An asymptotic proof of the classical log soft graviton theorem

Gianni Boschetti, Miguel Campiglia · 2026

Read An asymptotic proof of the classical log soft graviton theorem by Gianni Boschetti, Miguel Campiglia (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-09844.txt.

Introduction

Boschetti and Campiglia give a new proof of the old log soft graviton law, in the frame set out by Compère, Gralla and Wei. They use only Einstein's laws near far past, far future and far space, plus rules that link those zones. Their proof works the same if time runs back, and it lets soft waves come in too. If no soft memory comes in, the old factor comes back, its past future gap traced to a jump of the field at far space.

Catalog record

CREATORGianni Boschetti, Miguel Campiglia
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE115788
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.09844

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An asymptotic proof of the classical log soft graviton theorem Gianni Boschetti, Miguel Campiglia Abstract We present a derivation of the classical log soft graviton theorem within the asymptotic framework of Compère, Gralla, and Wei. The proof relies solely on Einstein equations near timelike, spatial, and null infinity, together with matching properties across these regions. The approach is fully covariant under time reversal and incorporates contributions from incoming soft radiation. In the absence of incoming memory one recovers the standard log soft factor, which features an asymmetry between future and past hard components. From an asymptotic perspective, the origin of this asymmetry lies in a long-known discontinuity of the gravitational field at spatial infinity. 1 Introduction In penrose Penrose introduced his celebrated conformal description of spacetime, partly motivated by “a longer term aim …for a covariant S-matrix theory incorporating gravitation”. This marked the beginning of what may be called an asymptotic approach to gravitational scattering, which avoids relying on the Minkowski background built into perturbative treatments. Traditionally, the successes of this approach were mostly kinematical, e.g. the characterization of asymptotic states and charges aaprl ; AS ; aajmp . Over the past decade it has become clear that the asymptotic perspective is specially suited for addressing dynamical questions within the soft sector of gravitational radiation stromgravscatt . In particular, a variety of soft theorems admit a natural formulation in terms of matching properties of the gravitational field across timelike, null and spatial infinity stromlectures . In this paper we deepen this viewpoint by presenting an asymptotic proof of the classical log soft graviton theorem laddhasen1 ; sahoosen ; proofdeq4 ; senreview . 1 1 1 See logwcl ; sayalicons ; sayaliqedgrav ; fuentelogscalar ; comperelogem ; bricenolog ; Duary:2025siq for related discussions in the context of electromagnetism and massless scalars. We build on and further develop the framework put forward by Compère, Gralla and Wei (CGW) cgw where the three types of infinities are treated on equal footing (see Figure 1 2 2 2 The diagrams in Figure 1 only intend to capture the exterior boundaries of spacetime, i.e. those associated to geodesics that escape to infinity. There can also be internal boundaries, notably in presence of black holes. In the asymptotic picture, black holes (or any other compact object) are registered as point-like sources at \mathcal{H}^{\pm} with multipolar moments appearing at subleading order in the large time expansion. We thank G. Compère for discussions on this point. ). We refer to hansen ; persides for earlier work in this direction and compererobert for a very recent treatment addressing similar aspects to those discussed here. Figure 1: Left: Penrose diagram of an asymptotically flat spacetime. Right: A “democratic” representations of null, timelike and spatial infinities. In both cases the null infinities \mathcal{I}^{\pm} are described by cylinders. The timelike \mathcal{H}^{\pm} and spatial \mathcal{H}^{0} infinities on the right diagram are hyperboloids parametrizing the directions of asymptotic geodesics at the points i^{\pm} and i^{0} on the left diagram. Although our contribution is limited to the soft sector, we are motivated by the hope that advancing the CGW framework may serve the longer-term aim of a fully covariant theory of gravitational scattering. This perspective is in line with recent efforts towards boundary descriptions of the S-matrix Kim:2023qbl ; Jain:2023fxc ; Kraus:2024gso ; Ammon:2025avo in the context of flat space holography (see raju ; Donnay:2023mrd ; Bagchi:2023cen and references therein). The plan of the paper is as follows. Section 2 provides some basic preliminaries that permeate our discussion, including notation and conventions. In section 3 we review the leading and log classical soft graviton theorems, extending the latter to the case where there is incoming soft gravitational radiation. Section 4 is a self-contained exposition of the main points of the CGW framework that we shall need for the asymptotic proof, along with several extensions, notably explicit Green’s functions solutions to the asymptotic metric coefficients at timelike and spatial infinities. The results of this analysis are put together in section 5 to provide a proof of the log soft theorem. The paper is supplemented with six appendices containing technical material. 