for the foreseeable future.”; comment by Claudio Rebelo. The above feedback is very exciting, and it seems that many colleagues have been considering such or a similar approach. We see our first main contribution in documenting all these similar thoughts and in making the link to the PtU factors in a CL context, which turned out to be the grossing-up method of Lorenz–Schmidt [ 6 ] . Concerning the last remark, (individual) claims reserving data has a natural triangular structure through censoring at the present evaluation date. The present paper illustrates how triangular methods on aggregated data can be refined to be able to operate on individual claim-level information. There were two main critical points raised above: the computational side (which indeed may be demanding) and the recursive structure (which may be prone to biases). We will come back to these issues in the next bullet points and in our numerical studies below. The proposal in the addendum to Semenovich [ 12 ] starts from a cross-classified Poisson model, which provides a different way of computing the CL reserves; see Hachemeister–Stanard [ 2 ] , Kremer [ 3 ] and Mack [ 7 ] . This cross-classified structure presents a more restrictive model from a mathematical perspective, but from a computational viewpoint it circumvents the recursive estimation and forecast structure. This indeed may provide another very promising alternative, i.e., by solving

Read the complete text