Sign Identifiability of Causal Effects in Stationary Stochastic Dynamical Systems

Gijs van Seeventer, Saber Salehkaleybar · 2026

Read Sign Identifiability of Causal Effects in Stationary Stochastic Dynamical Systems by Gijs van Seeventer, Saber Salehkaleybar (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-08311.txt.

Introduction

van Seeventer and colleagues study sign identifiability of causal effects in steady stochastic systems. They examine the same question in ongoing linear equations with a known causal structure. Unlike older approaches, they drop the assumption of a known diffusion matrix, keeping the model's built-in scale invariance. Rather than recovering drift coefficients, they introduce the edge-sign question. It asks whether the sign of a given drift entry is fixed across all seen covariance matrices induced by parametrisations fitting that structure.

Catalog record

CREATORGijs van Seeventer, Saber Salehkaleybar
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE107430
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY SA
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.08311

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sign Identifiability of Causal Effects in Stationary Stochastic Dynamical Systems Gijs van Seeventer, Saber Salehkaleybar Abstract We study identifiability in continuous-time linear stationary stochastic differential equations with known causal structure. Unlike existing approaches, we relax the assumption of a known diffusion matrix, thereby respecting the model’s intrinsic scale invariance. Rather than recovering drift coefficients themselves, we introduce edge-sign identifiability: for a given causal structure, we ask whether the sign of a given drift entry is uniquely determined across all observational covariance matrices induced by parametrizations compatible with that structure. Under a notion of faithfulness, we derive criteria for characterising identifiability, non-identifiability, and partial identifiability for general graphs. Applying our criteria to specific causal structures, both analogous to classical causal settings (e.g., instrumental variables) and novel cyclic settings, we determine their edge-sign identifiability and, in some cases, obtain explicit expressions for the sign of a target edge in terms of the observational covariance matrix. 1 Introduction Learning dynamical systems from observational data via parametrized models is central across scientific domains, from systems biology [ Marbach et al. 2012 ] to economics [ Hamilton 2020 ] . The aim of such modelling is often to answer a causal question: what happens to a target variable Y if we intervene on a variable X ? Recently, causal modelling of stationary diffusions has emerged to address settings in which full time trajectories are unavailable or unobservable [ Fitch 2019 , Lorch et al. 2024 ] . In such cases, observations can be viewed as samples collected from a stationary process. These processes are often described by stationary stochastic differential equations (SDEs) [ Øksendal 2003 ] . While stationary SDEs induce time-invariant observational distributions, they internally encode temporal causal dependencies, allowing for a natural causal interpretation [ Lorch et al. 2024 , Améndola et al. 2025 ] . This interpretation admits a graphical representation analogous to structural causal models (SCMs) [ Sokol and Hansen 2014 , Pearl 2009 ] . Unlike acyclic SCMs, graphical models induced by stationary SDEs naturally allow for cycles and self-loops, features ubiquitous in real-world dynamical systems. The literature studies causal SDE models under various assumptions (see Section 3 ). We focus on continuous-time, linear, time-homogeneous stationary SDEs, i.e., the stationary Ornstein-Uhlenbeck (OU) process. We assume that the causal structure, namely, which variables directly affect others, is known. Given a fixed causal structure, a central question is identifiability, i.e., whether the value of a causal effect (or a property of it, such as its sign) can be determined from the observational distribution. Our main contributions are as follows: • Sign identifiability. Existing notions of identifiability for OU processes assume a known causal structure and a fixed part of the model parameters, specifically the diffusion matrix. Since the OU process is invariant under positive rescaling, fixing the diffusion matrix imposes a strong restriction (see Section 2.1.1 ). Respecting this scale invariance, we introduce a notion of edge-sign identifiability (see Section 2.2 ), focusing on the sign rather than the magnitude of a causal effect. Sign identifiability requires only that the causal structure be known, thereby relaxing the assumption that the diffusion matrix is known. • Categories of sign