Minimizers that are not impulsive minimizers and higher order abnormality

Monica Motta, Michele Palladino, Franco Rampazzo · 2026

Read Minimizers that are not impulsive minimizers and higher order abnormality by Monica Motta, Michele Palladino, Franco Rampazzo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11302.txt.

Introduction

Monica Motta, Michele Palladino, and Franco Rampazzo tackle a mismatch between two routes to necessary conditions in optimal control problems with a target. Set separation and penalization give non-equivalent results. The clash traces to notions of tangency at the target. They show the Clarke tangent cone serves as a quasi differential quotient approximating cone under local invariance or prox-regularity. For impulsive control, the result links infimum gaps for minimizers to higher abnormality. That abnormality sits in a maximum principle built on Lie brackets.

Catalog record

CREATORMonica Motta, Michele Palladino, Franco Rampazzo
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77581
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11302

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Minimizers that are not impulsive minimizers and higher order abnormality Thanks: Submitted to the editors DATE. Monica Motta, Michele Palladino, Franco Rampazzo Abstract This paper addresses two related problems in optimal control. The first investigation consists of compatibility issues between two classical approaches to deriving necessary conditions for optimal control problems with a final target: the set-separation approach and penalization techniques. These methods generally lead to non-equivalent conditions, mainly due to their reliance on different notions of tangency at the target. We address this issue by considering Quasi Differential Quotient (QDQ) approximating cones (which are fit for the set-separation approach ) and identifying conditions under which the Clarke tangent cone (which is a typical tool within penalization techniques) is also a QDQ approximating cone. In particular, we show that this property holds under suitable local invariance assumptions or when the target coincides locally with an r r -prox regular set . In the second part of the paper we apply this compatibility result to the study of infimum-gap phenomena in optimal control problems with unbounded controls and impulsive extensions. In particular, we establish a connection between the occurrence of infimum gaps for strict-sense minimizers and abnormality in a higher-order Maximum Principle involving Lie brackets. While the abnormality–gap correspondence beyond first-order conditions has been already established for extended-sense –i.e. impulsive– minimizers, a topological argument involving the former and the utilization of the above compatibility issues allow us to extend this correspondence to strict-sense minimizers. keywords Optimal control, Infimum gap, Impulsive control, Higher-order conditions † † runningheads: Strict minimizers and higher-order abnormality / M. Motta and M. Palladino and F. Rampazzo AMS 49K15, 49N25, 93C10 1 Introduction Non-equivalent approaches to deriving necessary conditions for a continuous-time optimal control problem with a closed final target \mathcal{S} can be found in the literature. In particular, two methods have been developed: on the one hand, the so-called set-separation approach (see, e.g. [ 33 ] - [ 36 ] , [ 38 , 39 ] ); on the other hand, a penalization technique, rooted in Ekeland’s variational principle (see, e.g. [ 37 ] , [ 10 ] ). It is well known that these approaches may yield non-equivalent necessary conditions, mainly because they rely on different notions of tangency at points of the target (see [ 7 ] ). However, under suitable compatibility assumptions, nothing precludes studying some issues connected with important properties of necessary conditions using both approaches. This idea motivates the first part of the present paper. In the second part, we apply this compatibility framework to investigate an infimum-gap problem. The main obstacle to combining the set-separation approach with the penalization technique lies in the fact that, in general, a tangent cone – e.g. the Clarke tangent cone– to a point \bar{x} of the final target \mathcal{S} is not what is called, in the set-separation approach, an approximating cone . In this work we adopt the notion of a QDQ approximating cone , which encompasses several types of approximating cones appearing in the literature. We address this theoretical question in the next subsection, while in the subsequent subsection we will discuss an application to a concrete problem, related to the infimum-gap question. 