Ignorance with(out) Grasping
Ekaterina Kubyshkina, Mattia Petrolo · 2026
Read Ignorance with(out) Grasping by Ekaterina Kubyshkina, Mattia Petrolo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-09569.txt.
Introduction
Ekaterina Kubyshkina and Mattia Petrolo argue that ignorance is a hyperintensional notion, tied to content rather than truth alone. An agent may lack knowledge of one of two logically equal claims yet not the other. With topic-sensitive semantics they rework three logics for three forms of ignorance and prove each sound and complete. The frame also recasts logical omniscience: what matters is whether the agent grasps the content at stake.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ekaterina Kubyshkina, Mattia Petrolo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 93449 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.09569
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Ignorance with(out) Grasping Ekaterina Kubyshkina, Mattia Petrolo Abstract In this work, we argue that ignorance can be inherently understood as a hyperintensional notion. When faced with two logically or necessarily equivalent propositions, an agent may be ignorant of one while not of the other. To capture formally this intuition, we employ a topic-sensitive semantics, enabling the modeling of an agent’s attitude toward the content of a proposition. Within this framework, we reevaluate three existing logical systems, usually characterized by standard Kripke semantics, to account for three forms of ignorance: ignorance whether, ignorance as unknown truth, and disbelieving ignorance. For each form, we present a sound and complete system. To highlight the advantage of this approach, we apply it to address the problem of logical omniscience rephrased in terms of ignorance. The resulting framework considers an agent’s capacity to grasp the content of a proposition, bridging the gap between standard relational settings for ignorance representation and natural intuitions about the role of content in forming one’s ignorance. Keywords: Hyperintensionality; topic-sensitive semantics; ignorance whether; ignorance as unknown truth; disbelieving ignorance 1 Introduction Hyperintensional contexts, initially introduced by Cresswell 1975 to distinguish between necessarily equivalent contents, have, in recent decades, garnered significant attention in both logical and philosophical investigations. Several notions have been identified as hyperintensional to some extent: information, belief, knowledge, meaning, explanation (see, e.g., Fine 2017 , Leitgeb 2019 , Berto 2019 , Berto & Hawke 2021 ). Furthermore, Wansing 2017 argues that hoping, fearing, supposing, and imagining exhibit hyperintensional features. Building on this, Berto & Nolan 2023 advance the thesis that: “One may be led to the general conclusion that thought is hyperintensional.” A primary objective of the present work is to contribute new evidence to support this thesis by introducing a novel element to the plethora of hyperintensional notions: ignorance. From an epistemological standpoint, ignorance is usually conceived as a multi-layered notion. In contrast to knowledge and belief, often regarded as paradigmatic cases of hyperintensional notions, ignorance is commonly understood as a notion that manifests in various kinds or forms. For instance, Peels 2020 delineates six forms of (propositional) ignorance: disbelieving ignorance, suspending ignorance, undecided ignorance, unconsidered ignorance, deep ignorance, and complete ignorance. 1 1 1 We do not have to assume that these forms of ignorance are exhaustive. For our purposes here, it is sufficient to accept that ignorance is not a singular and monolithic notion. Let us focus our attention on complete ignorance, although unconsidered ignorance and deep ignorance could serve the same purpose. Peels 2020 characterizes complete ignorance as “ p is such that S cannot grasp or entertain p ,” where S is an epistemic subject and p a true proposition. Due to this form of ignorance, it has been argued that ignorance, in its full generality, cannot be viewed as a mental state. This stems from the fact that complete ignorance lacks at least one of the typical features attributed to mental states, namely the aspect of having an attitude towards a proposition (see Kubyshkina et Petrolo 2020 ). Furthermore, there exists a lack of consensus among epistemologists regarding the very definition of ignorance. The Standard View defines ignorance merely as