Autoparallels and the Inverse Problem of the Calculus of Variations
Lavinia Heisenberg · 2026
Read Autoparallels and the Inverse Problem of the Calculus of Variations by Lavinia Heisenberg (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11581.txt.
Introduction
Heisenberg proves that autoparallel curves for a broad class of affine connections can come from an action principle. The connections are torsion-free, yet they need not be metric-compatible. She builds the action functional in full and shows that standard variational steps yield the wanted equations. The route runs through the inverse problem of the calculus of variations and its Helmholtz conditions. The result gives particle motion in metric-affine geometries a firm variational base. It also supports the math behind the geodesic principle in relativistic gravity.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lavinia Heisenberg |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42997 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11581
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Autoparallels and the Inverse Problem of the Calculus of Variations Lavinia Heisenberg Abstract We prove that autoparallel curves associated with a torsion-free but not necessarily metric-compatible affine connection can be derived from an action principle. We explicitly construct the action functional and show by standard variational techniques that it produces the desired equations. Our analysis is based on systematically solving the inverse problem of the calculus of variation and the associated Helmholtz conditions. This demonstrates that the dynamics of autoparallels admit a consistent variational formulation even in the presence of non-metricity. Our results provide a variational framework for particle motion in metric-affine geometries and thereby contribute to the mathematical foundations of the geodesic principle in relativistic gravity. pacs 98.80.Cq I Introduction Einstein’s original formulation of General Relativity (GR) builds on the assumption of a torsion-free and metric-compatible affine structure. More general geometric frameworks, and with them a rich landscape of gravity theories, naturally arise once one allows the affine structure of spacetime to be independent of the metric Heisenberg 2019 ; Heisenberg 2024 . In a metric-affine geometry, spacetime is equipped with both a metric tensor and an affine connection, which need not be compatible. The failure of metric compatibility is measured by the non-metricity tensor, while the antisymmetric part of the connection defines the torsion. In particular, GR can be formulated equivalently in terms of curvature, torsion, or non-metricity, a correspondence often referred to as the geometric trinity of gravity Heisenberg 2019 ; Beltrán Jiménez et al. 2019 ; Heisenberg 2024 . The three theories making up the geometric trinity, namely GR, the teleparallel equivalent of GR (TEGR), and the symmetric teleparallel equivalent of GR (STEGR), are based on different geometric postulates, but their field equations possess the same solution space. This is the sense in which they are equivalent. However, conceptual differences persist and carry over into other theories of gravity based on metric-affine geometry. In particular, the motion of test particles may be affected by the particular type of geometry used to formulate a given theory of gravity. In GR, test particles are postulated to follow geodesics. Geometrically, these are curves which extremize the proper time functional and may be interpreted as locally shortest or extremal paths. Equivalently, they satisfy the condition that their tangent vectors are parallel transported with respect to the Levi-Civita connection. The coincidence of these two characterizations of geodesics—the variational and the affine—relies crucially on the metric compatibility and torsion-free nature of the Levi-Civita connection. In the presence of an independent affine connection, the description of free-fall motion becomes more subtle. Two a priori distinct notions of preferred curves arise. On the one hand, autoparallels are defined as curves whose tangent vectors are parallel transported with respect to the affine connection; they represent the straightest possible curves associated with the connection. On the other hand, geodesics are obtained as extremals of a point-particle action which only depends on the metric. While in (pseudo-) Riemannian geometry these two notions coincide, as mentioned above, in a generic metric-affine geometry they constitute two genuinely distinct concepts. This leads to an apparent ambiguity in the kinematics of freely falling particles. This ambiguity raises