The propensity for disobedience: Rule-breaking, compliance and social phase transitions Journal: Elsevier
Nuno Crokidakis · 2026
Read The propensity for disobedience: Rule-breaking, compliance and social phase transitions Journal: Elsevier by Nuno Crokidakis (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-10221.txt.
Introduction
Nuno Crokidakis models how rule breaking, from traffic violations to defying legal limits, persists in a society. His replicator dynamics weigh personal benefit against institutional punishment and social sanctions inside each utility function. With positive social feedback, the system is bistable: broad compliance and broad violation are both stable, with a sharp first order style jump between them. Negative feedback instead gives a smooth transition driven by rising collective cost.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nuno Crokidakis |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36070 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.10221
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The propensity for disobedience: Rule-breaking, compliance and social phase transitions Journal: Elsevier Nuno Crokidakis Abstract We develop a mathematical model to describe the persistence of rule-breaking behaviors in societies, such as traffic violations, disregard for legal restrictions and other forms of noncompliance. Using a replicator-type dynamics with utility functions incorporating individual benefits, institutional punishment and social sanctions, we first built a general formulation of the system. Within this framework, we analyze two distinct models differing in the nature of social feedback. In the presence of positive feedback, the system exhibits bistability, with widespread compliance and widespread violation as stable equilibria, and the transition between these states occurs discontinuously once a critical threshold is crossed, resembling a first-order phase transition. By contrast, when negative feedback is present, the population undergoes a continuous phase transition between compliant and noncompliant collective states, driven by an increasing collective cost of rule-breaking. Numerical simulations and analytical results illustrate how changes in enforcement, social tolerance or perceived benefits can shift the system across tipping points. The results provide a theoretical explanation for the fragility of social order under weak institutions and highlight possible pathways to promote compliance. 1 Introduction Rule compliance and rule-breaking are pervasive features of human societies. From traffic violations and tax evasion to academic misconduct and informal norm transgressions, individuals repeatedly face the decision between adhering to established rules or pursuing private advantages [ 1 ] . Although such choices may appear purely individual, their aggregate outcomes often display collective patterns, including abrupt norm collapse, persistent intermediate levels of compliance or long periods of apparent stability followed by sudden shifts. The dynamics of social norms have long been studied across disciplines. Threshold models of collective behavior emphasize how individual decisions may depend on the behavior of others, leading to nonlinear aggregate outcomes [ 2 ] . Classic segregation models further illustrate how simple local incentives can generate large-scale macroscopic patterns [ 3 ] . More recent work has explored the evolution of social norms and collective conventions within evolutionary and economic frameworks [ 4 ] . Collective behavioral changes in social systems have also been investigated in the context of cascading processes on complex networks [ 5 ] . From the perspective of statistical physics and evolutionary dynamics, collective behavior can be understood as an emergent property of interacting agents adapting their strategies over time [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] . Replicator equations and related dynamical systems provide a natural mathematical framework to describe how strategies with higher relative utility increase in frequency within a population [ 13 , 14 ] . Such approaches have been widely applied in the study of cooperation, competition and social interactions on networks and mean-field structures [ 15 ] . A key ingredient in many models of norm compliance is the role of punishment, social sanctions and reputational incentives. Experimental evidences suggest that enforcement mechanisms and peer sanctions can substantially influence cooperative behavior and norm adherence [ 16 ] , and external conditions such as collective risk can significantly influence the strength of social norms and promote cooperative behavior in groups [ 17 ] . However, less attention has been given to the structural distinction between different types of collective feedback and their impact on the macroscopic nature of social transitions [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . In particular, it remains unclear under which conditions the breakdown of social norms occurs abruptly, resembling a discontinuous phase transition, and when it instead proceeds gradually, leading to continuous changes in collective behavior. Addressing this question requires a minimal dynamical framework capable of distinguishing between reinforcing and stabilizing feedback mechanisms. Most existing works focus either on equilibrium game-theoretic approaches or on empirical norm dynamics. Less attention has been given to the structural distinction between reinforcing and stabilizing collective feedback and its implications for the order of social transitions. In this work, we develop a mathematical model for the evolution of rule-breaking behavior based on adaptive utility comparison. We first introduce a general formulation in which individual incentives, institutional enforcement and social feedback jointly determine strategy adaptation. We then analyze two distinct regimes: one characterized by positive social reinforcement, leading to bistability and discontinuous transitions, and another characterized by increasing collective costs of widespread violations, resulting in continuous transitions and intermediate stationary states. By comparing these two formulations, we show that the qualitative nature of collective outcomes is determined not by individual rationality per se, but by the structural form of collective feedback. 2 Models and Results 2.1 General model formulation We consider a population in which individuals repeatedly face the choice between complying with a social rule or breaking it. Let d(t)\in[0,1] denote the fraction of rule-breakers at time t , so that 1-d(t) is the fraction of compliant individuals. The key idea is that the perceived advantages of each strategy depend not only on institutional enforcement, but also on collective behavior. We assume that agents choose between compliance (C) and disobedience (D) by comparing the corresponding expected utilities, which combine private incentives, institutional enforcement and social feedback. In other words, we will define utility functions U_{C}(d) and U_{D}(d) , for compliance and disobedience, respectively. Thus, the utility difference can be defined as \Delta(d)=U_{D}(d)-U_{C}(d)~, (1) and it can be viewed as a relative advantage of rule-breaking. As we will show, the nature of the phase transitions observed in the model, whether continuous or discontinuous, is not a property of individual agents, but rather of the collective feedback mechanisms governing their interactions. In the following subsections, we introduce the two distinct models analyzed in this work. 2.2 Model I: Positive social feedback and bistable dynamics The expected utility of breaking the rule in Model I is written as U_{D}(d)=B-pF-s\,(1-d), (2) where B represents the immediate private benefit of disobedience, p is the probability of punishment, F is the fine (or institutional cost) and s(1-d) captures social sanctions that become stronger when few people disobey. The expected utility of compliance is U_{C}(d)=-C+R\,(1-d), (3) where C represents the individual cost of complying (time, effort, discomfort). The term R\,(1-d) accounts for reputational or symbolic rewards associated with complying with the rule. These rewards depend on the social environment and tend to be stronger when rule-following behavior is widespread in the population, reflecting the social value attached to conformity. From Eq. ( 1 ), we have the utility difference for Model I, \Delta(d)=U_{D}(d)-U_{C}(d)=(B-pF+C)-(s+R)(1-d)=K-L(1-d), (4) where \displaystyle K \displaystyle= \displaystyle B-pF+C (5) \displaystyle L \displaystyle= \displaystyle s+R (6) We assume strategy adjustments follow a replicator-type mean-field dynamics, \dot{d}(t)=\gamma\,d(1-d)\,\Delta(d), (7) where \gamma>0 controls the speed of adaptation. The prefactor d(1-d) ensures that \dot{d}=0 at the absorbing boundaries d=0 (full compliance) and d=1 (full violation). We assume that individuals do not deterministically choose between compliance and disobedience, but rather adapt their behavior over time by comparing the relative utilities of the two strategies. In this context, the fraction d(t) of disobedient agents evolves according to the difference in expected utilities, a standard assumption in evolutionary game theory and population dynamics [ 14 , 18 ] . This leads naturally to a replicator-type equation for d(t) , ensuring that strategies with higher relative