Evidence - Driven Reasoning for Industrial Maintenance Using Heterogeneous Data

Fearghal O’Donncha, Nianjun Zhou, Natalia Martinez, James T Rayfield, Fenno F. Heath III, Abigail Langbridge, Roman Vaculin · 2026

Read Evidence - Driven Reasoning for Industrial Maintenance Using Heterogeneous Data by Fearghal O’Donncha, Nianjun Zhou, Natalia Martinez, James T Rayfield, Fenno F. Heath III, Abigail Langbridge, Roman Vaculin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-08171.txt.

Introduction

O'Donncha and colleagues present Condition Insight Agent, a deployed decision-support system for industrial maintenance. These systems hold rich but scattered evidence: free-text work orders, mixed sensor readings, and structured failure knowledge. Alone, these sources yield alerts that cannot answer the key question: given this asset's history and behavior, what is happening and what action is warranted? The system joins upkeep language, behavior patterns from sensor data, and engineering failure knowledge, then checks conclusions with a rule-based check loop.

Catalog record

CREATORFearghal O’Donncha, Nianjun Zhou, Natalia Martinez, James T Rayfield, Fenno F. Heath III, Abigail Langbridge, Roman Vaculin
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48756
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.08171

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evidence - Driven Reasoning for Industrial Maintenance Using Heterogeneous Data Fearghal O’Donncha, Nianjun Zhou, Natalia Martinez, James T Rayfield, Fenno F. Heath III, Abigail Langbridge, Roman Vaculin Abstract Industrial maintenance platforms contain rich but fragmented evidence, including free-text work orders, heterogeneous operational sensors or indicators, and structured failure knowledge. These sources are often analyzed in isolation, producing alerts or forecasts that do not support conditional decision-making: given this asset history and behavior, what is happening and what action is warranted? We present Condition Insight Agent, a deployed decision-support framework that integrates maintenance language, behavioral abstractions of operational data, and engineering failure semantics to produce evidence-grounded explanations and advisory actions. The system constrains reasoning through deterministic evidence construction and structured failure knowledge, and applies a rule-based verification loop to suppress unsupported conclusions. Case studies from production CMMS deployments show that this verification-first design operates reliably under heterogeneous and incomplete data while preserving human oversight. Our results demonstrate how constrained LLM-based reasoning can function as a governed decision-support layer for industrial maintenance. Keywords Industrial AI \cdot Physical AI \cdot Agentic AI \cdot Evidence - grounded reasoning \cdot Industrial maintenance \cdot Decision support systems \cdot Constrained language models 1 Introduction Enterprise asset-intensive organizations rely on condition-based maintenance to reduce downtime and manage operational risk. Computerized Maintenance Management Systems (CMMS) aggregate health scores, alerts, work orders, and operational indicators, but rarely support the conditional reasoning required for maintenance decisions. In practice, decisions depend on reasoning across multiple forms of evidence: given a change in behavior, which failure hypotheses are plausible, which align with maintenance history, and what action is appropriate? Existing systems fall short because evidence remains fragmented across meters, work orders, and engineering knowledge, while relationships between operational signals and asset models are often uncertain. Practitioners must manually reconcile these sources under time pressure reliant on expert judgment. This challenge is compounded by industrial data realities: operational indicators originate from heterogeneous IoT and SCADA (Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition) platforms with inconsistent naming and limited shared ontology; maintenance history is largely unstructured text; and engineering artifacts such as Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) are rarely integrated into data-driven workflows. Supporting maintenance reasoning therefore requires controlled reasoning over heterogeneous, partially structured, and semantically uncertain evidence. Large language models (LLMs) offer flexible reasoning, but naively applying generative models in reliability-critical settings introduces risks. Unconstrained agents may hallucinate explanations or produce fluent but unsupported recommendations. In industrial maintenance, trust depends on traceability, engineering consistency, and explicit linkage between claims and evidence. We present Condition Insight , a deployed reasoning framework that combines deterministic evidence construction with constrained LLM-based synthesis. Meter histories are abstracted into behavioral summaries, work orders into maintenance patterns, and FMEA-derived semantics bound the space of admissible explanations. The system is integrated into enterprise CMMS workflows and evaluated across large asset portfolios. Our solution and contributions for this paper are: • We define Conditional Insight as a deployed decision-support task connecting operational indicators, maintenance history, and engineering failure knowledge into evidence-grounded explanations. • We introduce a trajectory-controlled architecture separating deterministic evidence extraction from constrained LLM synthesis governed by failure semantics. • We introduce a deterministic verification loop that cross-checks LLM outputs against operational rules and structured evidence, ensuring auditable decision elements. • We demonstrate how this verification-first design improves traceability and hallucination resistance compared to unconstrained LLM pipelines. • We report deployment lessons from enterprise CMMS environments with heterogeneous IoT data and sparse ontology support. Beyond this application, our results illustrate how constrained, evidence-grounded LLM reasoning can be operationalized in reliability-critical environments where explanations must remain auditable. 