not knowing (see, e.g., Le Morvan 2012 ), while the New View defines it as the absence of true belief (see, e.g., Peels 2012 ). A crucial distinction between these positions lies in the acceptance (Standard View) or rejection (New View) of false propositions as genuine instances of ignorance. As a consequence, the New View, in contrast to the Standard View, contends that ignorance must be factive, meaning that if an agent is ignorant of \phi , then \phi is true. Finally, from a logical standpoint, ignorance currently lacks a standard formalization with well-established semantic properties and systems, comparable to the formalizations for knowledge and belief. Over the last few decades, several frameworks formalizing different aspects of ignorance have emerged. Detailed presentations of some of these frameworks will be provided in the next section. For the moment, it is sufficient to note that the multi-layered nature of ignorance and the diverse intuitions surrounding it contribute to a profound disagreement concerning the very foundations of this elusive notion. The discussion on the epistemological and logical status of ignorance, as described, provides compelling evidence for the necessity of distinguishing this notion from other mental states usually analyzed in the literature on hyperintensional phenomena. Considering the substantial importance and ubiquity of ignorance, evident across scientific instances as well as in moral and social contexts, this constitutes one of the main motivations for pursueing a dedicated inquiry about the hyperintensionality of this notion. The plan is as follows. Section 2 introduces three formal frameworks for ignorance representation prevalent in the literature. Each of these frameworks introduces ignorance via a primitive modality, allowing one to model three kinds of ignorance: ignorance whether, ignorance as unknown truth, and disbelieving ignorance. In Section 3 , we explore the rationale behind treating ignorance as a hyperintensional notion and present the semantics employed to model hyperintensional ignorance. The main results are sound and complete axiomatizations for each kind of ignorance. In Section 4 , we tackle the problem of logical omniscience through the lens of ignorance, offering an application of our systems to address this problem. We conclude in Section 5 . 2 The formal representation of ignorance Recently, the formal representation of ignorance has attracted significant attention, not only in logic (see Steinsvold 2008 , Fan et al. 2015 ) and computer science (see van der Hoek & Lomuscio 2004 ), but also in formal epistemology (see Kubyshkina & Petrolo 2021 ). In this section we provide an overview of three logics in which ignorance is represented via a primitive modality. Specifically, we will consider ignorance whether , ignorance as unknown truth , and the formal counterpart of disbelieving ignorance . In this section, we utilize standard Kripke semantics, without modification to standard presentations. A frame is a pair (W,R) where W is a non-empty set of possible worlds, and R\subseteq W\times W is an accessibility relation. A model is a pair (\mathcal{F},v) where \mathcal{F} is frame and v:\texttt{Prop}\rightarrow\mathcal{P}(W) is a valuation function which assigns to each propositional variable in Prop a set of possible worlds. The first definition we consider is that of van der Hoek & Lomuscio 2004 , who take ignorance to be ‘not knowing whether’ (that is, ignorance whether). The authors consider an extension of classical propositional logic with a primitive operator I^{w} interpreted on Kripke models. The semantics is defined as follows. Definition 1 . Let \mathcal{M}=(W,R,v) , then 1. \mathcal{M},w\models p iff w\in v(p) ; 2. \mathcal{M},w\models\neg\phi iff \mathcal{M},w\not\models\phi ; 3. \mathcal{M},w\models\phi\wedge\psi iff \mathcal{M},w\models\phi and \mathcal{M},w\models\psi ; 4. \mathcal{M},w\models I^{w}\phi iff there exist w^{\prime},w^{\prime\prime}\in W such that Rww^{\prime} , Rww^{\prime\prime} , \mathcal{M},w^{\prime}\models\phi , and \mathcal{M},w^{\prime\prime}\models\neg\phi . The propositional operators ( \vee , \rightarrow , \leftrightarrow ) are defined standardly. Expressions of the form ‘ I^{w}\phi ’ are to be read as ‘the agent is ignorant whether \phi .’ Fan et al. 2015 show that this semantics characterizes the following system. 2 2 2 Technically, the authors provide the result for the noncontingency operator \triangle . As noted in [ Fan 2021 , p. 1295] ,