Extended Radio Galaxies in EMU: A Comparative Look at Source-Finding Techniques
Lachlan J. Barnes, Andrew M. Hopkins, Yjan Gordon, Nikhel Gupta, Gary Segal, Heinz Andernach, Michael J. I. Brown, Duncan Farrah, Stanislav S. Shabala, Sarah V. White, O. Ivy Wong · 2026
Read Extended Radio Galaxies in EMU: A Comparative Look at Source-Finding Techniques by Lachlan J. Barnes, Andrew M. Hopkins, Yjan Gordon, Nikhel Gupta, Gary Segal, Heinz Andernach, Michael J. I. Brown, Duncan Farrah, Stanislav S. Shabala, Sarah V. White, O. Ivy Wong (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-10579.txt.
Introduction
Lachlan J Barnes and co-authors compare three automatic ways to find extended radio galaxies in the EMU survey. The field is GAMA 09, and extended sources are hard for automated detection. The team tried a DRAGN hunter working from component catalogues, a coarse-grained complexity metric, and a machine learning pipeline trained on the pilot survey. Together the three found nearly all extended sources, yet each found a largely distinct set, with only a few hundred shared by all. A complete census, they conclude, will need such methods combined.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lachlan J. Barnes, Andrew M. Hopkins, Yjan Gordon, Nikhel Gupta, Gary Segal, Heinz Andernach, Michael J. I. Brown, Duncan Farrah, Stanislav S. Shabala, Sarah V. White, O. Ivy Wong |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 72689 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.10579
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Extended Radio Galaxies in EMU: A Comparative Look at Source-Finding Techniques Lachlan J. Barnes, Andrew M. Hopkins, Yjan Gordon, Nikhel Gupta, Gary Segal, Heinz Andernach, Michael J. I. Brown, Duncan Farrah, Stanislav S. Shabala, Sarah V. White, O. Ivy Wong Abstract Extended radio sources present unique challenges for automated detection and classification in wide-field radio surveys. With current surveys such as the Evolutionary Map of the Universe (EMU), robust and scalable methods are essential to identify and catalogue these complex sources. We apply three automatic approaches to detect complex radio emission in EMU observations of the Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA) 09 field (EMU-G09) in order to evaluate their relative strengths and limitations in preparation for large-scale application across future EMU data releases. These include DRAGN HUNTER , designed to detect likely DRAGNs (Double Radio sources associated with Active Galactic Nuclei) from a component catalogue; coarse-grained complexity, a metric designed to highlight regions of complex emission; and RG-CAT, a machine learning pipeline trained on radio sources identified in the EMU pilot survey. We find that together, the three methods recover nearly all extended sources in EMU-G09 but identify largely distinct, partially-overlapping subsets, with only 375 375 sources identified by all finders. This demonstrates that a combination of complementary techniques will be required to achieve a complete census of extended radio sources in future large-scale surveys. keywords radio continuum: galaxies, galaxies: jets, galaxies: structure \alsoaffiliation Astrophysics and Space Technologies Research Centre, Macquarie University, Balaclava Road, Sydney, NSW 2109, Australia Lachlan J. Barnes][email protected] \alsoaffiliation Astrophysics and Space Technologies Research Centre, Macquarie University, Balaclava Road, Sydney, NSW 2109, Australia \alsoaffiliation Permanent address: Universidad de Guanajuato, Departamento de Astronomía, DCNE, Callejón de Jalisco s/n, Guanajuato 36023, Mexico \alsoaffiliation Institute for Astronomy, University of Hawai‘i, 2680 Woodlawn Dr., Honolulu, HI, 96822, USA \alsoaffiliation International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), The University of Western Australia, Crawley, WA, Australia \published dd Mmm YYYY 1 Introduction The study of extended radio sources has expanded rapidly over recent decades. Historically, radio telescopes did not have the sensitivity to detect faint sources, nor the resolution to detect extended sources, limiting the total number of extended radio sources in survey catalogues (see 57 , for a review) . Large-scale surveys such as FIRST ( 5 ; 71 ) , NVSS ( 12 ) and LoTSS ( 65 ; 66 ; 64 ) have increased the known number of radio sources dramatically (cataloguing \sim\!900,000 , \sim\!1.8 million and \sim\!4.4 million sources, respectively), many of which show extended emission ( \sim\!80\% , \sim\!16\% , \sim\!80\% , respectively). Current radio telescope facilities, such as the Square Kilometre Array pathfinders (see 52 ; 53 , for more details) , and their respective