2 Related Work Data-Driven and Knowledge-Driven Maintenance. Condition-based and predictive maintenance research has focused on anomaly detection, fault diagnosis, and remaining useful life estimation from sensor data 4 ; 10 ; 16 . These approaches typically produce alerts or forecasts rather than integrated explanations that connect observed behavior to maintenance history and engineering failure semantics. In parallel, knowledge-driven methods employ rule-based systems, ontologies, digital twins, and FMEA to encode asset structure and causal failure knowledge 12 ; 8 . While interpretable, such approaches often depend on comprehensive ontologies and consistent data alignment, which are difficult to sustain in enterprise environments with heterogeneous assets and evolving data schemas 14 ; 2 . LLMs, Agents, and Constrained Generation. Large language models (LLMs) enable multi-step reasoning through retrieval-augmented generation and tool-augmented agents 3 ; 11 ; 19 . These capabilities have motivated applications in industrial operations, including agentic anomaly detection and asset-oriented benchmarks 15 ; 17 ; 7 . However, many agentic systems prioritize autonomy over constraint, which poses risks in reliability-critical settings 1 ; 6 . Recent work on reliable generation introduces verification loops, self-refinement, human-in-the-loop evaluation, and LLM-based judging to improve grounding and reduce hallucination 13 ; 20 ; 18 ; 9 . Our work extends this line by demonstrating a deployed reasoning framework in which deterministic evidence construction and rule-based governance explicitly bound LLM synthesis under real-world maintenance constraints. 3 Problem Setting and Task We study conditional reasoning for maintenance decision support in an enterprise CMMS deployment spanning multiple asset classes. Rather than prediction, the objective is decision-ready interpretation of asset condition under heterogeneous and imperfect evidence. Condition Insight Task Given maintenance evidence (historical work orders, asset-level operational indicators, and structured failure knowledge) the task is to generate an interpretable explanation of an asset’s current or emerging condition together with appropriate maintenance recommendations. The output is an evidence-grounded narrative linking observed behavior to maintenance history and plausible failure mechanisms. Evidence Sources The system operates over three complementary but weakly aligned evidence types: • Work orders document past symptoms, diagnoses, and interventions in largely unstructured text, capturing experiential maintenance knowledge. • Operational indicators (“meters”) are low-frequency, curated measurements (e.g., runtime, periodic readings, discrete states) whose meaning arises from temporal patterns and whose semantics vary across cumulative, incremental, and categorical forms. • Failure knowledge is represented using Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA), linking asset components to plausible failure mechanisms and influencing factors that constrain admissible explanations. Integration Constraints In practice, these sources are not natively aligned. Operational indicators originate from heterogeneous IoT and SCADA systems with inconsistent naming and limited shared ontology, and mappings between telemetry points and CMMS assets or components are often partial or ambiguous. Consequently, schema-level integration is unreliable and rule-based reasoning over raw signals is brittle. Conditional reasoning must therefore operate on abstracted behavioral evidence rather than authoritative semantic mappings while tolerating incomplete context and uncertain data relationships. 4 Condition Insight Framework The Condition Insight system separates deterministic evidence construction from constrained LLM reasoning. This separation reflects a key deployment requirement: explanations must remain traceable to operational evidence and consistent with engineering knowledge, even when underlying data is heterogeneous or incomplete. Figure 1 illustrates the pipeline. Heterogeneous asset data (including work orders, operational indicators, and failure knowledge) are first transformed into a structured evidence representation. A domain LLM agent then performs constrained synthesis over this evidence, followed by a verification stage that governs key decision elements. 4.1 Overview of Reasoning Pipeline The system operates in two stages: • Analytics and Evidence Construction produces a structured evidence packet ( asset_facts ) summarizing asset behavior, maintenance history, and failure semantics. • Constrained LLM Reasoning generates

Read the complete text