Experimental demonstration of optimal measurement for unambiguously discriminating asymmetric qudit states

Kang-Min Hu, Min Namkung, Myung-Hyun Sohn, Hyang-Tag Lim · 2026

Read Experimental demonstration of optimal measurement for unambiguously discriminating asymmetric qudit states by Kang-Min Hu, Min Namkung, Myung-Hyun Sohn, Hyang-Tag Lim (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-09026.txt.

Introduction

Kang-Min Hu and colleagues show the best way to tell asymmetric qudit states apart without error. Theory offers top-success measurements, but most demos cover equal-chance symmetric states since other methods resist lab use. Their projective test, tried with light states carrying orbital angular momentum in Laguerre-Gaussian modes, tells several asymmetric qudits apart for high-dimensional quantum information jobs.

Catalog record

CREATORKang-Min Hu, Min Namkung, Myung-Hyun Sohn, Hyang-Tag Lim
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43994
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.09026

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Experimental demonstration of optimal measurement for unambiguously discriminating asymmetric qudit states Kang-Min Hu, Min Namkung, Myung-Hyun Sohn, Hyang-Tag Lim Abstract Identification of nonorthogonal quantum states without error is crucial for various applications in quantum information technology, as well as the foundations of quantum physics. Theoretical studies have proposed measurements that maximize the success probability of unambiguously discriminating quantum states. However, these methods are not always experimentally feasible, which has led most demonstrations to focus on equiprobable symmetric states. Here, we establish a projective measurement scheme that optimally discriminates multiple asymmetric qudit states. We experimentally demonstrate this optimal projective measurement using a photonic orbital angular momentum state, where asymmetric qudit states are encoded in the Laguerre-Gaussian modes of a heralded single-photon state. Our results have broad applications in high-dimensional quantum state-based quantum information processing, including quantum key distribution and quantum sensing. I Introduction States of a quantum system are generally nonorthogonal, making it impossible for measurements to perfectly determine which state has been prepared. Instead, one can consider a measurement that identifies the prepared state with the maximum success probability allowed by quantum theory. From this perspective, quantum state discrimination is highly relevant to quantum foundations j.a.bergou ; j.a.bergou_text ; s.m.barnett . Useful strategies include minimum-error state discrimination (MESD) c.w.helstrom ; s.m.barnett_med ; j.bae ; d.ha_med ; d.ha_med2 , unambiguous state discrimination (USD) i.d.ivanovic ; d.dieks ; a.peres ; g.jaeger ; y.c.eldar ; m.a.jafarizadeh ; a.chefles ; a.chefles2 ; s.pang ; h.sugimoto ; j.a.bergou3 ; d.ha , maximal-confidence discrimination s.croke ; u.herzog ; u.herzog2 ; o.jiminez_mcd ; h.lee_mcd , error margin discrimination m.a.p.touzel_em ; a.hayashi_em ; h.sugimoto_em , and discrimination with a fixed rate of inconclusive outcomes a.chefles_frir ; c.-w.zhang_frir ; j.fiurasek_frir . Notably, USD holds great promise not only for rigorously interpreting quantum nature m.n.bera but also for advancing quantum information tasks, such as quantum communication c.h.bennett ; k.banaszek ; f.e.becerra , quantum random number generation j.b.brask ; h.tebyanian2 , and quantum sensing r.lecamwasam . The purpose of USD is to establish an unambiguous measurement that identifies quantum states without error. For geometrically symmetric states, it is possible to analytically determine an unambiguous measurement that maximizes the success probability of state discrimination a.chefles2 . However, quantum states are generally asymmetric. Therefore, the structure of unambiguous measurements must be extended to accommodate asymmetric states. Several works have theoretically proposed unambiguous measurements that optimally discriminate three asymmetric qutrit states h.sugimoto ; s.pang ; j.a.bergou3 ; d.ha . However, measurements implemented in experiments are often constrained by the limited structure of positive operator-valued measures (POVMs). In fact, experiments reported in several studies have primarily focused on discriminating a few symmetric states r.b.m.clarke ; o.jiminez ; m.a.solisprosser ; j.s.sidhu ; l.f.melo . This highlights the need to develop a measurement that performs optimal USD for asymmetric quantum states. Several works have proposed that POVMs for the USD are established by enlarging the state space and performing a projective measurement on the enlarged space p.