Island Sliding Barriers: A first-principles metric for determining remote epitaxy viability
Quinn T. Campbell, Manny Xavier de Jesus Lopez, Anthony Rice, Timothy J. Ruggles, Taisuke Ohta, Caitlin McCowan, Sadhvikas Addamane, Scott W. Schmucker, Justine Koepke · 2026
Read Island Sliding Barriers: A first-principles metric for determining remote epitaxy viability by Quinn T. Campbell, Manny Xavier de Jesus Lopez, Anthony Rice, Timothy J. Ruggles, Taisuke Ohta, Caitlin McCowan, Sadhvikas Addamane, Scott W. Schmucker, Justine Koepke (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-10968.txt.
Introduction
Quinn Campbell and coauthors search for a reliable first-principles test. The test asks which substrate-film pairs suit remote epitaxy. In this method, films grow over an inserted two-dimensional layer. The mechanism behind the technique is still unsettled. Older metrics such as electrostatic potential fail to explain which pairs work. The sliding barrier of islands on the surface proves the most rigorous criterion. It is computed with atoms free to relax. It points to island migration kinetics as the heart of the effect.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Quinn T. Campbell, Manny Xavier de Jesus Lopez, Anthony Rice, Timothy J. Ruggles, Taisuke Ohta, Caitlin McCowan, Sadhvikas Addamane, Scott W. Schmucker, Justine Koepke |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35841 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.10968
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Island Sliding Barriers: A first-principles metric for determining remote epitaxy viability Quinn T. Campbell, Manny Xavier de Jesus Lopez, Anthony Rice, Timothy J. Ruggles, Taisuke Ohta, Caitlin McCowan, Sadhvikas Addamane, Scott W. Schmucker, Justine Koepke Abstract Remote epitaxy, where a 2D van der Waals material (usually graphene) is inserted on top of the substrate before film epitaxy, has emerged as a promising path for growing electronics with lower defect rates and less stringent lattice matching requirements. The exact mechanism behind remote epitaxy has not been definitively shown, however, and it is not obvious when examining a new substrate-film pair whether they would be compatible with the remote epitaxy process. In this paper, we use first principles calculations to test several different mechanisms for determining whether a given substrate-film pair will successfully be grown with remote epitaxy. We find that previously calculated metrics such as electrostatic potential do not hold sufficient explanatory power. We find that the sliding barrier of small islands on the surface when the atomic positions are allowed to optimize provides the most rigorous criteria for whether a given substrate-film pair is remote epitaxy active. This indicates that remote epitaxy is likely a phenomenon related to the kinetics and ease of island migration on the graphene surface. † † affiliation: Center for Computing Research, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM, USA † † email: [email protected] † † affiliation: Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM, USA 1 Introduction Why does remote epitaxy work? This has been the key question ever since the process was introduced by Kim et al. 15 . In remote epitaxy, a 2D van der Waals layer of material (usually graphene) is placed over the substrate and then a growth process is initiated similar to traditional epitaxy. Remote Epitaxy (RE) has been shown to have numerous potential advantages over both traditional epitaxy and van-der-Waals epitaxy. The interaction of the graphene with the underlying substrate can lead to less stringent lattice matching requirements. Furthermore, the epilayer has typically been shown to be single domain, with reduced misfit dislocations and other defects, and with the ability to be rapidly released and transferred 3 ; 13 . This combination of traits opens up exciting semiconductor growth possibilities and could be crucial for the development of next generation opto- and power electronics 12 ; 21 . While RE provides new semiconductor growth opportunities, the exact physical/chemical mechanism that enables RE remains under debate. The dominant explanation put forward so far by Kong et al. 16 is that the polarity of the substrate dominates whether it will be active for RE. Under this theory, substrates with stronger polarity, such as GaN or LiF will be able to transmit their underlying lattice through more layers of graphene. This hypothesis is backed up by examining both the electrostatic potential from Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations and Electron Back Scattering diffraction (EBSD) characterization of grown homo-epitaxial layers, finding single domain growth extends across more graphene layers for more polar materials. While this proposed chemical mechanism is tantalizing, it is not fully explanatory. Does polarity apply in cases where the substrate and film differ? If so, how exactly would the interaction be moderated between two materials with different levels of polarity? Furthermore, this theory assumes a perfect graphene layer is formed which does not affect the underlying substrate and is essentially transparent to the underlying substrate’s bonding patterns. Recent work has begun to question a number of key aspects around how perfect and transparent the graphene on top of the substrate actually is. A recent analytical model showed that even one layer of graphene (treated as homogenous electron gas with the carrier density of graphene) would lead to multiple orders of magnitude weakening of the underlying bonding potential 11 . Under the same model, the dominant factor influencing how much of the remote epitaxy potential goes through is not the polarity of the substrate, but how extended its bonding orbitals are. Furthermore, what if the graphene undergoes a reconstruction with the underlying substrate? 17 Presumably the graphene can no longer be considered to not be interacting with the substrate and its bonding with the film. And finally there remains the ever-present possibility that the graphene layers have significant pinholes, which would lead to direct epitaxy in significant regions of the graphene and account for much of the observed RE characteristics even if these pinholes are atomic in size 4 . Figure 1: A schematic of a typical remote epitaxial (RE) scheme, where a substrate is covered by a 2D van der Waals (vDW) layer, which is then used to grow high quality, single crystal films that would not previously be available for the substrate. We then present a schematic of which systems have been found to be viable with RE, with green boxes representing that experimental evidence has been shown with single crystalline layers from these setups, red indicating that only multicrystalline, vDW like layers have been grown, and yellow indicating that the evidence is ambiguous. The data for GaAs/graphene/GaAs comes from Ref. 15 , Ge/graphene/GaAs and GaAs/graphene/Ge from Ref. 3 , GaN/graphene/SiC from Ref. 9 ; 23 ; 3 , and GaN/graphene/GaN from Ref. 16 . Fundamentally, it still remains unclear for a novel pair of substrate and film if these materials would be compatible with a RE growth process, and, if so, how many of layers of graphene would the process work with. In Fig. 1 we schematically show a set of substrate and film pairings that have been reported in the literature to be active as well as inactive for RE as well as how many layers of graphene this is true for. Even substrates that have shown RE can interact poorly with different films as demonstrated by GaAs on GaAs succeeding, while Ge on GaAs does not. While there has been significant discussion on complicating factors in the experimental preparation of these results (density of pinholes often being a key unknown), for the purposes of this paper, we will accept the experimental results as providing a ground truth for the viability of RE in different systems. To advance next generation electronic materials growth, the field needs an (ideally first-principles) metric which could reliably predict whether a given substrate and film pairing will work with RE and with how many graphene layers. In this manuscript, we use first-principles calculations of a variety of different substrate/film combinations to determine a metric for predicting to RE. We examine previous metrics and mechanisms such as charge density extension and electrostatic potential decay, finding them insufficient to explain experimental results. We also examine the properties of individual atoms above the substrate graphene, finding them insufficient to explain RE. Finally, we determine the sliding barrier of film islands on the graphene/substrate surface as the most reliable indicator of RE viability. These results imply that the RE growth process is dominated by kinetics and future work should focus on developing more detailed understandings of the initial island growth and agglomeration. 2 Methodology For each system of interest, we created slab models where the bottom layers of the substrate were terminated with a passivating hydrogen atom, and the top of the substrate was exposed to graphene layers and then film atoms