A Comprehensive Analysis of the Effects of Network Quality of Service on Robotic Telesurgery

Zhaomeng Zhang, Seyed Hamid Reza Roodabeh, Homa Alemzadeh · 2026

Read A Comprehensive Analysis of the Effects of Network Quality of Service on Robotic Telesurgery by Zhaomeng Zhang, Seyed Hamid Reza Roodabeh, Homa Alemzadeh (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-06824.txt.

Introduction

Zhang and colleagues study how network quality affects long-distance robotic telesurgery. Reliable networks matter, yet real degradation effects on task performance remain poorly understood. They introduce NetFI, a fault injection tool that mimics packet loss, delay, and communication loss with random models built from real network data. With a surgery sim, NetFI supports a user study: volunteers at three skill levels do a standard Peg Transfer task under varied settings. Analysis links network trouble to task scores, motion steps, and felt workload, flagging specific steps vulnerable to trouble.

Catalog record

CREATORZhaomeng Zhang, Seyed Hamid Reza Roodabeh, Homa Alemzadeh
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38207
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.06824

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Comprehensive Analysis of the Effects of Network Quality of Service on Robotic Telesurgery Zhaomeng Zhang, Seyed Hamid Reza Roodabeh, Homa Alemzadeh Abstract The viability of long-distance telesurgery hinges on reliable network Quality of Service (QoS), yet the impact of realistic network degradations on task performance is not sufficiently understood. This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of how packet loss, delay, and communication loss affect telesurgical task execution. We introduce NetFI, a novel fault injection tool that emulates different network conditions using stochastic QoS models informed by real-world network data. By integrating NetFI with a surgical simulation platform, we conduct a user study involving 15 participants at three proficiency levels, performing a standardized Peg Transfer task under varying levels of packet loss, delay, and communication loss. We analyze the effect of network QoS on overall task performance and the fine-grained motion primitives (MPs) using objective performance and safety metrics and subjective operator’s perception of workload. We identify specific MPs vulnerable to network degradation and find strong correlations between proficiency, objective performance, and subjective workload. These findings offer quantitative insights into the operational boundaries of telesurgery. Our open-source tools and annotated dataset provide a foundation for developing robust and network-aware control and mitigation strategies. I INTRODUCTION Robotic Assisted Minimally Invasive Surgery (RAMIS) has seen widespread clinical adoption, exemplified by the da Vinci surgical system, which has been used in over 17 million procedures worldwide [ 19 ] . These systems enhance surgeon dexterity and visual feedback, thereby improving patient outcomes, accelerating recovery, and reducing complications. Conventionally, the master tool manipulators (MTMs) and patient-side manipulators (PSMs) are co-located in the operating room, linked by a wired connection to ensure robust, low-latency data transmission. However, the emergence of high-bandwidth, low-latency 5G/6G networks is overcoming this limitation, enabling the paradigm of long-distance telesurgery [ 10 ] . Telesurgery could reduce the need for physical presence while increasing the flexibility of surgical resources in extreme or high-risk environments, such as rural areas, battlefields [ 12 ] , deep sea [ 9 ] , and outer space [ 34 ] . Although several long-distance (up to 1000km) procedures have been successfully conducted in the past [ 26 ] , challenges related to network communication stability remain a major barrier to the wide adoption of robotic telesurgery [ 3 ] . Network Quality of Service (QoS) degradations such as delay, packet loss, and communication loss can significantly impact surgeons’ intra-operative decisions and performance, potentially leading to unsafe situations and medical complications. Several studies have examined the impact of varying types and degrees of degradations on the feasibility and user performance in surgical teleoperation [ 40 ] . These studies indicate that while some surgeons consider network latencies below 200ms to be acceptable [ 28 ] , latencies as low as 50ms [ 3 ] to 135ms [ 23 ] can still hinder telesurgery performance. Moreover, a 2000km teleoperation study showed that packet losses of 3% to 7% under 150 Mbps communication bandwidth can result in corrupted image frames, distracting