AI-Generated Rubric Interfaces: K–12 Teachers’ Perceptions and Practices
Bahare Riahi, Sayali Patukale, Joy Niranjan, Yogya Koneru, Tiffany Barnes, Veronica Cateté · 2026
Read AI-Generated Rubric Interfaces: K–12 Teachers’ Perceptions and Practices by Bahare Riahi, Sayali Patukale, Joy Niranjan, Yogya Koneru, Tiffany Barnes, Veronica Cateté (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-10773.txt.
Introduction
Bahare Riahi and co-authors study K-12 teachers' views of AI-generated rubric tools, in a summer workshop with twenty-five teachers. Teachers rarely build rubrics from scratch, since the work is slow and level distinctions are hard to phrase. After hands-on use of MagicSchool.ai and a chatbot, they called the AI rubrics strong starting drafts that clarified vague criteria. Oversight stayed essential: wording could be generic or pitched at the wrong grade, and editing criteria was the weakest part. Teachers would adopt them if customization stays easy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bahare Riahi, Sayali Patukale, Joy Niranjan, Yogya Koneru, Tiffany Barnes, Veronica Cateté |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42146 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.10773
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
AI-Generated Rubric Interfaces: K–12 Teachers’ Perceptions and Practices Bahare Riahi, Sayali Patukale, Joy Niranjan, Yogya Koneru, Tiffany Barnes, Veronica Cateté Abstract This study investigates K–12 teachers’ perceptions and experiences with AI-supported rubric generation during a summer professional development workshop (n = 25). Teachers used MagicSchool.ai to generate rubrics and practiced prompting to tailor criteria and performance levels. They then applied these rubrics to provide feedback on a sample block-based programming activity, followed by using a chatbot to deliver rubric-based feedback for the same work. Data were collected through Pre- and post-workshop surveys, open discussions and exit tickets. We used Thematic analysis for qualitative data. Teachers reported that they rarely create rubrics from scratch because the process is time-consuming and defining clear performance-level distinctions is challenging. After hands-on use, teachers described AI-generated rubrics as strong starting drafts that improved structure and clarified vague criteria, but emphasized the need for teacher oversight due to generic or grade-misaligned language, occasional misalignment with instructional priorities, and substantial editing requirements. Survey results indicated high perceived clarity and ethical acceptability, moderate assignment alignment, and usability as the primary weakness, particularly the ability to add, remove, or revise criteria. Open-ended responses highlighted a “strictness-versus-detail” tradeoff: AI feedback was often perceived as harsher but more detailed and scalable, leading teachers to express conditional willingness to adopt AI rubric tools when workflows support easy customization and preserve teacher control. 1 Introduction The rapid growth in computer science enrollment, teachers face growing challenges in managing their classes effectively, making classroom management and individualized support increasingly demanding. To address these issues, digital tools and learning platforms have been introduced to assist teachers in supporting their tasks while also enhancing student learning outcomes and performance [ 8 ] . Rubrics are instruments that define criteria and performance standards, helping ensure consistency in grading while guiding both instructors and students in the assessment process [ 11 , 14 , 30 ] . They offer teachers a systematic framework for evaluating student work and provide students with a clearer understanding of the standards expected of them [ 2 ] . By making assessment criteria explicit, rubrics allow students to see the rationale behind point deductions, enabling students to envision strategies for improving their work [ 5 ] . Providing effective and personalized feedback remains one of the most critical and time consuming responsibilities of educators. Due to heavy workloads of the teachers, the quality of feedback is often constrained [ 16 ] . Recent advances in artificial intelligence (AI) have expanded these systems’ capabilities, enabling features such as automated rubric generation to streamline assessment practices [ 21 ] . Unlike many existing autograders that require programming or specialized test-case design, rubric-based systems start from a familiar artifact that teachers already use for grading, making them more usable for novice K–12 teachers and aligned with existing practice [ 4 ] . Once a rubric is defined, LLMs can leverage its structure to evaluate aspects of student work such as reasoning, creativity, and clarity, extending beyond what traditional code- or