Atmospheric Escape Rates from Mars - If it Orbited an Old M-Dwarf Star Journal: ApJ

David A. Brain, Ofer Cohen, Thomas E. Cravens, Kevin France, Alex Glocer, Parker Hinton, Francois Leblanc, Yingjuan Ma, Akifumi Nakayama, Shotaro Sakai, Ryoya Sakata, Kanako Seki, Julián D. Alvarado-Gómez, Zachory Berta-Thompson, Eryn M. Cangi, Michael Chaffin, Jean-Yves Chaufray, Renata Frelikh, Yoshifumi Futaana, Katherine Garcia-Sage, Lukas Hanson, Mats Holmström, Bruce Jakosky, Riku Jarvinen, Ravi Kopparapu, Daniel R. Marsh, Aimee Merkel, Thomas Earle Moore, Yuta Notsu, Rachel A. Osten, William K. Peterson, Laura Peticolas, Robin Ramstad, Kevin B. Stevenson, Robert Strangeway, Wenyi Sun, Naoki Terada, Aline A. Vidotto · 2026

Read Atmospheric Escape Rates from Mars - If it Orbited an Old M-Dwarf Star Journal: ApJ by David A. Brain, Ofer Cohen, Thomas E. Cravens, Kevin France, Alex Glocer, Parker Hinton, Francois Leblanc, Yingjuan Ma, Akifumi Nakayama, Shotaro Sakai, Ryoya Sakata, Kanako Seki, Julián D. Alvarado-Gómez, Zachory Berta-Thompson, Eryn M. Cangi, Michael Chaffin, Jean-Yves Chaufray, Renata Frelikh, Yoshifumi Futaana, Katherine Garcia-Sage, Lukas Hanson, Mats Holmström, Bruce Jakosky, Riku Jarvinen, Ravi Kopparapu, Daniel R. Marsh, Aimee Merkel, Thomas Earle Moore, Yuta Notsu, Rachel A. Osten, William K. Peterson, Laura Peticolas, Robin Ramstad, Kevin B. Stevenson, Robert Strangeway, Wenyi Sun, Naoki Terada, Aline A. Vidotto (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11561.txt.

Introduction

Brain and co-authors ask how fast a Mars-like planet would lose its air around Barnard's star, an old M dwarf, at Mars-like flux. Escape runs through thermal, ion, and photochemical routes, plus sputtering. The team sets the planet at a distance with the same total stellar flux Mars gets today. Thermal escape dominates, at rates two to five orders of magnitude above present-day Mars. Such a planet, they conclude, would hold no real atmosphere past tens of millions of years.

Catalog record

CREATORDavid A. Brain, Ofer Cohen, Thomas E. Cravens, Kevin France, Alex Glocer, Parker Hinton, Francois Leblanc, Yingjuan Ma, Akifumi Nakayama, Shotaro Sakai, Ryoya Sakata, Kanako Seki, Julián D. Alvarado-Gómez, Zachory Berta-Thompson, Eryn M. Cangi, Michael Chaffin, Jean-Yves Chaufray, Renata Frelikh, Yoshifumi Futaana, Katherine Garcia-Sage, Lukas Hanson, Mats Holmström, Bruce Jakosky, Riku Jarvinen, Ravi Kopparapu, Daniel R. Marsh, Aimee Merkel, Thomas Earle Moore, Yuta Notsu, Rachel A. Osten, William K. Peterson, Laura Peticolas, Robin Ramstad, Kevin B. Stevenson, Robert Strangeway, Wenyi Sun, Naoki Terada, Aline A. Vidotto
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE64219
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11561