identifiability. Our analysis distinguishes three cases: identifiability, non-identifiability, and partial identifiability. We also show that in the confounding structure, the sign of the causal effect is partially identifiable with positive measure (for more details, see Section 4.1 ). Moreover, numerical experiments in Section 5 suggest that partial identifiability constitutes a genuine intermediate regime between identifiability and non-identifiability. • General criteria and applications to specific structures. We derive general criteria for edge-sign identifiability and apply them to specific graph structures in Section 4 . General criteria include, for instance, a graphical criterion for determining whether an edge is identifiable. We apply the general criteria in some special graph structures, including causal structures analogous to bivariate cause–effect and instrumental variable settings, for which we obtain an explicit expression for the sign of the causal effect in terms of the covariance matrix. 2 Preliminaries and Problem Setup 2.1 Background and Notation We denote random vectors in \mathbb{R}^{d} as X\in\mathbb{R}^{d} . Its i th entry is X_{i}\in\mathbb{R} for i\in\{1,\dots,d\} . In addition, we denote the set of positive definite matrices as PD_{d} and the set of positive definite diagonal matrices as PDD_{d} , where d is the dimension. Note that PDD_{d}\subset PD_{d} . 2.1.1 Stochastic Differential Equations Stochastic differential equations (SDEs) describe stochastic processes \{X(t)\},X(t)\in\mathbb{R}^{d} , which is a collection of random vectors X(t) for a time t . We will consider continuous stationary processes, which means that the probability density f_{t}\big(X(t)\big) is the same for all considered times, i.e., f_{t}\big(X(t)\big)=f_{t^{\prime}}\big(X(t^{\prime})\big) with t,t^{\prime}\geq 0 . A general SDE has the form dX(t)=g(X(t),t)dt+h(X(t),t)d\beta(t) , where g:\mathbb{R}^{d}\times\mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}\rightarrow\mathbb{R}^{d} is the drift function, h:\mathbb{R}^{d}\times\mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}\rightarrow\mathbb{R}^{d\times d} is the diffusion function and \beta is a random noise term. We consider linear, time-homogeneous SDEs driven by a Wiener process, i.e., SDEs with linear, time-invariant drift and diffusion functions and Gaussian noise. We will assume the commonly used It\hat{o} interpretation, which is a choice in what it means to integrate a random noise term [ Øksendal 2003 ] . The only non-trivial continuous stationary, linear and time-homogenous SDE is known as the multivariate Ornstein-Uhlenbeck (OU) process [ Doob 1942 ] . 1 1 1 Note that the OU process only becomes stable for large times. Therefore we consider times t\in[0,\infty) where we shifted our initial time to zero by T , and T is large enough to fulfil the stationarity condition. The OU process is described by dX(t)=\Big(AX(t)-b\Big)dt+CdW(t), (1) where A\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times d} is the drift matrix, b\in R^{d} is a constant vector, C\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times d} is the diffusion matrix and W(t) is the d -dimensional Wiener process at time t . Due to being a Wiener process, the OU process is characterised by the first two moments, i.e., the mean m(t) and the covariance matrix \Sigma(t) . Since we consider a stochastic stationary process, \frac{d}{dt}m(t)=0 and \frac{d}{dt}\Sigma(t)=0 . Therefore the mean m=b and every entry of the covariance matrix \Sigma_{ij}=\mathbb{E}\big[(X_{i}(t)-m)(X_{j}(t)-m)\big] . Without loss in generality, we take the mean m=0 such that X(t)\sim\mathcal{N}(0,\Sigma) . Moreover, the stationarity condition \frac{d}{dt}\Sigma=0 is equivalent to the Lyapunov equation A\Sigma+\Sigma A^{T}=-D, (2) where D=CC^{T} [ Särkkä and Solin 2019 ] . In addition, stationarity requires the drift matrix A to be Hurwitz stable, i.e., the real part of the eigenvalues of A needs to be negative. Note that, given D\in PD_{d} , we have that A is Hurwitz stable in the Lyapunov equation (Eq. ( 2 )) if and only if \Sigma\in PD_{d} (Theorem 1.1 from [ Frommer and Hashemi 2012 ] ). Furthermore, if we choose an uncorrelated noise setting with C being diagonal, we will always have D\in PDD_{d}\subset PD_{d} . If we have correlated noise, C is no longer diagonal and it needs to be verified that D\in PD_{d} . Unless otherwise noted, we will assume D\in PDD_{d} A Wiener process W is scale invariant, i.e., W(t)=W(at)/\sqrt{a} for a\in\mathbb{R}_{+} . Furthermore, given that we are considering a stationary process, we have that two times t,at\in[0,\infty) are indistinguishable in the sense that X(t)=X(at) . This means that we can always rescale our OU process with \sqrt{a} to

Read the complete text