When are Two Subgroups Independent?

Alexa Gopaulsingh · 2026

Read When are Two Subgroups Independent? by Alexa Gopaulsingh (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11309.txt.

Introduction

Alexa Gopaulsingh takes up a question posed by Rosenmann and Ventura: what should independence of two subgroups mean for general groups? Her answer is category-theoretic in flavor. Subgroups are independent when any pair of endomorphisms, one on each subgroup, extends jointly to an endomorphism of the group they generate. She shows almost-disjointness is not enough to force it. She gives necessary and sufficient conditions. She offers a heuristic that settles many cases, while the full answer stays open.

Catalog record

CREATORAlexa Gopaulsingh
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48240
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11309

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

When are Two Subgroups Independent? Alexa Gopaulsingh Abstract Abstract In [ 6 ] , Rosenmann and Ventura asked "What is the right definition of dependence of subgroups for general groups?". Here we aim to answer this question and generalise the notion first used by Rosemann in [ 5 ] . We consider a definition of subgroup independence which is a special case of the category-theoretic one introduced in [ 1 ] . It is that: Two subgroups of a group are independent if and only if any two endomorphisms, one acting on each subgroup, can be extended to an endomorphism of the group generated by these subgroups. This definition helps to illuminate that the usual condition of almost disjointness of subgroups (two subgroups A and B are almost disjoint if and only if A\cap B=\{e\} , where e is the identity element) is not enough to force independence and here we find necessary and (different) sufficient conditions for subgroup independence. The aim of this note is to introduce this general notion of subgroup independence to the group theory community and to pose the open question of its characterisation. We present the partial results known up to this point. Moreover, we use the progress made so far to give a heuristic algorithm that decides subgroup independence for many cases. AMS Subject Classification: 20-02, 20A10, 20J15 Keywords: Subgroup Independence \cdot Subalgebra Independence \cdot Categorical Independence 1 Introduction Independence notions have long been of interest in many fields. For example, they are important in physics in quantum field theory, see [ 7 ] . Here, many unequal notions of independence were introduced. For a review and comparison of these, see [ 8 ] . In [ 6 ] , Rosenmann and Ventura asked for a definition of independence which generalises the notion first used by Rosemann in [ 5 ] for free groups. In Section 3.2, we mention how the introduced definition extends that one. In [ 1 ] , a general approach and a category-theoretic definition of subalgebra independence of structures was introduced. It generalises and continues work done in [ 4 ] and [ 2 ] to give a categorical definition of independence as subobject morphism coexistence. For the category of Groups, this essentially reduces to: Two subgroups A and B of a group, are independent if and only if any endomorphisms, \alpha on A and \beta on B , can be extended to an endomorphism of the minimal group generated by A and B (their join). This extension, if it exists must be unique, see [ 1 ] . Here, it uses the fact that in the categories of Sets, Boolean Algebras, Vector Spaces and Abelian Groups, the co-product of two algebras in these categories are the join of these algebras. This results in the independence definitions evaluating to the expected notions in these categories: For the category of Sets, subset independence is disjointness; for Vector Spaces, subspace independence is linear independence; for Boolean Algebras, subalgebra independence is logical independence and for the category of Abelian groups, subgroup independence is almost disjointness. However, surprisingly, for the category of Groups the situation was found to be mysterious and not equivalent to the usual requirement of almost disjoint subgroups. In this category, the internal co-product of two subgroups is not necessarily isomorphic to their join. We found that it is possible for a pair of subgroups to satisfy the usual requirement of almost disjointness and yet still their endomorphisms affect each other. That is, there exists endomorphisms of almost disjoint subgroups of a group which do not have an extension in their join, see Example 2.1 . This category-theoretic definition helped to shed light on this situation and we see that we have to be more careful and require more than simply almost disjointness to determine if the endomorphisms of two subgroups influence each other. Informally, we found that part of the reason for this is that even if two subgroups A and B are such that A\cap B=\{e\} (i.e they are almost disjoint), it still may be that case that A contains a non-trivial conjugate of an element B (or a product of B ’s conjugates). Homomorphism mappings on elements restrict what their conjugates can be mapped to and hence A can still affect B in this way. This prompts us to define a notion of subgroup separateness which states that not only is A almost disjoint from B but it must be almost disjoint from the minimal normal group containing B in their join. We found that requiring both A to be separate from B and for B to be separate from A , is indeed necessary for subgroup independence. However, we will show that even this is not sufficient. Additionally, we will see that if we were to take a stronger version of this separateness for A and B which states that their minimal normal subgroups in their join must be almost disjoint, then this is too strong to characterise subgroup independence. Though we have gotten closer, the exact sweet spot of this conjugate influence is yet to be found and we motivate it as an interesting open problem. Moreover, this article contains the progress so far, for determining when two subgroups are independent. The necessary and (separately) sufficient conditions in the following sections can help us to decide independence or dependence of subgroups for many cases. We have used these results to condense a heuristic algorithm given in Section 5 which can be useful to scientists or anyone who may need to detect subgroup dependence. 2 Subgroup Independence We start by giving the notations and conventions used in this article and we also introduce the subgroup separateness and subgroup independence definitions which we investigate. 2.1 Definitions and Notation – Let A be a subset of a group G . Then, we denote the subgroup generated by A as \langle A\rangle . – Let A be a group. We will denote the identity of it by e . – X\cdot Y=\{x*y\ |x\in X\text{and}\ y\in Y\} for sets X and Y of a group (G,*) . – The order of an element g in a group G , will be denoted by |g| . – Let a group G be isomorphic to a group H . Then, we write G\cong H . – Two subgroups, A and B are said to be almost disjoint iff A\cap B=\{e\} . – Let A and B be subgroups of a group. Then, the group generated by their union, \langle A\cup B\rangle , is called the join of A and B . –Let A be a subgroup of a group G . We define Conj(A)_{G} to be the set of conjugates of A in G . – Let A be a group. Let \langle Conj(A)_{G}\rangle be the minimal normal subgroup containing A in G . – In the following, we will always assume that A and B are subgroups of a common group and so it makes sense to consider their join. Also, as we will always be considering the Conj(A)_{\langle A\cup B\rangle} , we will simply write Conj(A) . – Let (A,B) be a pair of groups. The endomorphisms \alpha and \beta of

Read the complete text