Intergenerational geometric transfers of income

Encarnación Algaba, Juan D. Moreno-Ternero, Eric Rémila, Philippe Solal · 2026

Read Intergenerational geometric transfers of income by Encarnación Algaba, Juan D. Moreno-Ternero, Eric Rémila, Philippe Solal (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-09280.txt.

Introduction

Encarnación Algaba and colleagues study how income might be shared across an endless stream of generations, each endowed with some income of its own. An allocation rule maps each income stream to another, in effect moving income between generations. They show that a family of geometric rules is singled out by axioms of consistency, continuity, and independence. Feasibility and scale invariance serve as the basic requirements behind that characterization.

Catalog record

CREATOREncarnación Algaba, Juan D. Moreno-Ternero, Eric Rémila, Philippe Solal
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52713
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.09280

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Intergenerational geometric transfers of income Thanks: The second author gratefully acknowledges grant PID2023-146364NB-I00, funded by MCIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and FSE+. This work is part of the R&D&I project grant PID2022-137211NB-I00, funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033/, the project “ERDF A way of making Europe/EU” and IMUS-MarÌa de Maeztu grant CEX2024-001517-M - Apoyo a Unidades de Excelencia MarÌa de Maeztu. Financial support from the Université Jean Monnet, Saint-Etienne, within the program “Mathématiques de la décision pour l’ingénierie physique et sociale” (MODMAD) is also acknowledged. Eric Rémila and Philippe Solal would like to thank the hospitality received during their stay in the Universidad de Sevilla (IMUS and Department of Applied Mathematics II). Encarnación Algaba, Juan D. Moreno-Ternero, Eric Rémila, Philippe Solal Abstract We study intergenerational transfers of income. In our stylized model, each generation in an infinite (but countable) stream is endowed with some income. An allocation rule associates with each infinite stream another stream, thus involving intergenerational transfers of income. We single out a family of geometric rules as a consequence of imposing axioms formalizing the principles of consistency, continuity and independence (as well as the basic requirements of feasibility and scale invariance). Key words : Intergenerational transfers, geometric rules, infinite streams, consistency, continuity. JEL classification : D63, D64, Q56 1 Introduction Economists, philosophers and social scientists alike have long been concerned with the issue of intergenerational equity. Koopmans (1960) and Diamond (1965) are the seminal contributions within the axiomatic literature on this issue. They both consider a stylized setting in which a social planner aims at ranking different (infinite but countable) streams of welfare, for a stream of generations. Diamond (1965) famously showed that impartiality cannot be combined with being sensitive to the interests of any single generation if the social preferences are required to be complete and continuous. Later contributions established related (and stronger) impossibility results (e.g., Asheim, 2010). Many hold the view that concepts of welfare across persons are incommensurate (e.g., Rawls, 1971; Moreno-Ternero and Roemer, 2008). If one accepts that view, or simply faces the absence of comparable information about preferences, then one should depart from the above framework to deal with a more fundamental resourcist framework in which each generation is associated with a level of resource (e.g., consumption, income, wealth) rather than welfare. 1 1 1 The term resourcist is borrowed from Roemer (1986). In such a setting, Epstein (1986) poses the dilemma that an economy has to choose between development and equity. Such a dilemma is resolved by Asheim (1991) for some domains of technologies, upon combining altruism with the exclusion of unjust allocations. In a more general multi-commodity framework, Piacquadio (2014) also highlights the conflict between distributional equity and the Pareto principle. In this paper, we focus on intergenerational transfers of income. That is, we also endorse a resourcist framework, in which we consider (infinite but countable) streams of income, for a stream of generations. In our framework, streams will be labelled according to the set of integer numbers \mathbb{Z} , instead of the set of non-negative integer numbers \mathbb{N} . That is, both the past and the future are unbounded. The aim is to design allocation rules that associate with each stream of income another stream of income, thus involving intergenerational transfers of income. Our approach will also be axiomatic and we shall single out a family of geometric rules as a result of combining various axioms formalizing principles with normative appeal. On the one hand, we shall consider two basic and standard operational axioms: feasibility (allocation rules cannot yield streams with a higher aggregate income than the original stream) and scale invariance (which implies that the units in which income is measured are irrelevant). On the other hand, we consider axioms formalizing the principles of independence, consistency and continuity. Independence of a future income states that changing the income of one generation does not affect the allocation of past generations. Consistency refers to the scenario in which the allocation is reevaluated in a given generation, assuming past generations have zero income (with the interpretation that they already “left” with their awards) and the present generation’s income is augmented with the residual income from past generations (the intergenerational transfers they gave), whereas the future generations keep their original incomes. The axiom states that the allocation for the present and future generations should not change in this new scenario. Finally, continuity is the standard notion formalizing that small changes in the original income stream can only produce small changes in the income stream the rule yields. Nevertheless, various continuity notions can be considered, depending on the norm at stake. In this case, we endorse the standard 1-norm (or taxicab norm). We shall also explore alternative continuity notions arising from the infinity norm and the point-wise norm. A side result of our analysis is that different continuity notions will have different implications, when combined with the rest of the axioms in our analysis. Our work is also connected to other strands of the axiomatic literature that have evolved recently. Income redistribution problems for finite generations were formally introduced by Ju et al. (2007), as an instance of their generalized claims problems. 2 2 2 Their model for income redistribution is thus similar to the taxation model studied by Young (1988), which reinterprets the seminal model to study the problem of adjudicating conflicting claims introduced by O’Neill (1982). They focus on the notion of reallocation-proofness (a group of agents cannot manipulate the outcome of the rule upon reallocating the incomes within the group) and show that this axiom, together with no transfer paradox (transferring some income before redistribution takes place does not increase income after redistribution) characterizes the family of income-tax schedules with a flat tax rate and personalized lump-sum transfers. Chambers and Moreno-Ternero (2021) studied the bilateral case of this model and showed that continuity , no transfer paradox and idempotency characterize a large family (dubbed threshold rules), that guarantee partial redistribution for unequal incomes. Martínez and Moreno-Ternero (2022) show that the combination of equal treatment of equals , additivity , and idempotency characterizes a pair of rules: full redistribution and laissez-faire (the counterpart of the no-transfer rule in our setting). Dismissing the latter axiom, one widens the scope to characterize a family of linear combinations between both rules. A similar family was characterized earlier by Casajus (2015), resorting to a monotonicity axiom instead of additivity . From a different vantage point, Hougaard et al. (2017) studied the problem of revenue allocation in a hierarchy. Therein, Hougaard et al. (2017) characterize (uniform) geometric rules by the combination of lowest rank consistency , highest rank revenue independence , highest rank splitting neutrality , and scale invariance . 3 3 3 Harless (2020) and Ju et al. (2024) present related results for the same model. Dietzenbacher and Kondratev (2023) and Kondratev et al. (2024) also characterize geometric rules in the related setting of prize allocation in competitions. The first axiom in the list, albeit similar, is different from the consistency axiom we use in this setting, as it is a variable-population axiom assuming that an agent in the hierarchy (the one at the bottom, a concept that cannot be defined in our setting) departs. Likewise, the second one in the list

Read the complete text