test-based autograders typically capture [ 31 ] . Given the increasing ubiquity of AI in education, there is a growing consensus that both teachers and students must develop a foundational understanding of AI tools and their affordances. Equally, the design of effective AI systems requires careful alignment with users’ needs [ 23 ] , preferences [ 24 ] , perceptions and experience. This study examines the rubric generation feature of AI-enabled educational platforms, with particular attention to how it can enhance assessment and feedback practices in teaching and learning contexts. The present study aims to: Examine the potential of artificial intelligence (AI) tools for rubric generation. Investigate teachers’ experiences, perceptions, and practices related to the use of these AI tools [ 6 ] . We conducted professional development sessions with middle- (n = 19) and high-school teachers (n = 6). During these sessions, teachers created rubrics with AI tool, and used the AI-generated rubrics to assess assignments. We gather teachers’ feedback on the AI-enabled grading and rubric interface. This study aim to answer the following research questions: • RQ1. What are teachers’ perspectives about using a Large Language Model (LLM) for generating rubrics and making assessments for block-based programming in their classrooms? • RQ2. How does hands-on exposure to AI rubric/assessment tools influence teachers’ intentions to adopt them in future classroom practice? 2 Background Rubrics provide a coherent framework that spells out the criteria for student work and the quality levels for each, outlining the task’s key components, standards for success, and performance-level descriptors [ 6 , 25 ] . As detailed, consistent, requirement-aligned rubrics are essential for fair, transparent evaluation, recent work explores how AI can strengthen rubric development, improving precision, efficiency, and curricular alignment [ 9 ] . AI can process rich, context-specific inputs and support iterative refinement, streamlining assessment design and enabling personalization [ 13 , 26 ] . Within CS education, research suggests that educational generative AI tools can be useful and well-received for assessment-adjacent support when paired with guardrails and instructor control [ 17 ] . Related work on rubric-based AI assistance for grading similarly indicates that AI can generate reasonably accurate first-pass, rubric-aligned judgments that instructors validate, improving grading efficiency while keeping teachers in control; one study reports up to 85% agreement with teacher criterion-level decisions in a CS course exam setting [ 10 ] . Work in block-based learning environments has also examined AI-enabled assessment support, but often from a learner-facing perspective. For example, LevelUp is an automatic assessment tool embedded in a block-based machine learning environment that provides continuous, rubric-based formative feedback while learners are coding, and reports positive student perceptions of usefulness after the study [ 22 , 7 ] . These systems emphasize in-the-moment scaffolding to improve student project quality during creation, rather than supporting teachers in authoring and adapting assessment criteria. Another instructor-facing tool that automates rubric creation from teacher inputs is Colleague AI’s Rubric Generation. It supports generating standards-aligned, editable rubrics from information such as grade level, subject, standards, goals, and uploaded materials, and it can also generate accompanying answer keys and feedback—reducing rubric authoring time and improving consistency while keeping teachers responsible for final grading decisions [ 27 ] . This workflow is similar to MagicSchool.ai, which likewise prompts teachers to specify key context (e.g., grade level and scoring scale) and to provide assignment and standards information. As shown in Figure 1 , MagicSchool.ai allows teachers to enter the grade level, scale/point structure, standards or objectives, and an assignment description, and it also provides an “additional customization” field for prompting specific rubric preferences (e.g., focus areas or tone). These shared design elements reflect a common pattern across instructor-facing rubric tools: the system generates an initial draft, while teachers retain control to adapt criteria, wording, and emphasis to match their instructional intent and classroom context. More broadly, studies suggest AI-assisted rubrics may promote fairness and consistency by enforcing common criteria, tying judgments to explicit outcomes, and enabling timely individualized feedback, while also raising requests for greater transparency and explainability that underscore the importance of human oversight and iterative revision [ 15 ] . Complementarily, comparisons of AI-generation feedback by chatbots with instructors and peers