Are quantum trajectories suitable for semiclassical approximations? Keywords: quantum trajectories, dynamical chaos, integrability

Alfredo M. Ozorio de Almeida · 2026

Read Are quantum trajectories suitable for semiclassical approximations? Keywords: quantum trajectories, dynamical chaos, integrability by Alfredo M. Ozorio de Almeida (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-10206.txt.

Introduction

Ozorio de Almeida asks whether quantum trajectories in the de Broglie Bohm picture suit semiclassical work. Those paths rest on a quantum potential drawn from the full wave answer, which strongly reshapes them next to classical paths. Integrability, closely matched in classical and quantum work, is not kept by the quantum paths. They can even turn chaotic for integrable systems, a mismatch that clouds the shift from classical to quantum, the author argues.

Catalog record

CREATORAlfredo M. Ozorio de Almeida
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25612
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.10206

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Are quantum trajectories suitable for semiclassical approximations? Keywords: quantum trajectories, dynamical chaos, integrability Alfredo M. Ozorio de Almeida Abstract The quantum trajectories in the de Broglie - Bohm formulation of quantum mechanics depend on an additional quantum potential derived from the full wave solution of Schrödinger’s equation. The task of supplying collectively all the correct quantum results strongly alters the characteristics of the corresponding classical trajectories, which underlie semiclassical approximations to the evolving wave function. Both classical and quantum trajectories are here considered to be conservative with no influence of an external environment, even though this is the source of eventual classicality in quantum systems, that is, decoherence. The concept of integrability, closely correspondent in classical and quantum mechanics, is not preserved by the quantum trajectories. General systems, in which classical chaotic motion participates, are much harder to treat semiclassically, but quantum trajectories can be chaotic even for integrable systems. This discrepancy between the character of classical and quantum trajectories in the de Broglie - Bohm interpretation does not clarify the singular classical-quantum transition. 1 Introduction Initial reactions to David Bohm’s bold reinterpretation of quantum mechanics in terms of trajectories, which are sensitive to the evolving wave function [ 1 , 2 ] , were mostly negative. Even though this was preceded by De Broglie’s work on pilot waves [ 3 ] , the conceptual immobility imposed by the dominant Copenhagen interpretation was broken in the long run by Bohm showing that quantum trajectories are fully compatible with standard quantum mechanics. Indeed, the recent meeting ”Bohm in Brazil”, held at the Advanced Study Institute of the University of Sao Paulo, brought to light how this influenced the proposal by John Bell of the fundamental experiments [ 4 , 5 ] , which have established a more solid ground for our conceptions. Quantum mechanics (QM) covers vast ranges, from elementary spins or q-bits to those manybody systems, which may have properties that are accurately described classically. In its centenary, many different approaches and representations have shown their value in treating a growing list of quantum problems and applications. My concern here is with semiclassical aproximations (SC), that is, with the supplementation of classical mechanics (CM) that is required to treat quantum problems with increasing accuracy as Planck’s constant \mbox{\amsb\char 125\relax}\rightarrow 0 , compared to appropriate classical actions. I will not deal with this classical limit itself, which has a remarkable singular nature discussed, for instance, by Michael Berry in [ 6 ] . Therefore, no matter how close to the classical limit, it is QM that is here considered. Indeed, this is unitary QM, previous to any measurement and sealed against any influence by an environment or heat bath, which drives the transition to classicality within the various models of decoherence [ 7 ] . The corresponding classical trajectories for such an open quantum system need to be dissipative [ 8 ] , instead of the conservative classical and quantum trajectories discussed here. The starling conceptual break from CM to QM forms the initial barrier to the development of SC approximations. At first sight, the uncertainty principle seems to bury the possible relevance of any kind of trajectory initiated at a single point in phase space. SC approximations are thus a direct growth of the old quantum theory of Bohr [ 9 ] and Sommerfeld [ 10 ] , rather than germinating within the main stream of QM. The neatest connection to bona fide