Long-range magnetic order with disordered spin orientations in a high-entropy antiferromagnet
Yao Shen, Guangkai Zhang, Qinghua Zhang, Xuejuan Gui, Yu Zhang, Heemin Lee, Cheng-Tai Kuo, Jun-Sik Lee, Ronny Sutarto, Feng Ye, Zhao Pan, Xiaomei Qin, Jinchen Wang, Tianping Ying, Youwen Long · 2026
Read Long-range magnetic order with disordered spin orientations in a high-entropy antiferromagnet by Yao Shen, Guangkai Zhang, Qinghua Zhang, Xuejuan Gui, Yu Zhang, Heemin Lee, Cheng-Tai Kuo, Jun-Sik Lee, Ronny Sutarto, Feng Ye, Zhao Pan, Xiaomei Qin, Jinchen Wang, Tianping Ying, Youwen Long (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-10412.txt.
Introduction
Yao Shen and co-authors report a rare case where long-range magnetic order survives heavy atomic disorder, in a high-entropy honeycomb material. Disorder usually kills such order, favoring spin glasses or clusters. Using resonant soft x-ray scattering plus neutron methods, they tracked each element in a material where four metals share the lattice. Below a set temperature the system orders in a zigzag antiferromagnetic pattern, all four elements joining one transition. Yet each element's spins point in distinct directions, a balance of single-ion anisotropy against exchange.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yao Shen, Guangkai Zhang, Qinghua Zhang, Xuejuan Gui, Yu Zhang, Heemin Lee, Cheng-Tai Kuo, Jun-Sik Lee, Ronny Sutarto, Feng Ye, Zhao Pan, Xiaomei Qin, Jinchen Wang, Tianping Ying, Youwen Long |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33993 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.10412
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Long-range magnetic order with disordered spin orientations in a high-entropy antiferromagnet Yao Shen, Guangkai Zhang, Qinghua Zhang, Xuejuan Gui, Yu Zhang, Heemin Lee, Cheng-Tai Kuo, Jun-Sik Lee, Ronny Sutarto, Feng Ye, Zhao Pan, Xiaomei Qin, Jinchen Wang, Tianping Ying, Youwen Long Abstract Disorder in magnetic systems typically suppresses long-range order, promoting short-range states such as spin glasses and magnetic clusters. This is particularly prominent in high-entropy materials, characterized by the random distributions of local magnetic entities and exchange interactions. However, in rare exceptions, long-range magnetic order can persist in high-entropy systems, while the microscopic characters and underlying mechanisms remain elusive, especially the magnetic behaviors of individual elements. Here, combining neutron diffraction and resonant soft x-ray scattering, we have conducted an element-specific investigation into the magnetic order of a high-entropy honeycomb-lattice van der Waals material (Mn 1/4 Fe 1/4 Co 1/4 Ni 1/4 )PS 3 . Despite significant atomic disorder, long-range zigzag antiferromagnetic order is observed below 72 K, with all four transition-metal elements participating in a unified phase transition. However, the spin orientations of various elements are distinct, attributed to the competition between single-ion anisotropies and exchange interactions. Our findings showcase a novel form of long-range magnetic order with disordered spin orientations, which is synergically stabilized by distinct magnetic elements in a high entropy magnet, offering a new paradigm for understanding complex magnetic systems. Introduction Conventionally, magnetism is characterized by order parameters indicative of symmetry breaking and features a repeating pattern of magnetic moments. Disorder can be introduced through chemical substitution, which is commonly treated as local perturbations when its effects are weak. However, when disorder becomes significant — such as when dopant concentrations approach those of the host material — the periodic spin arrangement can be entirely disrupted, leading to dramatically weakened magnetic correlations. In classical magnetic systems, such disordered states with short-range order are generally understood within the framework of spin glass theory Binder and Young 1986 ; Mydosh 2015 . Such is the case for the magnetism in high-entropy (HE) materials — such as alloys Yeh et al. 2004 ; Miracle and Senkov 2017 ; Ding et al. 2019 ; George et al. 2019 ; Sun and Cava 2019 , ceramics Oses et al. 2020 , oxides Rost et al. 2015 ; Witte et al. 2019 , and van der Waals compounds Ying et al. 2021 ; Ying et al. 2022 ; Chen et al. 2022 . These materials feature multiple principal elements randomly distributed at comparable concentrations, yielding exceptionally high configurational entropy. They can exhibit highly tunable properties, novel topological electronic structures Laha et al. 2024 , and outstanding performance in applications Sarkar et al. 2018 ; Schweidler et al. 2024 ; Han et al. 2024 . Regarding magnetic properties, the substantial disorder arising from randomly distributed magnetic moments and exchange interactions