1.1 A theoretical issue We first introduce the notion of an approximating cone. We use the acronym QDQ to mean Quasi Differential Quotient . We refer to Section 3 for the definition of QDQ, a notion of a generalized differential (which in our application will be an element of Lin(\mathbb{R}^{N},\mathbb{R}^{n}) , however, in general it can be a subset of such linear maps) introduced in [ 28 ] . It coincides with a sort of regular instance of Sussmann’s Approximate Generalized Differential Quotient. A QDQ approximating cone {\mathcal{K}} to a set \mathcal{S}\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{n} at a point \bar{x}\in\mathcal{S} is the image {\mathcal{K}}=L\cdot\Gamma , where \Gamma is a cone (of dimension N\leq n ) and L\in Lin(\mathbb{R}^{N},\mathbb{R}^{n}) is a QDQ of a map from a subset of \mathbb{R}^{N} into \mathcal{S} . We will also make use of the well-known Clarke tangent cone . We recall (see Section 2.3 ) that the Clarke tangent cone to \mathcal{S} at \bar{x} , here denoted by T^{C}_{\mathcal{S}}(\bar{x}) , can be defined as follows: \displaystyle T_{\mathcal{S}}^{C}(\bar{x}):=\left\{v\in\mathbb{R}^{n}:\ \ \underset{t\downarrow 0,\,x\to\bar{x}}{\limsup}\,\frac{{d_{\mathcal{S}}(x+tv)-d_{\mathcal{S}}(x)}}{t}\right\} (where, for any z\in\mathbb{R}^{n} and any {\mathcal{A}}\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{n} , d_{\mathcal{A}}(z) denotes the distance of the point z from the subset {\mathcal{A}} , that is, d_{\mathcal{A}}(z)=\inf\{|z-x|:\ x\in\mathcal{A}\} ). The afore-mentioned compatibility issue can be expressed as follows: Q1. Under which assumptions on \mathcal{S} does the Clarke tangent cone T_{\mathcal{S}}^{C}(\bar{x}) also constitute a QDQ approximating cone to \mathcal{S} at \bar{x} ? To give an answer to question Q1 , we need the following notion of r -prox regular set (see Section 2.4 ), a notion that generalizes both the concepts of convex set and of C^{2} set. Roughly speaking, for r>0 , a subset \mathcal{A}\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{n} is a r -prox regular set (also called a set with positive reach ) if for every y\in\mathbb{R}^{n}\backslash\mathcal{A} such that d_{\mathcal{A}}(y)\leq r there exists a unique projection of y onto the boundary of \mathcal{A} (denoted by \partial\mathcal{A} ). Our answer to Q1 is the following (see Theorem 3.1 ): Result 1. If there exists a real number \delta>0 such that either (i) (\bar{x}+T^{C}_{\mathcal{S}}(\bar{x}))\cap B_{\delta}(\bar{x})\subseteq\mathcal{S} , or (ii) \mathcal{S}\cap B_{\delta}(\bar{x}) coincides with the restriction to B_{\delta}(\bar{x}) of a r -prox regular set for some r>0 , then the Clarke tangent cone T^{C}_{\mathcal{S}}(\bar{x}) to \mathcal{S} at \bar{x} is a QDQ approximating cone to \mathcal{S} at \bar{x} . As a general consequence, it follows that, under hypothesis (i) or (ii) in Result 1 , any statement about necessary conditions expressed in terms of QDQ approximating cones to a target set \mathcal{S} (within the set-separation approach) implies analogous necessary conditions in which the so-called transversality condition is formulated in terms of the Clarke normal cone. As we shall see in the application to the infimum-gap phenomenon (see the next subsection), this is particularly helpful when one is dealing with higher-order necessary conditions (involving Lie brackets of the dynamical vector fields). 1.2 An application to the question of infimum gaps When the infimum of an optimal control problem is not attained, a standard strategy consists of extending the domain of optimization to its closure with respect to an appropriate topology. Classical examples include relaxation (by convexification or extension to probability measures) or impulsive extension of non-coercive problems with unbounded controls. Clearly, an important prerequisite of such extensions is that no infimum gaps occur, which means that the infima of the original and extended problems coincide. Furthermore, one should be able to construct near-optimal processes for the original problem from a minimizer of the extended one. Therefore, identifying sufficient conditions that exclude an infimum gap is crucial both for the theoretical foundation and for the numerical implementation of optimal control methods. Let us briefly explain how the goal of avoiding infimum gaps is connected with the theoretical issue described in the previous subsection. Since the early contributions of Warga [ 38 ] – [ 41 ] , it has been known that, in relaxed problems that exhibit an infimum gap, the extended minimizer satisfies necessary conditions in the form of an abnormal Maximum Principle: this means that the multiplier connected with the cost is

Read the complete text