2 Preliminaries 2.1 Asymptotic geodesics In asymptotic Cartesian coordinates, the general asymptotic form of geodesics that escape to infinity is X^{\mu}(s)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle|s|\to\infty}}{{=}}sV^{\mu}+\log|s|\,c^{\mu}(V)+O(s^{0}), (1) where s is an affine parameter and V^{\mu} the asymptotic direction. c^{\mu} captures the leading deviation from a straight line, which we refer to as log deviation vector . 3 3 3 In terms of asymptotic Christoffel symbols, c^{\mu}(V)=\lim_{|s|\to\infty}s^{2}\Gamma^{\mu}_{\nu\rho}(sV)V^{\nu}V^{\rho} . Our minimal assumption on asymptotic flatness is that this limit is well defined. This vector is intimately tied with logarithmic translations Bergmann:1961zz ; aalog , diffeomorphisms that have the asymptotic form \xi^{\mu}_{L}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle|s|\to\infty}}{{=}}\log|s|\,L^{\mu}+\cdots, (2) and that act on c^{\mu} according to \delta_{L}c^{\mu}=-L^{\mu}. (3) The possible asymptotic directions V^{\mu} fall into five categories: future/past null, future/past timelike and spacelike, corresponding to the five asymptotic boundaries pictured in the right panel of Figure 1 . For null rays, we parametrize the asymptotic directions by n^{\mu}=(1,\hat{n}), (4) where \hat{n} is a unit 3-vector. Eq. ( 1 ) then takes the form X^{\mu}(s)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle s\to\pm\infty}}{{=}}s\,n^{\mu}+\log|s|\,c^{\mu}_{\mathcal{I}^{\pm}}+O(s^{0})\quad\text{(null geodesics)}, (5) where incoming/outgoing null rays are distinguished by the sign of s . A key property of asymptotic null geodesics is that their log deviation vector c^{\mu}_{\mathcal{I}^{\pm}} is independent of the asymptotic direction sahoosen ; gianni1 . This allows one to “gauge it away” by a log translation, as expected by general results on the existence of radiative coordinates blanchetnull . In such (future/past) radiative log frame , the O(s^{0}) piece of ( 5 ) can be used to distinguish different arrival/departure times. By an appropriate choice of O(s^{0}) parametrization, Eq. ( 5 ) can be brought into the form X^{\mu}(s)\stackrel{{\scriptstyle s\to\pm\infty}}{{=}}s\,n^{\mu}+u\,t^{\mu}+\cdots\quad\text{(null geodesics in radiative log frame)}, (6) where t^{\mu}=(1,\vec{0}) , u is a retarded/advanced time and the dots refer to terms that vanish in the large s limit. The “endpoints” of such null geodesics, parametrized by (u,\hat{n}) , define the null infinities \mathcal{I}^{\pm} . For non-null geodesics, we normalize the asymptotic velocity such that s becomes a proper time/distance. The log deviation vector now exhibits a non-trivial dependance on the asymptotic velocity and cannot be gauged away. 4 4 4 This velocity-dependence is related to the non-smoothness of the Penrose metric at the points i^{0},i^{\pm} hansen . Eq. ( 1 ) then takes the form \displaystyle X^{\mu}(s) \displaystyle\stackrel{{\scriptstyle s\to\pm\infty}}{{=}} \displaystyle sV^{\mu}+\log|s|c^{\mu}_{\mathcal{H}^{\pm}}(V)+O(s^{0}),\quad V^{\mu}V_{\mu}=-1,\quad V^{0}>0, (7) \displaystyle X^{\mu}(s) \displaystyle\stackrel{{\scriptstyle s\to\infty}}{{=}} \displaystyle sV^{\mu}+\log|s|c^{\mu}_{\mathcal{H}^{0}}(V)+O(s^{0}),\quad V^{\mu}V_{\mu}=1, (8) for timelike/spacelike geodesics. Their corresponding “endpoints” are parametrized by the unit hyperboloids \mathcal{H}^{\pm} and \mathcal{H}^{0} . Note that, as in the null case, our conventions are such that V^{0}>0 for both incoming and outgoing timelike geodesics. In the following subsection we present the coordinates that we shall use on these “endpoints at infinity” spaces, see Table 1 for a summary. The extension of these coordinates into spacetime is discussed in section 4 . space coordinates infinity type \mathcal{I}^{\pm} (u,\phi^{A}) null \mathcal{H}^{\pm} (\rho,\phi^{A})=x^{a} timelike \mathcal{H}^{0} (\tau,\phi^{A})=x^{a} spatial Table 1: Coordinates at the five infinities. 2.2 Coordinate conventions All five infinities feature an angular direction. We denote by \phi^{A} the corresponding 2d coordinates. These specify the unit 3-vector \hat{n} and associated null direction n^{\mu} ( 4 ). The null infinities are therefore parametrized

Read the complete text