Lepton Mixing from a Lattice Flavon Model: A Two-Branch Octant– δ \delta Prediction
Vernon Barger · 2026
Read Lepton Mixing from a Lattice Flavon Model: A Two-Branch Octant– δ \delta Prediction by Vernon Barger (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-06934.txt.
Introduction
Barger carries a single-flavon lattice model from quarks into leptons. The model explained quark masses and mixing; its power structure now gives charged-lepton masses and normal ordering. Neutrino mixing needs broken mu-tau reflection symmetry, yielding a nonzero reactor angle and CP phase. The PMNS matrix splits into neutrino and charged-lepton parts, with phases aligned by the single-flavon origin. One interference link ties the Dirac phase to the neutrino phase plus a charged-lepton correction, and ties the correction sign to the octant, giving two branches.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Vernon Barger |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57487 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.06934
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Lepton Mixing from a Lattice Flavon Model: A Two-Branch Octant– δ \delta Prediction Vernon Barger Abstract We extend the single-flavon B B -lattice Froggatt–Nielsen (FN) framework—previously successful for quark masses and Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) mixing—to the lepton sector. The same B B -lattice power structure ( ϵ ≡ 1 / B ≃ 0.19 \epsilon\equiv 1/B\simeq 0.19 ) generates charged-lepton mass hierarchies and a normal-ordered neutrino spectrum; large neutrino mixing angles require an additional approximate mu–tau symmetry, broken at 𝒪 ( ϵ ) \mathcal{O}(\epsilon) to generate a nonzero reactor angle and CP-violating phase. The Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata (PMNS) matrix factorizes as U PMNS = U e † U ν U_{\rm PMNS}=U_{e}^{\dagger}U_{\nu} , with near-tribimaximal U ν U_{\nu} corrected by small charged-lepton rotations whose phases are naturally aligned by the single-flavon origin of the Yukawa textures. This alignment produces a two-branch prediction in the ( θ 23 , δ ) (\theta_{23},\delta) plane: a lower-octant solution with θ 23 ≈ 43 ∘ \theta_{23}\approx 43^{\circ} , δ ≈ 286 ∘ \delta\approx 286^{\circ} , and an upper-octant solution with θ 23 ≈ 46 ∘ \theta_{23}\approx 46^{\circ} , δ ≈ 304 ∘ \delta\approx 304^{\circ} . The lower octant is favored by a ∼ 4 : 1 \sim\!4{:}1 theoretical prior. The Jarlskog invariant J CP ≃ − 0.027 J_{\rm CP}\simeq-0.027 is nearly branch-independent; only precision measurements of the atmospheric octant and Dirac phase at DUNE, Hyper-Kamiokande, IceCube, and JUNO can distinguish the two solutions. I Introduction Single- B lattice textures Y_{e}\sim\epsilon^{p^{e}} , m_{\nu}\sim\epsilon^{p^{\nu}} ( \epsilon=1/B , B -lattice power counting) Diagonalize U_{e}^{\dagger}Y_{e}U_{e}=Y_{e}^{\rm diag} U_{\nu}^{T}m_{\nu}U_{\nu}=m_{\nu}^{\rm diag} U_{\mathrm{PMNS}}=U_{e}^{\dagger}U_{\nu} (neutrino-dominant U_{\nu} + small U_{e} ) Interference in U_{e3} U_{e3}\simeq s_{13}^{\nu}e^{-i\delta_{\nu}}-\theta_{12}^{e}s_{23}^{\nu}e^{i\phi_{12}^{e}} Prediction: octant– \delta correlation two branches in (\theta_{23},\delta) selected by the same phase controlling U_{e3} Figure 1: Schematic logic of the single- B lattice-flavon lepton analysis. Neutrino-dominant mixing corrected by B -lattice charged-lepton rotations produces an interference-controlled reactor element U_{e3} , implying a predictive two-branch octant– \delta structure. The Froggatt–Nielsen mechanism Froggatt:1978nt ; Leurer1992 ; Leurer1993 offers a natural framework for addressing fermion mass hierarchies through a single expansion parameter. In this work we