The AJ conjecture and connected sums of torus knots
Xingru Zhang · 2026
Read The AJ conjecture and connected sums of torus knots by Xingru Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-10235.txt.
Introduction
Xingru Zhang verifies the AJ conjecture for connected sums of torus knots when two parameters share the same sign. Torus knots correspond to coprime integer pairs, and the conjecture links a knot's recurrence polynomial to its A polynomial. In cases where the pair products match but the pairs differ, the recurrence polynomial gains repeated factors after a key evaluation. Zhang notes these seem to be the first such examples, so the conjecture needs slight modification.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xingru Zhang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 179128 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.10235
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The AJ conjecture and connected sums of torus knots Xingru Zhang Abstract . The set of isotopy classes of nontrivial torus knots T ( p , q ) T(p,q) in S 3 S^{3} is in bijection with the set of coprime integer pairs ( p , q ) (p,q) satisfying | p | > q ≥ 2 |p|>q\geq 2 . We verify the AJ conjecture for the connected sums T ( p , q ) # T ( a , b ) T(p,q)\#T(a,b) when p p and a a have the same sign. Notably, in cases where p q = a b pq=ab but p ≠ a p\neq a , the recurrence polynomial α ( t , M , L ) {\alpha}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) of T ( p , q ) # T ( a , b ) T(p,q)\#T(a,b) has repeated factors involving the variable L after evaluation at t = − 1 t=-1 . These appear to be the first examples of knots exhibiting this phenomenon. Therefore, the AJ conjecture requires a slight modification to accommodate this possibility. 1. Introduction The AJ conjecture, formulated by Garoufalidis [ 3 , Conjecture 2] , predicts a fundamental connection between two important knot invariants for knots in S^{3} : the A-polynomial and the colored Jones polynomial. For a knot K in S^{3} , its (normalized) A -polynomial A_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) is a two-variable polynomial in {\mathbb{Z}}[{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}] with no repeated factors and with relatively prime integer coefficients, which is uniquely associated with K up to a sign (see [ 1 ] ). Note that A_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) always contains the factor {{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}-1 . For a knot K in S^{3} and each positive integer n , the n -colored Jones polynomial J_{{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}}(n) is a one-variable Laurent polynomial in {\mathbb{Z}}[t^{\pm 1}] with the zero framing (see [ 18 ] ). In this paper, J_{{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}}(n) is normalized such that for the unknot U , (1.1) J_{{\mbox{\tiny U}}}(n)=[n]:=\frac{t^{2n}-t^{-2n}}{t^{2}-t^{-2}}. By defining J_{{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}}(-n):=-J_{{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}}(n) and J_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(0):=0 , one may treat J_{{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}}(n) as a discrete function J_{{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}}(\cdot):{\mathbb{Z}}\to{\mathbb{Z}}[t^{\pm 1}] . The quantum torus {\mathcal{T}} , a non-commutative ring with presentation {\mathcal{T}}={\mathbb{Q}}[t^{\pm 1}]\left<{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}^{\pm 1},{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}^{\pm 1}\right>/({{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}-t^{2}{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}), acts on the set of discrete functions f:{\mathbb{Z}}\to{\mathbb{Q}}[t^{\pm 1}] by (1.2) ({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}f)(n):=t^{2n}f(n),\quad({{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}f)(n):=f(n+1). The set of annihilators of J_{{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}}(n) in {\mathcal{T}} , denoted by {\mathcal{A}}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}:=\{P\in{\mathcal{T}}\mid PJ_{{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}}(n)=0\}, is a left ideal of {\mathcal{T}} called the recurrence ideal of K (as each operator P\in{\mathcal{A}}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}} defines a recurrence relation for J_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(n) and vice versa). A fundamental result proven in [ 5 ] states that for every knot K in S^{3} , J_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(n) has a nontrivial recurrence relation, or equivalently, {\mathcal{A}}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}} is not the zero ideal. The ring {\mathcal{T}} can be extended to a principal left ideal domain \widetilde{{\mathcal{T}}} by adjoining inverses of polynomials in t and M ; that is, \widetilde{{\mathcal{T}}} is the set of Laurent polynomials in L with coefficients in {\mathbb{Q}}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}) (which is the set of rational functions in t and M with coefficients in {\mathbb{Q}} ) under the product defined by (1.3) f(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}){{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}^{j}\cdot g(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}){{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}^{k}=f(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}})g(t,t^{2j}{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}){{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}^{j+k}. The extended left ideal \widetilde{{\mathcal{A}}}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}=\widetilde{{\mathcal{T}}}{\mathcal{A}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}} is then generated by a single non-zero element in \widetilde{{\mathcal{T}}} . Such a generator can be normalized