Reply to the comment on “Instability of the ferromagnetic quantum critical point and symmetry of the ferromagnetic ground state in 2D and 3D electron gases with arbitrary spin-orbit splitting”
Dmitry Miserev, 1∗ Daniel Loss, 1 and Jelena Klinovaja 1 · 2026
Read Reply to the comment on “Instability of the ferromagnetic quantum critical point and symmetry of the ferromagnetic ground state in 2D and 3D electron gases with arbitrary spin-orbit splitting” by Dmitry Miserev, 1∗ Daniel Loss, 1 and Jelena Klinovaja 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-06825.txt.
Introduction
Miserev and colleagues reply to a comment by Belitz and Kirkpatrick on their article about instability in ferromagnetic quantum criticality. The original article treats ground-state symmetry in electron gases in two and three dimensions with varied spin-orbit splitting. A reply of this kind answers points raised by critics and states where the authors stand on disputed claims. Readers tracking the debate should read the reply alongside the comment and the original article to see where agreement ends and dispute remains.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dmitry Miserev, 1∗ Daniel Loss, 1 and Jelena Klinovaja 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 12598 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.06825
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reply to the comment on “Instability of the ferromagnetic quantum critical point and symmetry of the ferromagnetic ground state in 2D and 3D electron gases with arbitrary spin-orbit splitting” Dmitry Miserev, 1∗ Daniel Loss, 1 and Jelena Klinovaja 1 Abstract We reply on the comment of D. Belitz and T. R. Kirkpatrick on our article “Instability of the ferromagnetic quantum critical point and symmetry of the ferromagnetic ground state in 2D and 3D electron gases with arbitrary spin-orbit splitting”. They correctly pointed out that non-analyticities in the thermodynamic potential of 2D and 3D Fermi liquids that originate from the backscattering processes are suppressed by the square of the Cooper logarithm. This suppression is not so important in 2D Fermi liquids where the non-analyticity is cubic and, therefore, is much more relevant than the quartic Ginzburg-Landau term. However, the Cooper renormalization in 3D Fermi liquids renders marginally relevant quartic non-analyticity to marginally irrelevant one. We argue that the leading Ω ∝ B 4 ln ( E F / B ) \Omega\propto B^{4}\ln(E_{F}/B) form of the 3D non-analyticity in the thermodynamic potential Ω \Omega as a function of Zeeman field B B survives due to contribution coming from the arbitrary-angle scattering that is not subject to the Cooper renormalization. In perturbation theory, such correction first emerges in third order in interaction, as was identified by Maslov and Chubukov [Phys. Rev. B 79 , 075112 (2009)]. However, the sign of this third-order correction is positive, which contradicts to the physical argument on the sign of non-analytic corrections presented by D. Belitz and T. R. Kirkpatrick. Maslov and Chubukov argued that overall sign of the non-analytic correction is inconclusive, and strongly depends on the angular structure of the Landau scattering amplitude in the regime when interaction is no longer weak, this is also the regime where ferromagnetic quantum phase transition is expected. They also showed that the non-analyticity remains marginally relevant in the vicinity of 3D ferromagnetic quantum critical point, Ω ∝ − B 4 ln ln ( E F / B ) \Omega\propto-B^{4}\ln\ln(E_{F}/B) . Though this non-analyticity can formally destabilize the T = 0 T=0 ferromagnetic quantum critical point, it becomes irrelevant at any experimentally achievable temperatures. We appreciate the comment of D. Belitz and T. R. Kirkpatrick on our article “Instability of the ferromagnetic quantum critical point and symmetry of the ferromagnetic ground state in 2D and 3D electron gases with arbitrary spin-orbit splitting” Miserev et al. 2022 . Our main result that is represented by our Eqs. (38), (44), (48), corresponds to the non-analytic correction to the thermodynamic potential \Omega calculated for a short-range interaction with the matrix element u within second order perturbation theory in u for the case of a Fermi surface that is split by an arbitrary spin-orbit interaction and a finite Zeeman field. The novelty of our result is in the explicit form of the angular-dependent form-factors enveloping the non-analytic contributions. The drawback of the perturbative approach we used is missing renormalizations of the Cooper amplitude due to higher order terms in u . At zero Zeeman field B=0 and finite spin-orbit interaction, there