operators and affecting their performance [ 11 ] . Furthermore, simulated robots and environments are used in place of physical hardware to emulate QoS degradations, mitigating risks to expensive surgical robots and equipment while enabling flexible task and scenario design [ 42 , 20 , 33 ] . QoS degradation has also been studied in digital twin architectures [ 20 , 13 , 5 , 39 ] and cloud robotics [ 7 ] to support intent recognition, autonomy, and fault-tolerance for mitigating adverse events. To our knowledge, no prior work has investigated QoS degradation effects using both objective and subjective performance and safety metrics with realistic, model-based emulation of real-world network conditions across severity levels, from near-ideal to intermediate and severe scenarios, which arise in settings like battlefields or remote rural areas. Moreover, no prior work has quantified these effects at the subtask level. Decomposing complex operations into fundamental motion primitives (MPs) [ 32 , 18 ] provides a generalizable framework for more granular analysis, such as examining the effects of degradations on intricate tool-tissue interactions, development of targeted mitigation strategies, and fine-grained skill assessment. Fig. 1 : System Architecture of our telesurgical simulation setup with model-based network QoS emulation: the block diagram illustrates the data flow between the surgeon side console, the patient side robot simulator, and the network QoS emulator. To address these gaps, we perform a comprehensive analysis of the effects of QoS degradations on task performance, safety, and user experience. Our contributions are as follows: • Introducing a novel model-based Network Fault Injection tool (NetFI) that emulates the effect of communication loss, packet loss, and delay based on realistic models and data from 4G/5G networks, that can be easily integrated into any teleoperation system to simulate diverse network QoS conditions by modifying the stochastic models and their parameters. • Conducting a comprehensive user study involving 15 participants at three proficiency levels, performing a standard Fundamentals of Laparoscopic Surgery (FLS) [ 36 ] Peg Transfer task under different network conditions, using an open-source telesurgical simulation system which integrates a state-of-the-art surgical robot simulator (SurRoL [ 41 ] ) with a surgeon console (dVTrainer, Mimic Technologies) and mechanisms for real-time logging of kinematic, video, and foot pedal data for performance evaluation. This study resulted in a multi-modal dataset with MP and error labels of 180 Peg Transfer trials. • Providing new insights into the effects of different QoS degradation scenarios on user performance and operation safety , at both the task and MP levels , for different user proficiency levels and user experience. II BACKGROUND AND RELATED WORK II-A Networks in Robotic Telesurgery Safe and reliable long-distance telesurgery demands stringent network performance [ 35 ] , motivating numerous studies on how degradations affect operator performance and experience. Nankaku et al. [ 28 ] showed that delays \leq 100ms generally preserve performance, with experienced surgeons maintaining proficiency even at longer delays. Anvari et al. [ 1 ] reported that latencies > 300ms significantly increase task completion times and error rates. Feasibility of teleoperation has also been studied with challenging infrastructures such as satellite links in remote or extreme environments [ 14 ] and battlefields [ 2 ] . Simulation-based works have further complemented these findings. Xu et al. [ 42 ] examined the effects of latency on surgical performance using the dV-Trainer. Ouda et al. [ 33 ] demonstrated that packet loss substantially increases task completion time and error rates, and degrades video quality. Ishida et al. [ 20 ] analyzed user responses to randomized communication losses of 0-3s using the AMBF simulator [ 27 ] , but their study did not investigate the impact of comprehensive network degradation on granular action-level performance in dual-arm FLS tasks. We advance the state-of-the-art in this area through a comprehensive evaluation of performance, safety, and user experience across different network degradation scenarios. Our approach integrates realistic 4G/5G-informed QoS models, diverse error and failure types, performance metrics at the subtask level, and a comparative analysis across three user proficiency levels. II-B Peg Transfer and Motion Primitives The FLS Peg Transfer (PT) evaluates bimanual dexterity, hand–eye coordination, and depth perception. This task involves transferring six pegs across a pegboard using two graspers.

Read the complete text