is expected to suppress long-range magnetic order. Indeed, glass-like magnetic behaviors are commonly observed in HE magnets Yin et al. 2022 ; Angelo et al. 2025 , where spin moments are frozen in random directions, pinned by local lattice distortions. Yet, in some rare cases, long-range magnetic order can persist Johnstone et al. 2022 ; Zhu et al. 2024 ; Min et al. 2024 ; Nalbandyan et al. 2024 , presenting a fundamental paradox given the inherent disorder of the system, and the nature of such ordering remains unresolved. For instance, it is often presumed that once magnetic order is established in HE magnets, it uniformly affects all constituent elements with identical transition temperatures and spin orientations, even though each element, with its distinct orbital filling, could contribute its unique magnetic characteristics such as spin magnitudes and single-ion anisotropies. In fact, the magnetic behaviors of individual magnetic elements have never been thoroughly explored in HE materials. The lack of HE single crystals poses an additional barrier for detailed studies of their magnetic properties. In this regard, HEPS 3 , short for (Mn 1/4 Fe 1/4 Co 1/4 Ni 1/4 )PS 3 , emerges as a pivotal candidate to address this gap Ying et al. 2021 . As a newly discovered HE van der Waals material, it features a slightly distorted two-dimensional (2D) honeycomb lattice with the monoclinic space group C2/m and lattice constants of a=5.9321 Å, b=10.2737 Å, c=6.7061 Å, \alpha=\gamma=90^{\circ} and \beta\approx 107^{\circ} (Supplementary Note 1), belonging to the TMPX 3 family (TM: transition metal, X: S/Se) Zhou et al. 2022 ; Matthiesen et al. 2023 ; Zong et al. 2023 ; Ilyas et al. 2024 ; Wildes et al. 2023 ; Kang et al. 2020 ; He et al. 2024 . For the non- HE individual TMPX 3 members, as shown in Fig. 1 a–d, MnPS 3 exhibits Néel-type magnetic order with a propagation vector \mathbf{k}{}=(0,0,0) , while FePS 3 , CoPS 3 , and NiPS 3 display zigzag antiferromagnetic (AFM) order with a propagation vector \mathbf{k}{}=(0,1,L) where L varies with the specific TM element (Table 1 ). The magnetic moments in these materials are confined to the ac^{*} plane (Fig. 1 e), and their precise orientations are also element-dependent (Table 1 ). Here, \mathbf{a} , \mathbf{b} , and \mathbf{c} represent the real-space vectors, while \mathbf{a^{*}} \mathbf{b^{*}} , and \mathbf{c^{*}} denote reciprocal vectors. Note that \mathbf{c^{*}} is orthogonal to \mathbf{a} , and \mathbf{b^{*}} is parallel to \mathbf{b} . For HEPS 3 , which incorporates four different TM elements in equal concentrations, long-range magnetic order is hinted by magnetic susceptibility measurements at low temperatures Ying et al. 2021 , presenting a unique instance of magnetic order within a highly disordered system. Furthermore, the availability of HEPS 3 single crystals enables detailed exploration of its magnetic properties. Here, combining neutron diffraction and resonant soft x-ray scattering (RSXS) techniques, we have comprehensively investigated the magnetic ordering in HEPS 3 single crystals. Neutron diffraction is a powerful tool for detecting various forms of magnetic order, including long-range and short-range types, with greater access to reciprocal space. In contrast, resonant soft x-ray scattering (RSXS) , despite its limited reciprocal space coverage, achieves element-specific resolution by tuning the incident photon energy to the resonant edge of the target element. Our neutron diffraction experiments reveal the presence of three-dimensional (3D) long-range magnetic order, with a Néel temperature of T_{\mathrm{N}}{}\approx 72 K, coexisting with 2D magnetic signals. RSXS measurements further confirm that all four TM elements participate in the magnetic ordering through a unified phase transition. The resulting magnetic structure features element-dependent spin orientations, attributed to the competition between single-ion anisotropies and exchange interactions. Results Sample characterization First, we verify the random distribution of TM elements in HEPS 3 through atomic-resolved elemental mapping using scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) on an exfoliated HEPS 3 thin flake. The sample, with a thickness of dozens of unit cells, enables the STEM mapping to be interpreted as spatial averages across multiple stacked honeycomb layers. As shown in Fig. 1 f, the images reveal a homogeneous intensity distribution for each element, indicating that all elements are randomly distributed throughout the lattice. While a high-entropy scenario is well established, an anomaly indicative of magnetic phase transition is observed in the magnetic susceptibility measurements of HEPS 3 at T_{\mathrm{N}}{}=T_{1}\approx 72 K, followed by another transition taking place at T_{2}\approx 40 K, below which the zero-field-cooling (ZFC)