Gravitational Anomaly Measurement in Wide Binaries is Sensitive to Orbital Modeling
Serat M. Saad, Yuan-Sen Ting · 2026
Read Gravitational Anomaly Measurement in Wide Binaries is Sensitive to Orbital Modeling by Serat M. Saad, Yuan-Sen Ting (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-11015.txt.
Introduction
Serat Saad and Yuan-Sen Ting reanalyze the wide-binary dataset behind a recent claim of anomalous gravity at low accelerations. The claimed boost was said to match modified Newtonian dynamics. Their hierarchical Bayesian model fits three-dimensional orbital elements for all systems at once. It infers a single global gravity factor, which lands on the Newtonian value. A test mimicking the original approach, using a geometric de-projection instead, reproduces the anomalous value. This pinpoints the modeling choice as the source of the discrepancy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Serat M. Saad, Yuan-Sen Ting |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33327 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11015
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gravitational Anomaly Measurement in Wide Binaries is Sensitive to Orbital Modeling Serat M. Saad, Yuan-Sen Ting Abstract Recent work by 6 reported a gravitational anomaly in 36 wide-binary pairs, finding a gravity boost factor of γ ≡ G eff / G N ≈ 1.60 − 0.14 + 0.17 \gamma\equiv G_{\rm eff}/G_{\rm N}\approx 1.60_{-0.14}^{+0.17} at low accelerations, consistent with predictions from Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND). We reanalyze the same dataset using a hierarchical Bayesian model that infers a global γ \gamma across all systems while fitting three-dimensional orbital elements. Our model yields γ = 1.12 − 0.22 + 0.27 \gamma=1.12^{+0.27}_{-0.22} , consistent with Newtonian gravity ( γ = 1 \gamma=1 ) at the ∼ 0.4 σ \sim 0.4\sigma level. To identify the source of the discrepancy, we perform a test using an approach similar to 6 , replacing the semi-major axis with a geometric de-projection of the observed projected separation. This test yields γ = 1.56 − 0.18 + 0.21 \gamma=1.56^{+0.21}_{-0.18} , closely matching the result of 6 . This suggests that the inferred value of γ \gamma is sensitive to how the three-dimensional orbital separation is modeled, and including an independent semi-major axis parameter can account for velocity excesses that would otherwise be attributed to non-Newtonian gravity. I Introduction Testing gravity in the low-acceleration regime is an ongoing challenge in astrophysics. On galactic scales, the observational predictions deviate from Newtonian predictions based on visible matter alone ( 36 ; 26 ; 32 ) . The standard \Lambda CDM cosmological model accounts for these deviations by invoking cold dark matter (CDM) ( 33 ; 12 ) . The \Lambda CDM model has been successful at explaining large-scale structure and the cosmic microwave background ( 24 ; 25 ) . An alternative approach, Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND), was proposed by Mordehai Milgrom in 1983 ( 22 ) . MOND suggests that gravity is modified below an acceleration scale a_{0}\approx 1.2\times 10^{-10}~\rm{m\,s^{-2}} ( 22 ) . MOND has been successful in reproducing galaxy rotation curves and scaling relations ( 31 ; 13 ; 21 ; 19 ) , but faces challenges on cluster and cosmological scales ( 30 ; 2 ) . Distinguishing between these two frameworks requires tests in environments where their predictions differ and the systematic uncertainties can be controlled. Wide-binary stars, separated by thousands of AU, provide one such environment where gravity can be tested. At these separations, the internal gravitational acceleration of the binary can be compared to the MOND acceleration scale a_{0} . MOND framework therefore predicts deviation from Newtonian gravity in these systems. Testing MOND with wide binaries requires careful consideration of several theoretical ingredients. In MOND, the transition from Newtonian to modified gravity is governed by an interpolating function \mu(x) where x=a/a_{0} , with \mu\to 1 for x\gg 1 (Newtonian regime) and \mu\to x for x\ll 1 (deep-MOND regime). The exact form of \mu is not uniquely specified by the theory, and different choices lead to different predicted gravity enhancements at intermediate accelerations ( 13 ) . Furthermore, wide binaries in the solar neighborhood are subject to the