-x.chen ; y.sun ; y.sun2 ; m.mohseni . Notably, a photonic system using an orbital angular momentum (OAM) state can proficiently implement projective measurements to discriminate symmetric states s.franke-arnold2 ; m.agnew ; s.goel , as it efficiently supports a high-dimensional space. This advantage suggests the possibility that the discussed scheme may also be applicable for optimally discriminating arbitrary asymmetric qudit states. Stressing the arbitrariness of qudit states and their prior probabilities is particularly important in practical quantum communication g.cariolaro . The proportions of dits constituting an entire message are typically non-uniform. It implies that, during the quantum communication, the prior probabilities of the encoded qudit states are not equal to each other. This perspective also affects the amount of information shared between a sender and a receiver, relevant to secret key rate of USD-based quantum communication m.namkung_q . Moreover, unequal prior probabilities of quantum states in a given ensemble can influence the nonclassicality of the described quantum system d.ha_nonl ; j.shin_cont , demonstrating interesting features of the quantum foundation c.h.bennett_nonl ; d.schmid_cont ; k.flatt_cont . In this work, we demonstrate the structure of projective measurements that are useful for optimally discriminating multiple asymmetric qudit states , experimentally implemented using an OAM state of a single-photon. Specifically, we show that a four-dimensional projective measurement can achieve optimal unambiguous discrimination among three asymmetric qutrit states. Beyond qutrit states, we extend the application of projective measurements to optimal USD for multiple asymmetric qudit states. It suggests that a generalized measurement for discriminating high-dimensional asymmetric qudit states is efficiently established using the projective measurement, thereby circumventing the aforementioned infeasible interaction. In our experimental realization, three qutrit states, encoded with Laguerre-Gaussian (LG) modes, are discriminated using a four-dimensional projective measurement implemented with a spatial light modulator (SLM). Our experiment successfully achieves the maximum success probability for USD, as predicted by theoretical evaluations. Figure 1: Concept of USD, where Alice prepares one of three qutrit states. The two angles \varphi and \theta in Alice’s quantum states are distinct, indicating asymmetry. Alice prepares a quantum state |\psi_{x}\rangle , and Bob performs a measurement \mathcal{M} to identify the prepared state. There are only two possible outcomes in USD. If the measurement outcome is conclusive ( y\not=? ) with a probability p_{\rm succ} , Bob can confidently determine that Alice prepared |\psi_{x}\rangle . Otherwise, with probability p_{\rm fail}=1-p_{\rm succ} , the measurement outcome provides no useful information. II Theory We begin by introducing the quantum state discrimination scenario. Consider that a quantum state |\psi_{x}\rangle is prepared from the set \{|\psi_{1}\rangle,\cdots,|\psi_{d}\rangle\} in a state space, with a prior probability q_{x} . To identify which state is prepared, a measurement represented by a POVM \{\hat{M}_{y}\}_{y\in\{1,\cdots,d\}\cup\{?\}} is performed. Here, \hat{M}_{y} is the element corresponding to the outcome y . If y\in\{1,\cdots,d\} is obtained with probability \langle\psi_{y}|\hat{M}_{y}|\psi_{y}\rangle , the measurement identifies the prepared state as |\psi_{y}\rangle . Otherwise, for an inconclusive outcome y=? , it is impossible to extract any information about the prepared state. In this scenario, the success probability of identifying the prepared state is given by P_{s}=\sum_{y=1}^{d}q_{y}\langle\psi_{y}|\hat{M}_{y}|\psi_{y}\rangle . The main goal of quantum state discrimination is to find an optimal POVM that maximizes the success probability. In USD, an unambiguous measurement, described by a POVM \big\{\hat{M}_{y}^{\rm(USD)}\big\}_{y\in\{1,\cdots,d\}\cup\{?\}} on the state space, is established such that \langle\psi_{x}|\hat{M}_{y\not=x}^{\rm(USD)}|\psi_{x}\rangle=0 . This condition implies that all conclusive outcomes (y\not=?) indicate |\psi_{x}\rangle without error (see Fig. 1 ). To satisfy this constraint, the operator \hat{M}_{y}^{\rm(USD)} , corresponding to a conclusive outcome, takes the form \hat{M}_{y}^{\rm(USD)}=\alpha_{y}|\widetilde{\psi}_{y}\rangle\langle\widetilde{\psi}_{y}| , where \alpha_{y}\in[0,1] and \langle\widetilde{\psi}_{y}|\psi_{x}\rangle=\delta_{xy} for all x,y\in\{1,\cdots,d\} s.pang ; h.sugimoto ; j.a.bergou3 ; d.ha . Subsequently, \hat{M}_{?}^{\rm(USD)} , corresponding to an inconclusive outcome, is given by \hat{M}_{?}^{\rm(USD)}=\hat{I}-\sum_{y=1}^{d}\hat{M}_{y}^{\rm(USD)} due to completeness condition. The requirement \hat{M}_{?}^{\rm(USD)}\geq 0 implies the inequality \mathrm{G}_{d}-\mathrm{diag}\left(\alpha_{1},\cdots,\alpha_{d}\right)\geq 0 , where \mathrm{G}_{d}=\left\{\langle\psi_{x}|\psi_{x^{\prime}}\rangle\right\}_{x,x^{\prime}=1}^{d} is the Gram matrix j.a.bergou ; s.pang ; d.ha . In other words, the unambiguous measurement corresponds to a real vector on a closed convex set: \displaystyle\mathcal{C}_{d}=\left\{\left(\alpha_{1},\cdots,\alpha_{d}\right):\mathrm{G}_{d}-\mathrm{diag}\left(\alpha_{1},\cdots,\alpha_{d}\right)\geq 0\right\}. Due to this convexity, an optimal measurement can be represented as the tangential point between the convex set and the hyperplane of success probability P_{s}=\sum_{y=1}^{d}q_{y}\alpha_{y} . The realization of the optimal POVM generally requires an interaction between the state to be measured and an ancillary state m.a.neumark . However, such interactions can be challenging to implement in optical systems p.kok

Read the complete text