Win-score promotion gates in aggregator-routed RFQ markets: A two-tier stochastic control model
Alexander Barzykin · 2026
Read Win-score promotion gates in aggregator-routed RFQ markets: A two-tier stochastic control model by Alexander Barzykin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-10569.txt.
Introduction
Alexander Barzykin studies market making where an aggregator routes RFQ flow by a dealer's slowly moving win score. His two-tier control model splits quote-level competition from a routing layer gated by that score, while background flow stays ungated. Solving the problem gives a clean map from optimal win chances to optimal offsets. For steep gates, the score dynamics can show bistability and a campaign-versus-harvest pattern in quoting, with background flow keeping inventory mixing alive.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexander Barzykin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34658 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.10569
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Win-score promotion gates in aggregator-routed RFQ markets: A two-tier stochastic control model Alexander Barzykin Abstract We study market making in aggregator-routed RFQ markets where platform routing depends on slowly varying dealer performance scores. We propose a two-tier stochastic control model that separates RFQ-level price competition from a macro routing layer: tier A represents aggregator flow whose opportunity intensity is multiplied by a promotion gate driven by the dealer’s win score, while tier B captures background flow that is not gated and does not update the score. RFQs arrive in multiple sizes and the dealer chooses a size-ladder of bid/ask offsets; conditional on winning, trades earn spread minus an adverse selection correction and contribute to inventory risk. The resulting Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation admits a reduced Bergault-Guéant operator form with explicit win/lose branches for the score on tier A. Using the envelope-theorem argument, we express optimal controls through derivatives of the one-dimensional reduced Hamiltonians, yielding an interpretable mapping from optimal win probabilities to optimal offsets. In the long-memory regime, we derive an adiabatic approximation that separates fast inventory dynamics from slow score dynamics. A quadratic inventory ansatz and quadratic Hamiltonian expansion lead to a quasi-stationarity inventory-curvature scaling and a one-dimensional score drift field. For steep (logistic) promotion gates, the score dynamics can exhibit fold bifurcations, bistability, and hysteresis, producing an endogenous “campaign vs. harvest” pattern in optimal quoting. Numerical experiments confirm this behaviour and highlight the stabilizing role of background flow in maintaining inventory-mixing capacity even when the dealer is weakly promoted. Key words: Market Making, Stochastic Optimal Control, Adverse Selection, Win Ratio, RFQ, Bifurcation, Bistability 1 Introduction Multi-dealer request-for-quote (RFQ) protocols are central to dealer-to-client execution in several over-the-counter (OTC) markets, including foreign exchange (FX). In an RFQ, a client requests prices from multiple liquidity providers (LPs) and either trades with one LP or does not trade at all. In modern FX workflows, RFQs are frequently routed through aggregators that consolidate quotes and automate selection, creating an interaction between micro -level price competition inside each RFQ and macro -level flow allocation rules that determine which LPs are invited to compete and how frequently. On the modelling side, stochastic optimal control approaches to market making combine inventory management with quote-dependent order arrivals [ 21 , 2 , 20 , 10 ] . In OTC RFQ markets, an additional structural feature is size heterogeneity: an LP typically answers a menu of quotes for different notionals. This leads naturally to multi-size ladder controls and to Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) equations with non-local (jump) operators indexed by trade size [ 6 ] . Empirical and structural studies on multi-dealer-to-client (MD2C) platforms (notably in corporate bonds) explicitly model how hit probabilities depend on the competitive set and on the number of solicited dealers, highlighting that “how many dealers are asked” is a first-order primitive in RFQ economics [ 19 ] . More recently, causal interventions have been used to study counterfactual pricing and revenue questions on MD2C platforms, bridging structural RFQ models with modern discriminative learning [ 22 ] . In FX, protocol design layer is particularly important. First, the presence of last look (a short post-trade window in which an LP may accept or reject) affects both spreads and selection [ 24 , 11 ] . Second, even without last look, the aggregator itself shapes adverse selection and incentives. Oomen [ 23 ] argues that the “winner’s-curse” in an aggregator can strengthen as more LPs compete: the best displayed quote is more likely to be selected precisely in states that are unfavorable to the winning LP. This provides an economic rationale for limiting the number of LPs exposed to each RFQ and for using routing and ranking rules rather than always inviting the full pool. Recent work on broker performance evaluation and selection highlights the practical importance of quantitatively ranking execution providers using intraday cost models [ 18 ] . Related FX microstructure considerations, such as internalisation versus externalisation of client flow [ 9 , 3 ] and informational risks that accompany competitive quoting [ 4 ] , further motivate modelling the interaction between client access, dealer incentives, and platform design. A growing modern literature examines competition among liquidity providers and the extent to which it can be represented in tractable control or equilibrium frameworks. One approach treats competition in reduced form: a reference market maker optimises quotes while fill probabilities depend on differences versus exogenous competing quotes, yielding approximate closed-form solutions under linear-quadratic objectives [ 8 ] . Other works move to explicit strategic settings (e.g., Stackelberg or Nash structures), providing equilibrium characterisations for competitive liquidity provision [ 15 , 14 , 17 ] . A parallel strand uses reinforcement learning and agent-based models to study the emergence of tacit coordination in electronic markets and in MD2C-type dealer platforms, and the role of heterogeneity in mitigating such effects [ 13 , 12 , 1 , 16 ] . Across these strands, two empirical facts stand out in aggregator-routed RFQ markets: (i) the competitive set is typically a subset of all eligible LPs and is often shaped by ranking, relationship, or platform-level “top list + exploration” logic; (ii) inclusion and rank depend on slowly varying performance scores (e.g., long-run win ratio, response quality), which in turn depend on how aggressively the LP quotes. While the RFQ micro-link is well captured by size-ladder market making [ 6 ] and the macro design layer is motivated by aggregator economics [ 23 ] , there is limited academic control literature that treats platform shortlisting driven by a slow win-score as an explicit state variable feeding back into the LP’s future opportunity intensity. This paper proposes a minimal two-scale model that links RFQ-level market making to aggregator routing via a slow win-score. A key modelling choice is to start from the onset with two tiers of RFQ flow: • an aggregator tier (A), whose opportunity intensity is multiplied by a gate G(R) driven by the LP’s score and whose outcomes update the score; • a background tier (B), representing residual client flow that is not gated by the platform score and does not update it. This decomposition is motivated by practice: (a) only a subset of the firm’s franchise is routed through ranking-based shortlists; (b) inventory risk is managed against all trading opportunities, not only the ranked stream. Analytically, the background tier plays a stabilising role: it provides a baseline level of inventory mixing even when G(R) is small, and it allows the model to generate a “campaign vs. harvest” trade-off in which the LP can temporarily sacrifice edge on tier A to improve future access while still managing inventory through tier B. We derive a reduced HJB in a Bergault-Guéant operator form, with explicit “win” and “lose” branches in the score for tier A, and standard jump operators for tier B. Using an envelope-theorem argument, we express optimal controls through derivatives of scalar reduced Hamiltonians, giving a clean inverse mapping from optimal win probabilities to optimal offsets. In the long-memory-EMA limit, the model separates into a fast inventory-control scale and a slow reputation-dynamics scale. A quadratic inventory ansatz and quadratic Hamiltonian expansion à la Bergault et al. [ 7 ] yield an LQ-like closure, stationary Riccati scaling for the inventory curvature,