Magnetic landscape of NbTiN superconducting resonators under radio-frequency excitation
J. Baumgarten, N. Lejeune, L. Nulens, I. P. C. Cools, J. Van de Vondel, A. V. Silhanek · 2026
Read Magnetic landscape of NbTiN superconducting resonators under radio-frequency excitation by J. Baumgarten, N. Lejeune, L. Nulens, I. P. C. Cools, J. Van de Vondel, A. V. Silhanek (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-08500.txt.
Introduction
Baumgarten and colleagues film magnetic flux breaking into a thin superconducting film while radio waves drive it. At cold settings, sudden flux bursts can sap energy from quantum circuits and sensors, and it was unclear whether the drive itself sparks them. Their images show burst rates barely move with drive strength, yet each burst shifts the pitch at its own site.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J. Baumgarten, N. Lejeune, L. Nulens, I. P. C. Cools, J. Van de Vondel, A. V. Silhanek |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47170 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.08500
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Magnetic landscape of NbTiN superconducting resonators under radio-frequency excitation J. Baumgarten, N. Lejeune, L. Nulens, I. P. C. Cools, J. Van de Vondel, A. V. Silhanek Abstract Planar superconducting resonators are essential components in quantum circuits and highly sensitive sensors. However, their performance is often compromised by magnetic flux penetration, as the interaction of flux quanta and the induced radio-frequency (RF) currents in the superconducting thin film leads to significant energy dissipation. At low operating temperatures, this issue is aggravated as thermomagnetic instabilities can trigger the sudden propagation of magnetic flux avalanches. An important open question is whether the RF excitation itself stimulates the nucleation and propagation of magnetic flux avalanches in the superconducting thin film. The literature remains inconclusive on this point, partly due to the lack of compelling evidence for this phenomenon. In this work, we address this issue by unprecedented direct visualization of magnetic flux penetration through Faraday rotation imaging under simultaneous RF excitation. We demonstrate that the avalanche activity exhibits a weak dependence on the RF intensity for RF excitations within the linear Campbell regime. However, magnetic flux bursts clearly influence the RF transmission properties of the device. Furthermore, it is possible to unambiguously associate a particular avalanche event with a jump in resonance frequency. This enables us to identify the loci of most deleterious events and understand the distinct origins of upward and downward frequency shifts. These observations are supported by electromagnetic simulations in which local changes of the kinetic inductance mimic flux avalanches and confirm the invasive character of the MOI technique. The insights gained from this study aim to contribute to the broader understanding of the magnetic resilience of superconducting resonators, with the goal of improving their efficiency and stability. I Introduction Planar superconducting resonators operating at radio frequencies have driven major advances in a wide range of applications, including quantum sensing and detection 20 ; 64 , quantum computing 68 ; 44 , and information processing 6 ; 34 . Their unique advantage stems from the superconducting properties of the materials composing these resonators, notably their zero electrical resistance. The aforementioned applications require low energy losses in the system, characterized by high quality factors (Q), which is the ratio between the average stored magnetic energy and the dissipated energy. Indeed, superconducting resonators have been known to reach quality factors up to nearly 10 8 , several orders of magnitude higher than their metal counterparts 64 . To achieve such performances, it is crucial that the superconducting resonator remains free of superconducting vortices, as their motion leads to significant energy dissipation and consequently deteriorates the quality factor 60 . Although magnetic screening methods can be used to mitigate this problem, some applications require exposure to an external magnetic field 71 , such as certain qubit implementation schemes like spin ensembles in solid-state systems 38 , phase-slip qubits 3 , trapped electrons 13 , and many others 65 ; 70 ; 23 ; 31 . In addition, even though planar superconducting resonators are resilient to in-plane magnetic fields 36 , unwanted small in-plane misalignments can give rise to out-of-plane magnetic field components that can severely affect their performance. Generally, minimizing vortex-induced losses implies pinning them in order to prevent their motion. Another approach is to decrease the number of vortices in regions of high RF current amplitude and/or magnetic fields. Multiple studies explored the first approach, by introducing artificial pinning sites 8 ; 59 ; 48 . An alternative method involves modifying the ground plane, with studies showing that reducing its size 9 ; 17 or segmenting it into fractal structures 27 can effectively alleviate demagnetization effects (flux focusing) and minimize field penetration. While the strategies based on increasing vortex pinning can help reduce vortex-induced losses at temperatures not too far from the superconducting transition T_{c} , at temperatures below \sim T_{c}/2 , they may favor localized thermomagnetic instabilities 46 . These instabilities can trigger flux avalanches, which involve the rapid nucleation and propagation of magnetic flux into the superconducting material 67 , leading to performance degradation in superconducting resonators. Indeed, these flux avalanches have a significant impact on the resonators, introducing stochastic and unpredictable behavior that manifests as fluctuations in the resonance frequency as a function of the applied magnetic field 50 . Technologically relevant resonators based on conventional superconductors are particularly susceptible to these events, whereas flux avalanches are seldom detected in hight temperature superconductors 66 ; 52 ; 42 . Surprisingly, despite extensive research on the properties and behavior of superconducting resonators, the specific role of RF excitation in nucleating flux avalanches remains largely unexplored. There have been experimental studies suggesting that RF excitation does promote flux avalanches 25 ; 24 ; 4 ; 18 , while others report a suppression of magnetic flux avalanches for probing frequencies nearing the depinning frequencies 41 . From a theoretical standpoint, the information on the matter is also scarce. Numerical simulations have been used to investigate the effect of a uniform AC magnetic field of relatively low frequency (a few MHz) and show that the AC excitation reduces the threshold field for the onset of flux avalanches 33 . It should also be pointed out that experimental evidence 72 and theoretical predictions 28 indicate that at temperatures close to the critical one, the first-vortex penetration field for RF magnetic fields is somewhat larger than for DC fields. This could be beneficial to keep vortex penetration at bay. However, it is expected that this difference becomes less pronounced at low temperatures (see 54 ; 69 and references therein). The aim of this work is to provide further insights into the correlation and possible causation relation between RF excitations and magnetic flux avalanches in superconducting resonators. To this end, radio-frequency transmission measurements are combined with widefield magneto-optical imaging, allowing, on the one hand, for simultaneous and direct association of the nucleation and propagation of flux avalanches and their impact on the resonance frequency. On the other hand, we investigate if the presence of localized RF excitation influences the statistical distribution of the size and occurrence rate of magnetic flux avalanches. We demonstrate that the required concomitant radio-frequency measurements and magneto-optical imaging are a challenging feat, as the presence of the magnetic indicator significantly impacts the response of the resonator. We establish a clear correspondence between individual avalanche events and discrete shifts in resonance frequency, enabling the spatial mapping of the most deleterious occurrences and clarifying the distinct origins of upward and downward frequency shifts. Electromagnetic simulations, in which localized variations of the kinetic inductance emulate flux avalanches, reproduce these effects and help to underscore the invasive nature of the MOI technique. Together, these results establish a direct link between magnetic flux avalanches and resonance behavior in superconducting resonators, highlight the location of the most deleterious events, and inform future approaches for enhancing their stability and performance. II Experimental Methods II.1 Sample fabrication The resonators used in this work were fabricated either on double-side polished C-plane \mathrm{Al_{2}O_{3}} wafers of thickness 430 µm or on 525 µm-thick undoped Si. A 100 nm thick NbTiN film was deposited by sputtering from a \mathrm{Nb_{81.9}Ti_{18.1}N} target in a near UHV environment, with in-situ annealing at 660°C. The coplanar waveguide resonators were