external field effect (EFE): the external gravitational acceleration from the Galaxy, a_{\rm ext}\approx 1.8\times 10^{-10}~\rm{m\,s^{-2}} at the solar position, is comparable to a_{0} and much larger than the internal acceleration of the binary. In MOND, the EFE can suppress the internal anomaly, so the predicted gravity boost depends on a_{\rm ext}/a_{0} as well as on the interpolating function and the specific MOND formulation ( 5 ; 7 ) . However, the gravity boost factor \gamma\equiv G_{\rm eff}/G_{\rm N} , defined as the ratio of the effective gravitational constant to the Newtonian value, can be measured independently of these theoretical choices. The inference of \gamma is a kinematic measurement that assumes only Keplerian orbits; it does not assume any particular value of a_{0} , any specific interpolating function, or any MOND framework. Previous wide-binary studies using Gaia data have taken this approach, reporting \gamma=1.43\pm 0.06 ( 8 ) , \gamma=1.49\pm 0.2 ( 9 ) , \gamma=1.5\pm 0.2 ( 14 ) , and most recently \gamma=1.6\pm 0.2 ( 6 ) , which can be compared to AQUAL predictions of \gamma\approx 1.4 for wide binaries in the EFE-dominated regime of the solar neighborhood ( 5 ; 7 ) . In contrast, 4 reported preference for Newtonian gravity ( \gamma=1 ). The conflicting conclusions highlight that the result may be sensitive to the statistical methodology or the data used for the analysis. Recent work has introduced high-precision radial velocities (RVs) to enable three-dimensional analysis of wide-binary orbits. 28 obtained RVs for 32 wide binaries and found results broadly consistent with Newtonian gravity. 11 reanalyzed the same sample and reported a tentative gravitational anomaly of \gamma\equiv G_{\rm eff}/G_{\rm N}\approx 1.60_{-0.14}^{+0.17} for systems with low internal accelerations. Most recently, 6 assembled a sample of 36 wide binaries with high-precision 3D velocities and reported \gamma\approx 1.6\pm 0.2 , claiming a >3\sigma detection of deviation from Newtonian gravity. The methodology used by 6 and 11 consists of two steps: first, for each binary system, a Bayesian inference is performed to derive a posterior distribution of \Gamma , where \Gamma=\log_{10}\sqrt{\gamma} along with nuisance orbital parameters; second, the per-system posteriors are statistically consolidated to derive a combined \Gamma . While this approach has merit, aspects of the model formulation, particularly the treatment of projected separation and the absence of an independent semi-major axis parameter, may influence the inferred \gamma . In our previous work ( 20 , hereafter 20 ) , we developed a hierarchical Bayesian framework for testing MOND with wide-binary kinematics and applied that to the wide binaries from the C3PO survey ( 35 ) . That model fit three-dimensional orbital elements for all systems while inferring a global MOND acceleration scale a_{0} . The framework included the MOND interpolating function and an analytic treatment of the EFE, and tested two interpolating functions ( b=1 and b=2 ). The C3PO systems were found to reside in the MOND transition regime, and the analysis yielded tension with the canonical a_{0} value at \sim 3\sigma ( b=1 ) and \sim 2\sigma ( b=2 ). Although, because the C3PO test was performed in the transition regime, the results were sensitive to the choice of interpolating function and the EFE treatment. In this paper, we adapt the framework of 20 to infer the gravity boost factor \gamma for 36 wide binaries from 6 . In Section II , we describe the dataset from 6 . In Section III , we present our hierarchical Bayesian model. In Section IV , we report the results of our two model variants, discuss the interpretation of these results, and place our findings in the context of previous wide-binary gravity tests. II Data We use the sample of 36 wide-binary systems assembled by 6 . This sample was constructed through selection criteria designed to identify gravitationally bound pairs with 3D kinematics: multi-epoch RV verification, speckle interferometry to exclude unresolved tertiary companions, Hipparcos- Gaia proper motion consistency checks, and Gaia RUWE <1.4 . The RVs come from multiple instruments: the Las Cumbres Observatory (LCO) Network of Robotic Echelle Spectrographs (NRES), the Gemini-North MAROON-X spectrograph (MAROON-X), the High Accuracy Radial velocity Planet Searcher (HARPS) spectrograph on