to lie in {\mathcal{A}}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}} and takes the form \alpha_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}})=\sum_{i=0}^{d}D_{i}{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}^{i}, with d>0 minimum (among all non-zero annihilators of J_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(n) ) and with D_{0},\dots,D_{d}\in{\mathbb{Z}}[t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}] being coprime in {\mathbb{Z}}[t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}] . This polynomial \alpha_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) is uniquely determined up to a sign and is called the ( normalized ) recurrence polynomial of K . The original AJ conjecture states that for every knot K in S^{3} , \alpha_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(-1,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) is equal to A_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) up to a non-zero factor depending on M only. Based on examples found in this paper, for some knots K , {\alpha}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(-1,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) may contain repeated factors involving the variable L . Consequently, the AJ conjecture requires a slight modification: The AJ conjecture: For every knot K in S^{3} , {\alpha}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(-1,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) , after removing all repeated factors, is equal to A_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) up to a non-zero factor depending on M only. The conjecture remains largely open, having been proven true only for some simple classes of knots, such as some 2 -bridge knots [ 3 , 13 , 7 , 4 , 8 , 9 ] , torus knots [ 6 , 14 ] , some pretzel knots [ 8 ] , and some cabled knots over certain knots [ 11 , 10 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 2 ] . In this paper, we consider the AJ conjecture for connected sums of torus knots. Recall that the set of isotopy classes of nontrivial torus knots T(p,q) in S^{3} is in one-to-one correspondence with the set of coprime integer pairs (p,q) satisfying |p|>q\geq 2 . We show: Theorem 1.1 . The AJ conjecture holds for the connected sums T(p,q)\#T(a,b) when p and a have the same sign. As we will see, for a knot K=T(p,q)\#T(a,b) given as in Theorem 1.1 , its recurrence polynomial {\alpha}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) , after evaluation at t=-1 , has repeated factors involving the variable L exactly when pq=ab but p\neq a . In Section 2, we list the formulas to be applied. Theorem 1.1 is then proved in Sections 3-9, which correspond to seven cases. For convenience, in this paper we often represent the A -polynomial A_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) as an element in {\mathbb{Z}}[{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}^{\pm 1},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}] that differs from the normalized A -polynomial only by a factor of an integer power of M . Similarly, in each case of K=T(p,q)\#T(a,b) that we consider, we shall obtain a recurrence polynomial {\alpha}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) up to normalization, i.e., up to multiplying by a non-zero rational function in t and M . Our proof procedure consists of the following three steps: (1) Produce a candidate minimum L -degree non-zero annihilator {\alpha}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) in \widetilde{{\mathcal{A}}}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}} of the form \displaystyle{\alpha}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}})=\sum_{i=0}^{d}D_{i}{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}^{i} with D_{i}\in{\mathbb{Q}}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}) such that {\alpha}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(-1,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) is well-defined and has the same L -degree as {\alpha}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) ; (2) Verify that {\alpha}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(-1,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) , after removal of all repeated factors, is equal to the A -polynomial A_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) up to multiplying by a non-zero rational function in M ; (3) Prove that the L -degree d of our candidate annihilator {\alpha}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(t,{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}) is indeed the minimum among all non-zero annihilators of J_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}(n) in \widetilde{{\mathcal{A}}}_{{\mbox{\tiny K}}} . This procedure is sufficient to verify the AJ conjecture for the given knot. 2. Some formulas The A -polynomial of T(p,q) is given by (see e.g., [ 19 , Example 4.1] ) (2.1) A_{{{\mbox{\tiny T(p,q)}}}}({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}})=\begin{cases}({{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}-1)({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}^{2pq}{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}^{2}-1)&\text{if $|p|>q>2$,}\\ ({{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}-1)({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}^{2p}{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}+1)&\text{if $|p|>q=2$.}\end{cases} For knots K_{1} and K_{2} in S^{3} , if \displaystyle A_{{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}_{1}}({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}})=\prod_{i\in I}({{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}^{r_{i}}-{\delta}_{i}) and \displaystyle A_{{{\mbox{\tiny K}}}_{2}}({{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}},{{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}})=\prod_{j\in J}({{\mbox{\footnotesize L}}}{{\mbox{\footnotesize M}}}^{s_{i}}-{\delta}_{j})