develop the lepton sector of the lattice-flavon (“ninths”) implementation Barger2025bfn ; Barger2025bfnb ; LatticeFlavonQuarkMixing , in which fermion mass matrices are organized by powers of \epsilon=1/B , with B=75/14 . The same single- B structure that successfully accounts for quark masses and CKM mixing Cabibbo ; KobayashiMaskawa is applied here to charged leptons and neutrinos, supplemented in the neutrino sector by an approximate mu–tau symmetry that produces the large atmospheric and solar angles. The observed pattern of lepton mixing—large solar and atmospheric angles together with a comparatively small but nonzero reactor angle and a sizable Dirac CP phase NuFIT60 —provides a rich testing ground for this framework. Lepton mixing factorizes as Pontecorvo ; MNS U_{\rm PMNS}=U_{e}^{\dagger}U_{\nu}, (1) so that the observed angles and phases arise from controlled interference between neutrino-dominant mixing and small charged-lepton rotations fixed by B -lattice power counting. This structure leads to a predictive linkage: the same interference that generates U_{e3} correlates the atmospheric-octant selection with the displacement of the Dirac phase \delta (Fig. 1 ). We derive analytic diagonalization formulas, perform representative coefficient scans consistent with NuFIT 6.0 NuFIT60 normal ordering, and present a compact analytic relation encoding the two-branch octant– \delta structure. The resulting correlation provides a sharp and experimentally testable signature of the single- B lattice-flavon organizing principle at DUNE DUNE , Hyper-Kamiokande HyperK , IceCube IceCube , and JUNO JUNO . II Flavon Lattice and Messenger Framework The flavor structure is generated by a single Froggatt–Nielsen flavon field Froggatt:1978nt ; Leurer1992 ; Leurer1993 \Phi with \langle\Phi\rangle/\Lambda=1/B\equiv\epsilon . Effective Yukawa operators arise from integrating out heavy vectorlike messenger chains, producing suppression factors of the form Y_{ij}\sim c_{ij}\,\epsilon^{\,p_{ij}}\,e^{i\phi_{ij}}, (2) where p_{ij} are rational lattice exponents determined by messenger insertions, c_{ij}=\mathcal{O}(1) coefficients, and \phi_{ij} are physical phases. Exponent Structure In the charged-lepton sector, the additive charge rule p^{e}_{ij}=p^{e}_{L_{i}}+p^{e}_{R_{j}} (3) generates hierarchical masses controlled by the lattice exponents, with the specific charge assignments detailed in Sec. IV . The neutrino mass matrix (for normal ordering) follows m_{1}:m_{2}:m_{3}\sim B^{-2}:B^{-1}:1. (4) Phase Structure Physical CP violation arises from relative phases between entries. After field redefinitions removing unphysical phases, the remaining Dirac phase appears through interference of left-handed rotations: U_{\rm PMNS}=U_{e}^{\dagger}U_{\nu}. (5) In the Fritzsch–Xing (FX) convention Fritzsch adopted here for the lepton sector, the Dirac phase is associated with the U_{e3} element (in direct analogy with the CKM choice where the FX phase resides in V_{us} ). Writing the FX parameterization schematically as U_{\rm PMNS}^{\rm(FX)}=\begin{aligned} &R_{12}^{T}(\theta_{\ell})\,P_{\phi}\,R_{23}(\theta)\,R_{12}(\theta_{\nu}),\\ &P_{\phi}\equiv\mathrm{diag}(1,\,e^{i\phi_{\rm FX}},\,1).