An observer-based approach to the sorites paradox and the logic derived from that

Athanassios Tzouvaras · 2026

Read An observer-based approach to the sorites paradox and the logic derived from that by Athanassios Tzouvaras (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11624.txt.

Introduction

Tzouvaras attacks the sorites paradox with an observer-based view of truth for claims. His fluxing-object semantics uses models whose objects change over time, watched by agents on a discrete time line. The objects are partial functions of time and agent, so truth values can go missing. Read as a third value, the gaps give a logic proved identical to strong Kleene three-valued logic. Sorites objects change too slowly for an observer to catch. Interrupted watching explains it: in the gaps, the property can shift unseen.

Catalog record

CREATORAthanassios Tzouvaras
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46618
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11624

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An observer-based approach to the sorites paradox and the logic derived from that Athanassios Tzouvaras Abstract We approach the sorites paradox (SP) through an observer-based and time-dependent approach to truth of vague assertions. Formally the approach gives rise to a semantics, called fluxing-object semantics (FOS), because it involves models that contain “fluxing objects”, that is, entities changing with time and observer. The models are equipped with agents (observers) and a linear and discrete time axis for time. The changing entities are represented by partial functions of time and agent, and this partiality causes truth-value gaps. If we interpret a truth-value gap as a third truth value, then FOS becomes a three-valued logic, which, quite interestingly, is proved identical to strong Kleene three-valued logic. The sorites phenomena can be represented in a structure of FOS as special objects that change imperceptibly with respect to an observer and with respect to a particular attribute. In this account the key point that eliminates the paradoxical character of sorites is the partiality of functions. When the observer is fixed the partiality corresponds to interrupted watching on his part. The interruption creates watching gaps during which the attributed property of the object as understood by the observer may change, without violating the imperceptibility condition. Interrupted watching has, according to experts on visual attention and focusing capabilities of humans, a firm physiological justification. The relationship of watching gaps with horizon crossing is also discussed. Aristotle University of Thessaloniki Department of Mathematics 541 24 Thessaloniki, Greece e-mail: [email protected] Mathematics Subject Classification (2020) : 03B80, 06B50 Key words and phrases. Sorites paradox, vague predicate, watching gap, fluxing-object semantics, imperceptibly changing object, strong Kleene logic. 1 Introduction The sorites paradox (henceforth abbreviated SP) is a well-known and persistent puzzle arising in the area of vagueness, specifically in discrete vagueness, i.e., vague predicates which refer to quantities measured by natural numbers (baldness, bigness, heapness, etc). Mathematically SP amounts to failure of induction: Some vague predicates create subsets of ℕ without least element. For example if P(n) denotes the property “ n is small” (or “ n is not big”), n a positive integer, then clearly the extensions of both P(n) and \neg P(n) are nonempty. Moreover, since common wisdom necessitates P(n)\Rightarrow P(n+1) , the transition from the extension of P(n) to that of \neg P(n) is done in a mysterious and incomprehensible way, without crossing any boundary and without one being able to tell when and how this transition is realized. We call such a transition from P(n) to \neg P(n) , or conversely, a vague transition. Vague transitions are of course genuinely paradoxical (i.e., contradictory) for the set ℕ of ordinary integers. If we insist to assign set extensions to such predicates, then the only mathematical option available seems to be the use of nonstandard models of arithmetic, which do permit the existence of sets without least element. This approach has been taken in [ 14 ] , where it is shown that such models do represent faithfully most of the fundamental aspects of vague predicates. For example if M is a nonstandard model with \hbox{\nat\char 78\relax}\subset M , then the sets ℕ and M\backslash\hbox{\nat\char 78\relax} model a vague transition, since ℕ and M\backslash\hbox{\nat\char 78\relax} have no last and first elements, respectively. But nonstandard integers are totally infeasible and hence unable to be used in everyday experience (more in section 4.2). In this paper we provide a formal description of vague transitions without leaving the ground of standard natural numbers. As for the logic that the changing (in fact fluxing) entities obey, we shall adopt a special semantics suitable for their description, that heavily relies on a factor not taken into account in standard treatments of SP (e.g. those of [ 2 ] , [ 4 ] and [ 10 ] ). Namely, the role of an observer who is present at each particular sorites event and announces whether (they believe that) a given object a satisfies P or non- P . This semantics, called fluxing object semantics (FOS), will be considered in section 2. 1.1 The content of the paper Our approach adopted here to SP is based to an agent-dependent and time-dependent formalization of truth. It is a variant of classical semantics of propositional logic, with the difference that the objects of the ground model are not constant but “fluxing”, i.e., constantly changing, as partial functions of time and observer. It is called fluxing-object semantics (FOS). In FOS we have a time axis represented by ℕ and a set I of observers (although we mostly refer to a single observer i ). The changing objects are represented by partial (actually finite) functions from I\times\hbox{\nat\char 78\relax} into a classical relational structure {\cal A}=\langle A,R_{1},R_{2},\ldots\rangle . The partiality of functions f makes it possible to have points t<t^{\prime}<s on the time axis such that f(i,t) and f(i,s) are defined, while f(i,t^{\prime}) is not. This is interpreted as a “watching gap” between t and s concerning the observation of the object f by the observer i . Watching gaps entail that the observation of objects and situations is generally done interruptedly, or intermittently. The total period of watching splits into disjoint intervals of time, with watching gaps among them. By the definition of imperceptibly changing situations no vague transition is possible during the time of uninterrupted perceptual focusing. Therefore if any vague transition takes place within a specific changing situation, it takes place only during a watching gap. Since there can be plenty of watching gaps in the formal representation of objects, this easily provides a solution to SP. Another remarkable feature of FOS is the following. As expected, the partiality of the functions used in the FOS domains, i.e. the watching gaps, produces truth-value gaps in its satisfaction relation \Vdash . If we interpret these gaps as a third truth value (undetermined), then FOS gives rise to a three-valued logic. It is interesting that this logic (in the form of truth tables for the connectives \wedge , \vee and \neg ) is identical to the strong Kleene three-valued logic. The paper is organized as follows: In section 2 we sketch the framework of FOS and prove that it is a kind of sound and incomplete logic. In section 3 we treat the paradox SP in the framework of FOS and show how it is eliminated. In section 4 we cite the views of some experts in the fields of cognitive psychology and theory of vision on the question of plausibility of the idea of watching gaps. We also discuss how watching gaps explain horizon crossings. Finally in the Appendix we prove that FOS has the same truth tables with strong Kleene logic. 2 Fluxing Object Semantics (FOS) In contrast to the objects of mathematics which are abstract and timeless, physical objects are always time dependent and most often also agent dependent. So, whereas 17 has been and is going to be a prime number for ever and for any person who understands the definition of a prime, a man a can be nonbald at a time t for an agent i and bald at a time t^{\prime}>t for the same agent. Also a can be nonbald for an agent

Read the complete text