Unexpectedly Weak General Relativistic Effects in Strongly Relativistic Tidal Disruption Events

Ho-Sang Chan, Taeho Ryu, Julian Krolik, Tsvi Piran · 2026

Read Unexpectedly Weak General Relativistic Effects in Strongly Relativistic Tidal Disruption Events by Ho-Sang Chan, Taeho Ryu, Julian Krolik, Tsvi Piran (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-10208.txt.

Introduction

Ho-Sang Chan and coauthors simulate a strongly relativistic tidal disruption event and find general relativistic effects surprisingly weak. A Sun like star passing close to a million solar mass black hole was expected to shed orbital energy fast and form a disk promptly. Their relativistic hydrodynamics run instead shows debris staying highly eccentric, pooled near apocenter, with shocks rather than accretion powering the event. Early precession driven shocks fade within about a week.

Catalog record

CREATORHo-Sang Chan, Taeho Ryu, Julian Krolik, Tsvi Piran
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67800
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.10208

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unexpectedly Weak General Relativistic Effects in Strongly Relativistic Tidal Disruption Events Ho-Sang Chan, Taeho Ryu, Julian Krolik, Tsvi Piran Abstract Tidal disruption events (TDEs) occur when stars are destroyed by supermassive black holes and are among the brightest nuclear transients. It has been thought that strong relativistic effects rapidly dissipate orbital energy and produce prompt disk formation when the stellar pericenter is smaller than ∼ 10 \sim 10 gravitational radii. Using a general relativistic hydrodynamic simulation of a strongly relativistic TDE around a 10 6 ​ M ⊙ 10^{6}\,M_{\odot} black hole, we find instead that the overall evolution is similar to weakly relativistic TDEs: the debris remains highly eccentric, with most of the returned mass residing near the orbital apocenter ( ∼ 250 × \sim 250\times the initial pericenter distance), and shocks, rather than accretion, power the event. The simulation starts from the initial stellar approach and follows the debris evolution up to 35 35 days after the peak mass-return time ( ≃ \simeq 23 23 days). Although early shocks driven by strong relativistic apsidal precession and pericenter nozzle compression dissipate orbital energy efficiently, they last only about a week ( ∼ 0.3 \sim 0.3 of the peak mass-return time). Stream self-interactions increase the incoming stream’s angular momentum, thereby expanding its pericenter distance, weakening precession and shocks, and reducing dissipation. These results, along with previous work on weakly relativistic TDEs, suggest that circularization may be intrinsically slow regardless of the strength of relativistic effects, and the flow remains highly eccentric and extended during the peak of optical/UV luminosity. show][email protected] I Introduction A tidal disruption event (TDE) occurs when a star approaches a supermassive black hole (SMBH) with a separation smaller than or comparable to the tidal radius r_{t}\approx R_{*}(M_{\mathrm{BH}}/M_{*})^{1/3} , where M_{\mathrm{BH}} is the SMBH mass, M_{*} is the stellar mass, and R_{*} is the stellar radius. At this distance, the tidal forces exerted by the SMBH become comparable to the star’s self-gravity. For a zero-energy (parabolic) orbit, approximately half of the stellar debris remains gravitationally bound to the SMBH, while the other half escapes to infinity. The fallback rate of the bound debris rises to a peak value, \dot{M}_{0} , which can greatly exceed the Eddington mass accretion rate, and subsequently declines over time as t^{-5/3} ( M. J. Rees 1988 ; E. S. Phinney 1989 ) . This process produces a luminous flare far exceeding the luminosity of a quiescent black hole that is observable in the optical/UV and/or soft X‑ray bands (see T. Wevers & T. Ryu 2023 ; B. Mockler et al. 2025 , for recent reviews) . The conventional view of TDE emission rests on the premise that the accretion rate onto the black hole tracks the mass fallback rate because the returning debris is assumed to rapidly ‘circularize’, i.e., settle into circular orbits on the radial scale set by the debris’ mean angular