\end{aligned} (6) one sees explicitly that the leptonic Jarlskog invariant Jarlskog takes the form J_{\rm CP}=s_{\ell}c_{\ell}\,s_{\nu}c_{\nu}\,s^{2}c\,\sin\phi_{\rm FX}, (7) Relation to the Particle Data Group (PDG) phase PDG2024 . Because the Jarlskog invariant is basis independent, one may equate the FX and PDG forms, J_{\rm CP}^{\rm(FX)}=J_{\rm CP}^{\rm(PDG)}, (8) where in the PDG convention J_{\rm CP}^{\rm(PDG)}=s_{12}c_{12}\,s_{23}c_{23}\,s_{13}c_{13}^{2}\,\sin\delta_{\rm PDG}. (9) Hence s_{\ell}c_{\ell}\,s_{\nu}c_{\nu}\,s^{2}c\,\sin\phi_{\rm FX}=s_{12}c_{12}\,s_{23}c_{23}\,s_{13}c_{13}^{2}\,\sin\delta_{\rm PDG}. (10) The invariant physical quantity is J_{\rm CP} ; the parameter phases \phi_{\rm FX} and \delta_{\rm PDG} coincide only when the angle definitions match exactly. Diagonalization Given a Yukawa matrix Y , biunitary diagonalization yields U_{L}^{\dagger}\,Y\,U_{R}=Y^{\rm diag}. (11) Remark. While only the left-handed rotation matrices U_{L} enter directly into the observable PMNS matrix, the right-handed matrices U_{R} and their associated angles contribute to the diagonalization of the Yukawa operator and therefore enter the physical charged-lepton mass eigenvalues. In hierarchical B -lattice textures the scaling of m_{\ell} depends on the combined left- and right-handed exponents, even though U_{R} drops out of the low-energy mixing matrix. Illustrative 2\times 2 example. To see how the additive charge rule translates into mixing angles, consider a 2\times 2 charged-lepton sub-block with lattice exponents, p\;=\;\begin{pmatrix}p_{L_{1}}+p_{R_{1}}&p_{L_{1}}+p_{R_{2}}\\ p_{L_{2}}+p_{R_{1}}&p_{L_{2}}+p_{R_{2}}\end{pmatrix}, (12) Y\sim\begin{pmatrix}B^{-p_{11}/9}&B^{-p_{12}/9}\\ B^{-p_{21}/9}&B^{-p_{22}/9}\end{pmatrix}. (13) If p_{22}<p_{12} and p_{22}<p_{21} , the dominant entry is Y_{22} and the left- and right-handed mixing angles obtained by biunitary diagonalization scale as \displaystyle\theta_{12}^{L} \displaystyle\sim\frac{Y_{12}}{Y_{22}}\sim B^{-(p_{12}-p_{22})/9}, (14) \displaystyle\theta_{12}^{R} \displaystyle\sim\frac{Y_{21}}{Y_{22}}\sim B^{-(p_{21}-p_{22})/9}. Thus the same additive rule that fixes the diagonal suppressions (and hence mass ratios) automatically controls the rotation angles, with generally distinct left- and right-handed hierarchies when p_{12}\neq p_{21} . The observable mixing from this block is governed by the column suppression (left rotation), and in general \theta_{ij}^{L}\sim B^{-(p_{ij}-p_{jj})/9}, (15) ensuring that off-diagonal elements are suppressed relative to diagonal entries. Large leptonic mixing emerges when the neutrino sector provides comparable rotations that interfere with the small charged-lepton rotations. Tribimaximal limit The FX parameterization makes the role of the charged-lepton rotation \theta_{\ell} especially transparent. Setting \theta_{\ell}=0 (i.e. switching off charged-lepton mixing) gives U_{e3}=-s_{\ell}\,e^{i\phi_{\rm FX}}\sin\theta=0 , and the PMNS matrix reduces to U_{\rm PMNS}^{(\theta_{\ell}=0)}=\begin{pmatrix}c_{\nu}&s_{\nu}&0\\[4.0pt] -e^{i\phi}\,c\,s_{\nu}&e^{i\phi}\,c\,c_{\nu}&e^{i\phi}\,s\\[4.0pt] s\,s_{\nu}&-s\,c_{\nu}&c\end{pmatrix}, (16) where c\equiv\cos\theta , s\equiv\sin\theta , and the shorthand c_{\nu},s_{\nu} stands for \cos\theta_{\nu},\sin\theta_{\nu} . Substituting the tribimaximal (TBM) values HarrisonPerkinsScott \theta_{\nu}=\arctan(1/\!\sqrt{2})\approx 35.26^{\circ} and \theta=\pi/4 reproduces the familiar TBM pattern |U_{\rm TBM}|=\begin{pmatrix}\sqrt{2/3}&1/\sqrt{3}&0\\[3.0pt] 1/\sqrt{6}&1/\sqrt{3}&1/\sqrt{2}\\[3.0pt] 1/\sqrt{6}&1/\sqrt{3}&1/\sqrt{2}\end{pmatrix}. (17) In this limit the phase \phi_{\rm FX} is unobservable: it multiplies the entire second row and can be absorbed by a muon-field redefinition, giving J_{\rm CP}=s_{\ell}c_{\ell}\cdots\sin\phi_{\rm FX}=0 . Three consequences are immediate: (i) exact TBM resides entirely in U_{\nu} , parameterized by (\theta_{\nu},\theta) alone; (ii) all departures from TBM—nonzero \theta_{13} , atmospheric octant displacement, and the Dirac CP phase—switch on together when \theta_{\ell}\neq 0 ; (iii) since the B -lattice fixes \theta_{\ell}\sim\epsilon\approx 0.19 through the charged-lepton hierarchy,