is one remaining zero-momentum Cooper channel that respects time reversal symmetry and therefore is unaffected by the spin-orbit splitting of the Fermi surface: the corresponding interaction matrix element is given by the scattering of a spin-singlet pair of electrons with momenta \bm{k}_{+},-\bm{k}_{+} into the spin-singlet pair with momenta -\bm{k}_{-},\bm{k}_{-} , where k_{\pm}=|\bm{k}_{\pm}| are the Fermi momenta of the spin-split Fermi surface, and \bm{k}_{+} is parallel to \bm{k}_{-} . Other backscattering channels are suppressed as they are set off resonance due to the momentum mismatch \propto\beta_{\mathrm{SO}} between the scattered pairs, where \beta_{\mathrm{SO}} is the spin-orbit splitting (in order to calculate the contribution of these channels to the spin susceptibility at B=0 , an infinitesimal Zeeman field has to be included in calculations of \Omega to enable spin-flip transitions). A small but finite Zeeman field B breaks time reversal symmetry by boosting a finite momentum mismatch \propto B between the spin-singlet pairs, a mechanism similar to the one that destroys conventional superconductivity. However, in the limit B\to 0 the logarithmic Cooper renormalizations of the time-reversal-invariant amplitude, u_{\mathrm{C}} , at zero temperature T=0 , is suppressed by a large logarithm, \displaystyle u_{\mathrm{C}}=\frac{u}{1+u\ln(E_{F}/B)}\to\frac{1}{\ln(E_{F}/B)}\,, (1) where E_{F} is the Fermi energy, B the absolute value of the Zeeman field, u>0 is the bare matrix element of the backscattering interaction in the zero-momentum spin-singlet channel. This renormalization is precisely what was pointed out by D. Belitz and T. R. Kirkpatrick in their comment, and we fully agree with them on this matter. The effects of such Cooper renormalizations given by Eq. ( 1 ) are well-known and have been broadly studied in the context of non-analytic corrections to \Omega for 2D and 3D Fermi liquids. For example, extensive non-perturbative treatment of corrections non-analytic in temperature T to the heat capacity of interacting spin-degenerate Fermi liquids results in a very similar non-analyticity of \Omega as a function of T yielding the non-analytic corrections to the heat capacity, see Eq. (7.37a) for 2D, and Eq. (7.37b) for 3D Fermi liquids in Ref. Aleiner and Efetov 2006 . Corrections originating from the Cooper channel are suppressed by the logarithm squared [denoted by \mathcal{X}(T) ] compared to the perturbative result (see Eqs. (7.29a), (7.29b) in Aleiner and Efetov 2006 ). The T dependence of the spin susceptibility at B=0 originates from the spin-singlet Cooper channel exclusively, and is given by Es. (7.42) for 2D, and Eq. (7.43) for 3D Fermi liquids in Ref. Schwiete and Efetov 2006 in the limit T\to 0 , yet again demonstrating \propto 1/\ln^{2}(E_{F}/T) suppression compared to the perturbative result given by Eqs. (7.40), (7.41). The B -dependence of the spin susceptibility at T=0 originating from the backscattering processes suffers similar suppression by 1/\ln^{2}(E_{F}/B) . However, such logarithmic suppressions are not essential for studying two-dimensional (2D) quantum phase transitions as the B^{3} non-analyticity, even scaled down by \propto 1/\ln^{2}(E_{F}/B) , still represents the leading non-analyticity that is more relevant than the analytic \propto B^{4} term in \Omega(B) . In particular, Eq. (44) in our work Miserev et al. 2022 still represents the relevant non-analyticity in the 2D thermodynamic potential, though each term in Eq. (44) should be scaled down by the square of the Cooper logarithm with the appropriate argument. In particular, the \propto B^{3} non-analyticity is scaled down to \propto B^{3}/\ln^{2}(E_{F}/\mathrm{max}[B,T]) at exponentially small B and T satisfying u\ln(E_{F}/\mathrm{max}[B,T])\gg 1 . However, such exponentially small values of B and T might not even be relevant for studying 2D ferromagnetic quantum phase transitions unless the scale B_{0} at which the non-analytic correction in \Omega is balanced by the Ginzburg-Landau \propto B^{4} term is also exponentially small. For this reason, the Cooper renormalization of the cubic non-analyticity cannot stabilize the 2D ferromagnetic quantum critical point (QCP). The Cooper renormalization is much more serious for 3D metals, where the leading non-analyticity in \Omega scales down from the marginally relevant \propto B^{4}\ln(E_{F}/B) (perturbative result) to marginally irrelevant \propto B^{4}/\ln(E_{F}/B) (renormalized non-analyticity) which qualitatively changes the role of such non-analyticity: indeed, at B\to 0 the \propto B^{4}/\ln(E_{F}/B) non-analyticity is negligible compared to the Ginzburg-Landau \propto B^{4} term. D.