momentum, \simeq 2\,r_{p} . Accretion within such a disk leads to radiation, primarily in soft X-rays ( M. J. Rees 1988 ; L. E. Strubbe & E. Quataert 2009 ; G. Lodato & E. M. Rossi 2011 ) . Other works ( S. A. Balbus & A. Mummery 2018 ; A. Mummery et al. 2024 ) separate the accretion rate from the mass-return rate, while still asserting that the debris quickly ‘circularizes’. However, this assumption is in strong tension with observations 1 1 1 Recent observations of the polarization in TDEs also support non-circular gas morphology and shock-powered emission ( K. I. I. Koljonen et al. 2025 ; A. Floris et al. 2026 , e.g.,) . : a large majority of TDE candidates are instead brightest at the optical/UV wavelengths ( S. Gezari 2012 ; S. van Velzen et al. 2020 , e.g.,) . Moreover, the inferred sizes of the optical/UV emitting regions are typically \sim 100\times the expected dimensions of a circularized debris disk ( S. Gezari 2021 ) . Furthermore, the orbital energy that must be dissipated in order to form a compact disk exceeds the observed radiated energy by several orders of magnitude ( T. Piran et al. 2015 ; G. Svirski et al. 2017 ) . To resolve this tension, the hydrodynamics of the debris must be considered more carefully. The original argument for quick disk formation ( M. J. Rees 1988 ) held that strong relativistic apsidal precession would cause returning debris streams to intersect at a large angle, dissipating an amount of energy comparable to the debris’ kinetic energy at r\sim r_{p} . However, later work ( H. Shiokawa et al. 2015 ; L. Dai et al. 2015 ; J. Krolik et al. 2020 ) showed that for most TDEs, the pericenter is large enough that apsidal precession is relatively small, and the inter-stream shocks are therefore much weaker than initially envisaged. In global simulations since, for all of which the pericenter was >10\,r_{g} , this expectation was upheld ( T. Ryu et al. 2023b ; E. Steinberg & N. C. Stone 2024 ; D. J. Price et al. 2024 ; P. Abolmasov et al. 2025 ) . It is, however, of great interest to examine events with smaller pericenter distances to see what happens when the apsidal precession is strong. In such conditions, it has long been expected that the overall strength of shocks increases, and disk formation should be faster. To date, there have been only a handful of simulations of such events that start from realistic model parameters and track both the star’s disruption and the return of mass to the neighborhood of the black hole. Z. L. Andalman et al. 2022 studied the debris in the disruption of a 1 M_{\odot} star by a 10^{6} M_{\odot} SMBH with a pericenter distance of r_{p}\simeq 7 r_{g} , and followed it for \lesssim 7 days, or \lesssim 0.3 of the debris’ characteristic return time. In this short period of time, they found only limited circularization: the eccentricity of the debris remained high ( \simeq 0.88 ) and was changing very slowly by the end of their simulation. More recently, D. J. Price et al. 2024 reported on simulations comparing non-relativistic to relativistic TDEs (i.e., pericenter distances r_{p}=50\,r_{g} and 10\,r_{g} ) 2 2 2 The relativistic case reported in greatest detail assumed a Schwarzschild spacetime, but they also performed another one for spin parameter 0.99 and a stellar orbit tilted with respect to the black hole spin axis. . They found that disk formation in the relativistic case proceeds more rapidly than in their weakly relativistic simulations, but at the end of their simulation, roughly 10\times the time of peak mass-return, very nearly all the debris mass remained at radii \gtrsim 10^{3} r_{g} . In this work, we investigate how the debris morphology in strongly relativistic TDEs evolves, from the star’s initial approach to the black hole to well past the peak mass-return time. Our general relativistic hydrodynamic (GRHD) simulation demonstrates that strong relativistic effects initially lead to the formation of strong shocks as expected, but this phase is short-lived, lasting only until \sim 0.3 of the peak mass-return time, which is about a week for our simulation’s parameters. Thereafter, the shocks steadily weaken, and disk formation slows down. The debris orbits remain eccentric

Read the complete text