a fundamental question at the interface of geometry and variational principles: to what extent can autoparallel curves of a general affine connection be obtained as extrema of a variational principle? In this letter we address the slightly more restricted question of whether a reparametrization-invariant scalar worldline action exists, which only depends on the embedding of the particle worldline into spacetime and whose Euler-Lagrange equations reproduce the autoparallel equations of a torsion-free affine connection with arbitrary non-metricity. We provide a definitive answer in the affirmative to this question. To our knowledge, this is the first time an action functional generating autoparallels of a general torsion-free affine connection has been constructed. We achieve this by examining and solving the inverse problem of the calculus of variation. In particular, we show that, in the absence of torsion, the Helmholtz conditions can always be satisfied for a given metric and a given non-metricity tensor. We provide an explicit expression for the action functional and prove that it indeed reproduces the sought-after autoparallel equations by means of standard variational techniques. The letter is organized as follows. In Section II we review the necessary elements of metric-affine geometry to make the exposition self-contained. In Section III we formulate the inverse problem of the calculus of variation, adapted to our equations of interest—namely the autoparallel equation. We subsequently show how to solve the Helmholtz conditions, which culminates in a proof of existence of an action functional for the autoparallel equations in absence of torsion. We then explicitly state the action functional and prove that it produces the desired equations. We conclude with a summary and outlook in Section IV . II Geometric Preliminaries Tensor fields evaluated at different points of a manifold cannot be directly compared. The reason is that these fields are defined over different tangent spaces, which cannot be canonically identified with each other. However, these tangent spaces are isomorphic to each other, which allows us to introduce the concept of an affine connection \nabla and the related concept of parallel transport of tensor fields. With these concepts in hand, we can transport a given field from one point p of the manifold along a curve \gamma to a different point q in order to perform a comparison. In the case of a vector field, we can carry out this process such that the vector remains parallel to itself in an appropriate sense. Throughout this letter, \mathcal{M} is assumed to be a smooth, connected, n -dimensional manifold. The set of all smooth functions from \mathcal{M} to \mathbb{R} is denoted by \mathcal{F}(\mathcal{M}) , \mathfrak{X}(\mathcal{M}) is the set of all smooth vector fields on \mathcal{M} , and \Omega(\mathcal{M}) denotes the set of all smooth 1 -forms. We now introduce an affine connection. Definition II.1 (Affine connection) . An affine connection on \mathcal{M} is a map \nabla:\mathfrak{X}(\mathcal{M})\times\mathfrak{X}(\mathcal{M})\to\mathfrak{X}(\mathcal{M})\,\qquad(X,Y)\mapsto\nabla_{X}Y, which is \mathcal{F}(\mathcal{M}) -linear in the first argument, \mathbb{R} -linear in the second one, and it satisfies the Leibniz rule for the second argument. The definition of an affine connection is manifestly coordinate-independent. For practical purposes, it is often desirable to work in local coordinates. This is achieved point-wise by evaluating \nabla on the coordinate basis \{\partial_{a}\} of a given tangent space and defining the connection coefficients \Gamma^{a}{}_{bc} as \displaystyle\nabla_{\partial_{b}}\partial_{c}\eqqcolon\Gamma^{a}{}_{bc}\partial_{a}. (2.1) Notice that \nabla is not \mathcal{F}(\mathcal{M}) -bilinear and therefore not a tensor. Indeed, one can confirm by direct computation that \Gamma^{a}{}_{bc} does not transform in a tensorial way. Once a connection has been introduced, one can define the notion of parallel transport. Definition II.2 (Parallel transport) . Let \gamma:I\subset\mathbb{R}\to\mathcal{M} be a smooth curve. A vector field X\in\mathfrak{X}(\mathcal{M}) along \gamma is said to be parallel transported along \gamma if \nabla_{\dot{\gamma}}X=0, where \dot{\gamma} denotes the tangent vector field to \gamma . Parallel transport depends on both, the connection and the curve. In general, parallel transport between two points of \mathcal{M} is path dependent. Autoparallel curves on \mathcal{M} serve as counterparts to straight lines in flat space. Physically, one can interpret these curves as delineating the paths of particles which are uninfluenced by external forces. Mathematically, a