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Atmospheric Escape Rates from Mars - If it Orbited an Old M-Dwarf Star Journal: ApJ David A. Brain, Ofer Cohen, Thomas E. Cravens, Kevin France, Alex Glocer, Parker Hinton, Francois Leblanc, Yingjuan Ma, Akifumi Nakayama, Shotaro Sakai, Ryoya Sakata, Kanako Seki, Julián D. Alvarado-Gómez, Zachory Berta-Thompson, Eryn M. Cangi, Michael Chaffin, Jean-Yves Chaufray, Renata Frelikh, Yoshifumi Futaana, Katherine Garcia-Sage, Lukas Hanson, Mats Holmström, Bruce Jakosky, Riku Jarvinen, Ravi Kopparapu, Daniel R. Marsh, Aimee Merkel, Thomas Earle Moore, Yuta Notsu, Rachel A. Osten, William K. Peterson, Laura Peticolas, Robin Ramstad, Kevin B. Stevenson, Robert Strangeway, Wenyi Sun, Naoki Terada, Aline A. Vidotto Abstract Atmospheric escape is an important process that influences the evolution of planetary atmospheres. A variety of physical mechanisms can contribute to escape from an atmosphere, including thermal escape, ion escape, photochemical escape, and sputtering. Here we estimate escape rates via each of these processes for a hypothetical Mars-like exoplanet orbiting Barnard’s star (an old, inactive M dwarf star). We place the planet at an orbital distance that receives the same total stellar flux as it does in our solar system. We use the measured stellar extreme ultraviolet (EUV) spectrum and assumptions on the star’s magnetic field to determine both the high-energy radiation and the stellar wind environment around the planet. This information is used to model the response of the planet’s thermosphere, exosphere and magnetosphere using a variety of models that have been validated against solar system observations. We find overall escape rates that are dominated by thermal processes and elevated by 2-5 orders of magnitude relative to present-day Mars, suggesting that a Mars-like planet orbiting Barnard’s star would not retain a significant atmosphere for more than 10’s of millions of years. Recently reported planets around Barnard’s star should also not have retained significant atmospheres. By extension, Mars-like planets orbiting any M dwarf near the ’Habitable Zone’ should not retain atmospheres for extended periods of time. I Introduction As planetary atmospheres form and evolve, their mass at any given moment is determined by the time history of the source and loss processes that have acted on them. An important (and permanent) loss process is atmospheric escape to space. Atmospheric escape has been measured or indirectly inferred from a large number of solar system objects ( 4 ; 117 ; 12 ; 9 ; 47 ; 40 ) . Atmospheric isotope signatures further suggest that loss processes have played an important role in the evolution of solar system atmospheres ( 90 ; 19 ; 55 ) . Observations from the Mars Atmosphere and Volatile EvolutioN (MAVEN) mission indicate that Mars has lost at least half a bar of atmosphere over its history ( 53 ) . Atmospheric escape is known to be an active process at exoplanets, with multiple observations of strong escape from gas giant planets ( 125 ; 65 ; 62 ; 29 ; 107 , e.g.) . Sustained atmospheric escape is inferred to be the main reason for the ‘radius gap’, or deficit of observed exoplanets orbiting close to their star with sizes between Super-Earth and Sub-Neptune ( 88 ; 37 ) . There are now multiple observations of rocky exoplanets lacking a substantial atmosphere ( 60 ; 16 , e.g.) , implying that escape has removed their atmospheres. The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has enabled high spectral resolution transit spectroscopy of rocky exoplanets, with further evidence for rocky planets lacking significant atmospheres ( 43 ; 127 , e.g.) . The JWST-HST (Hubble Space Telescope) Rocky Worlds Director’s Discretionary Time (DDT) program is dedicated to a search for atmospheres on rocky exoplanets ( 95 ) . Understanding of atmospheric escape can be used to interpret these observations, and place them in context with each other and with solar system planets. They can also be used to test the proposed ‘cosmic shoreline’ framework for evaluating whether a given planet will retain an atmosphere ( 131 ) . The term ‘atmospheric escape’ refers to a suite of processes, rather than a single mechanism that removes particles from a planet’s atmosphere. Different investigators identify different numbers of escape processes, though this is an issue mostly of classification. There is general agreement on the physics that governs escape ( 51 ; 10 ; 44 , e.g.) . Here we identify five main processes, following 10 : thermal Jeans escape, hydrodynamic escape, ion escape, photochemical escape, and sputtering. Thermal and hydrodynamic escape both result from the thermal distribution of particle energies in a planet’s upper atmosphere. Some fraction of this distribution can exceed the escape energy from the planet, resulting in escape. If a significant fraction of the distribution exceeds the escape energy then the resulting escape can be characterized as a fluid outflow, and is referred to as hydrodynamic escape. Ion, photochemical, and sputtering escape are all non-thermal processes. In these cases some external energy (electric fields, exothermic reactions, and particle collisions, respectively) is required to accelerate particles away from the atmosphere. Charge exchange (between stellar wind protons and exospheric neutrals) is sometimes considered as a separate process; in this work it is included as a chemical pathway that leads to ion escape. Different escape processes are effective at removing different atmospheric species, and the importance of individual processes can change as a planet and its host star change with time. Many previous studies of atmospheric escape from exoplanets have included hydrodynamic escape as the dominant relevant escape process. Hydrodynamic escape is easiest to initiate for low-mass species such as hydrogen or helium, and previous studies have considered hydrodynamic escape from giant planets ( 89 ; 48 , see a reviews in) and from rocky planets with their primordial H/He atmospheres ( 68 ; 52 , e.g.) . Energy-limited hydrodynamic escape fluxes are straightforward to evaluate using known parameters of the planet (mass, radius, incident stellar flux at EUV/X-ray wavelengths), though they include efficiency parameters that are difficult to constrain ( 30 , e.g.) . Other exoplanet studies have considered the influence of non-thermal processes from exoplanets. These include estimates of photochemical escape ( 49 ; 67 ) and of ion escape ( 38 ; 1 ; 20 ; 24 ; 22 ; 21 ; 23 ; 28 , e.g.) . Comparatively few studies have considered the net atmospheric escape from exoplanets via multiple escape processes, despite the likelihood that multiple escape processes operate on many exoplanets, as they do on the planets in our solar system. Examples include 34 and 5 . To our knowledge, no studies have considered all five escape processes from an exoplanet. Here we present a comprehensive modeling case study of a Mars-like exoplanet orbiting an M dwarf star. We choose a Mars-like planet because four of the five escape processes operate on Mars today (all but hydrodynamic escape) and because observations of atmospheric escape are currently more complete at Mars than they are at Venus or Earth ( 53 ) . We place Mars in its present state around an M dwarf star because M dwarfs make up \sim 75% of the stars in the Galaxy and because rocky exoplanet planet characterization is only possible around M dwarfs using current facilities (i.e., JWST). M dwarf stars are known to remain particularly magnetically active

Read the complete text