large-scale surveys will further increase the number of known radio sources into the tens of millions. Double Radio sources associated with Active Galactic Nuclei ( 42 , DRAGNs;) dominate the population of extended radio sources at high flux densities ( 56 ) . These systems often show symmetric double-lobed structures with jets, hotspots, lobes, and compact cores coincident with a host galaxy ( 40 ; 33 ; 51 , e.g.,) . Deeper and more sensitive observations reveal an increasingly broader diversity of AGN-powered structures that depart from traditional classifications, such as the traditional Fanaroff–Riley morphology types ( 25 ) . These include X-shaped or winged radio galaxies ( 27 , e.g.,) , remnant or dying radio sources with diffuse fading lobes ( 10 , e.g.,) , and giant radio galaxies ( 19 ; 18 , GRGs,) extending over megaparsec scales. Extended radio emission is also not limited to AGN activity, and arises in a wide range of astrophysical environments. In nearby spiral galaxies, HII regions and supernova remnants contribute compact and filamentary radio features ( 13 ) . On larger scales, galaxy groups and clusters host low surface brightness sources such as radio halos, and relics in the intracluster medium ( 55 ; 35 , e.g.,) . Extended radio morphologies are diverse, often complex, and are shaped by various physical mechanisms beyond classical AGN jets. As the diversity of extended radio sources becomes more apparent, the process of identifying, cataloguing, and classifying them has become increasingly challenging. Identifying the host galaxies of extended systems also adds further complexity, but is required to derive any physical parameters of the sources (such as size or luminosity). Manual cross-matching is known to be labour-intensive and nonviable for large datasets ( 24 ; 72 ; 73 ; 23 , e.g.) . With modern surveys detecting millions of sources, automated approaches have become essential for scaling source identification and characterisation beyond what is feasible through human inspection alone. Automatic source detection software such as Selavy ( 75 ) , PyBDSF ( 50 , Python Blob Detector and Source Finder,) , and CAESAR ( 58 ; 61 ) have been incorporated into radio telescope pipelines to accommodate the large influx of radio data. They have been shown to accurately identify and characterise compact sources ( 36 ; 60 ; 8 ; 9 , e.g.,) , however there is mixed performance on extended sources. New tools have since been designed to identify and characterise extended radio emission, such as DRAGN HUNTER ( 28 ) , and coarse-grained complexity ( 63 ) . Various machine learning approaches have also been developed ( 45 ; 80 ; 26 ; 31 ; 59 ; 32 ; 2 , e.g.,) , which have been shown to be capable at handling the vast amounts of radio data being obtained and detecting extended sources. Complementary to these approaches, large-scale citizen-science projects such as Radio Galaxy Zoo ( 4 ; 78 , RGZ,) have shown that crowd-sourced human classifications remain highly effective for identifying complex extended systems, and can provide training sets to further advance machine learning approaches. Identifying and characterising extended radio sources remains a central challenge in the era of large-scale radio continuum surveys. In this work, we perform a comparative analysis of three independent extended source-finding algorithms, applied to the same region. Rather than comparing to a predefined ground truth, we focus on understanding the relative behaviour of each source finder: the types of extended systems they successfully identify, the cases they miss, and the degree of overlap between their detections. This comparison provides practical insight into the strengths and limitations of current methods, and informs future development and application of extended source-finding techniques for current and upcoming wide-field surveys. This paper is structured as follows: § 2 describes the multi-wavelength data used in this work. § 3 introduces and outlines the three extended source-finding algorithms. § 4 presents a comparative analysis of their performance and discusses implications for future surveys. Where relevant, we adopt a flat \Lambda CDM cosmology with H_{0}=70 km s -1 , Mpc -1 , \Omega_{\mathrm{M}}=0.3 , \Omega_{\Lambda}=0.7 , and \Omega_{\mathrm{k}}=0 . 2 Data 2.1 GAMA Galaxy and Mass Assembly 1 1 1 https://www.gama-survey.org/ ( 20 ; 7 ; 21 , GAMA,) is a multi-wavelength imaging and spectroscopic survey using the AAOmega multi-object spectrograph ( 68 ) on the Anglo-Australian Telescope (AAT). The GAMA survey covers five separate fields (G02, G09, G12, G15, and G23), spanning a collective area of 286 square degrees. Each region has a survey limit