QM proceeds by letting the classical variational principle pick out the trajectories, together with their phases, in Feynman’s path integral [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] . Nevertheless, wouldn’t it be more satisfying to start from the de Broglie-Bohm alternative, even though also exact version of QM? Each experimental result then depends on a particular quantum trajectory, within a probability ensemble that evolves in time along with Schrödinger’s wave function. At a first glance, the approximation of a quantum trajectory by its classical counterpart should be far simpler than approximating entire quantum states. The difficulty lies in Bohm’s quantum potential: the trajectories generated with this apparently innocent addition to the classical potential have the enormous task to supply all the exact results of QM. No classical perturbation theory [ 14 ] is able to bridge this gap. For this reason, the vast simplification of first order classical perturbation theory [ 15 ] , which would merely add the integral of the quantum potential over the unperturbed classical trajectory to obtain its Bohm phase, is doomed to be misleadingly inaccurate. A further obstacle arises if there is more than one degree of freedom. It is well established that integrable systems, which generalize in a rather straightforward way those with a single degree of freedom, are a minority among systems that harbour chaotic, exponentially divergent pairs of classical trajectories. Indeed, arbitrarily small perturbations of integrable systems already generate narrow chaotic zones. Thus, even though classical and quantum integrable Hamiltonians are often matched, along with their respective constants of the motion (in the form of phase space functions or commuting observable operators), the correspondence relies on purely classical trajectories, unaffected by the quantum potential. The following section presents the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation and a short review of standard criticism for simple systems. Then section 3 deals with classical integrability and its quantum correspondence. The breaking of integrability, leading to classically chaotic trajectories, is introduced in section 4, whereas the SC treatment of chaos is discussed in section 5. Concluding remarks concerning the difficulty of accessing SC approximations with quantum trajectories are presented in section 6. 2 Traveling waves and stationary waves For a start, let us take the simplest examples of wave functions of a quantum system, solutions of the Schrödinger equation in the configuration space {\mathbf{q}}=(q_{1},...q_{N}) \left[-\frac{\mbox{\amsb\char 125\relax}^{2}}{2m}\nabla^{2}+V({\mathbf{q}})\right]\langle{\mathbf{q}}|\psi\rangle_{t}=i\mbox{\amsb\char 125\relax}~\frac{\partial\langle{\mathbf{q}}|\psi\rangle_{t}}{\partial t} (2.1) and their de Broglie-Bohm trajectories [ 1 ] . Inserting the complex Bohm ansatz \langle{\mathbf{q}}|\psi\rangle_{t}=R_{t}({\mathbf{q}})~\exp\left(\frac{i}{\mbox{\amsb\char 125\relax}}S_{t}({\mathbf{q}})\right)~, (2.2) into the real part of the Schrödinger equation leads to an analogue of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation -\frac{\partial S_{t}}{\partial t}=\frac{\nabla S_{t}^{2}}{2m}+V+Q_{t}~, (2.3) with the added time-dependent quantum potential Q_{t}({\mathbf{q}})=-\frac{\mbox{\amsb\char 125\relax}^{2}}{2m}\frac{\nabla^{2}R_{t}}{R_{t}}~. (2.4) Therefore, the quantum trajectories depend on the curvature of the evolving amplitude of the exact wave functions. In the case of a single degree of freedom, N=1 , ({\mathbf{q}}=q) a plane wave with energy E propagates over a constant potential V : \langle q|\psi\rangle=\exp\left(\frac{i}{\mbox{\amsb\char 125\relax}}pq\right)~, (2.5) where the constant momentum p=\sqrt{2m(E-V)} (while the normalization constant is dropped). This is already in the standard Bohm form ( 2.2 ), here with the linear phase S({\mathbf{q}})=pq and constant amplitude R({\mathbf{q}})=1 , which also coincides with the simplest SC approximation. Indeed, even for a variable potential with E>V(q) everywhere, the SC generalization of the traveling plane wave ( 2.5 ) has its phase defined by the classical action S_{\rm SC}(q)=\int_{q_{0}}^{q}p(q^{\prime})~\rm{d}q^{\prime}=\int_{q_{0}}^{q}\sqrt{2m(E-V(q^{\prime}))}~\rm{d}q^{\prime}~. (2.6) The amplitude R_{\rm SC}(q)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{p(q)}}~, (2.7) is the square root of the constant classical Liouville distribution in phase space [ 14 ] , projected onto the position axis [ 16 ] . On the other hand, the complete quantum wave function includes a relatively weak reflected wave from even a soft step, in which the classical potential is increased by \delta V within a stepwidth \delta q , that is accounted for within

Read the complete text